Pick a Letter (14 in) Topic

Simple theme: Every player on your roster must have their first name start with the same letter. Pick A for homers galore with Aaron Judge and Alex Rodriguez. Pick T to drive opposing catchers crazy with Tim Raines and Ty Cobb stealing bases. Etc. etc. This is Season 2 for this league. We did last names for Season 1, so we'll switch it up with first names for Season 2.

The only team that can have more than one letter is if you go with the Lesser-Used Letters, for which you can pick any player whose first name starts with I, O, Q, U, V, X, and Y.

$100 million cap. NO AAA, WW, DH, clones, trades, or injuries. Pick any ballpark you like.

Sign up here and reserve your letter. Only four owners can use the same letter, so the letter will be capped after that. Owners are encouraged to take multiple teams, though those teams can't have the same letter.

If you need help sifting through players, you can visit https://www.baseball-reference.com/players/, and click on the last name of your choice to see all options.

League number to follow if there's enough interest. Thanks!
2/24/2026 4:12 PM
Possible Letters + Number of Teams Reserved:
A:
B: 2 (tgrun, mjkrunner)
C: 1 (scjensen51)
D: 2 (Oldtimer, jtvaughey)
E:
F:
G: 1 (jfranco77)
H:
I, O, Q, U, V, X, and Y: 1 (masterdebate)
J: 3 (d_rock97, boddicker, pick1or2)
K:
L:
M: 1 (mjoyce103)
N:
P:
R:
S:
T:
W: 1 (PirateSteve)
Z:
In, letter TBD: 2 (82689, c08jt)
2/27/2026 9:54 PM (edited)
C
2/24/2026 7:18 PM
Welcome scjensen51!
2/24/2026 11:04 PM
I'll come back. Give me a G this time around.
2/26/2026 10:06 AM
I'll take M.
2/26/2026 3:29 PM
Welcome both! We're more than halfway there
2/26/2026 5:07 PM
ill take W
2/27/2026 3:43 PM
Welcome, Steve!
2/27/2026 9:54 PM
Pick a Letter (14 in) Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.