The Boxes: Modern v Classic ($120M) Topic

esplanade
Posts: 3696 (4)
Hall of Famer
76
Prospect

We're back with two box sets: Modern vs Classic.

Pick on set and select only one player from each box. You can use ANY season of that player. $120M No DH, AAA, WW, trades or clones. Injuries on. Standard WIS Format. The Modern League must use ballparks from 1956-2026. The Classic League must use ballparks from 1885-1955.

The deadline for getting your rosters entered will be set for two (2) full calendar days after the final owner joins, so please only sign up if you’re sure you’ll be able to meet that deadline. After the deadline, the league will be filled based on whoever can enter a valid WIS team into the league first.


Please sign up in this thread.


I will declare after we're half full and provide league # at that time.

CLASSIC (NL) MODERN (AL)
1 JNavies
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
9/15/2026 8:38 PM (edited)
esplanade
Posts: 3696 (4)
Hall of Famer
76
Prospect
MODERN BOX SET
A B C D E
Vada Pinson Wade Davis Trevor Bauer Steve Sax Tim Raines
Rich Gossage Rafael Betancourt Richie Ashburn Spencer Strider Roger Clemens
Luis Arraez Norm Cash Mookie Betts Nick Anderson Larry Walker
Jose Leclerc Joe Horlen Jose Altuve John Tudor Keith Hernandez
Gary Sheffield Edgar Renteria Jake Arrieta Eric Gagne Evan Phillips
Dinelson Lamet Dave Righetti Chris Sale Charlie Blackmon Chipper Jones
Anthony Rendon Alan Trammell Adrian Beltre Bobby Murcer Barry Bonds
F G H I J
Xander Bogaerts Wade Boggs Tony Gonsolin Tony Gwynn Zack Greinke
Randy Johnson Placido Polanco Shane Bieber Ronnie Belliard Ron Guidry
Nolan Ryan Mike Scott Neifi Perez Luis Aparicio Luis Tiant
Jason Schmidt Jay Lopez Kevin Brown Joe Mauer Jose Fernandez
Frank Robinson Freddy Sanchez Hank Aaron Harvey Kuenn Grant Balfour
Dee Gordon Derek Jeter Devin Williams Cisco Carlos Christian Yelich
Albert Pujols Casey Sadler Billy Williams Buster Posey Aaron Judge
K L M N O
Todd Helton Trevor Hoffman Terry Pendleton Troy Percival Willie Wilson
Sandy Koufax Sergio Romo Pedro Martinez Rod Carew Paul O'Neill
Matt Harvey Miguel Cabrera Michael Conforto Mike Adams Magglio Ordonez
Kenta Maeda Joe Nathan Julio Franco Joaquin Benoit Jeff Bagwell
Greg Maddux Ellis Burks Felipe Alou George Brett Dwight Gooden
Craig Kimbrel Dean Chance Dick Groat Don Mattingly Chad Green
Bill Freehan Carl Yastrzemski Alex Rodriguez Bob Gibson B.J. Ryan
P Q R S T
Willie McGee Ted Simmons Will Clark Trea Turner Victor Gonzalez
Pete Runnels Rob Murphy Roberto Clemente Ryan Helsley Rafael Soriano
Kirby Yates Mike Piazza Mickey Mantle Mariano Rivera Matty Alou
John Olerud Jake McGee Joe Torre Ketel Marte Jonathan Lucroy
Hong-Chih Kuo Emmanuel Clase J.R. Richard Ichiro Suzuki Ivan Rodriguez
Chris Martin Cla Meredith DJ LeMahieu David Fletcher Dave Smith
Brooks Robinson Billy Wagner Bo Bichette Bryce Harper Bobby Witt Jr
U V W X Y
Takashi Saito Steve Karsay Tony Oliva Vida Blue Yandy Diaz
Ronald Acuna Jr. Ryan Braun Pete Rose Pablo Sandoval Sean Doolittle
Norm Charlton Matt Carpenter Lou Piniella Mark Loretta Kirby Puckett
Joe Morgan Justin Verlander Jonathan Papelbon Jason Kendall Johan Santana
Freddie Freeman Hanley Ramirez Jacob deGrom Don Sutton Elston Howard
Craig Biggio Corbin Burnes Dennis Eckersley Dave Anderson Clayton Kershaw
Carlos Gonzalez Albert Belle Andrew Miller Al Kaline Carney Lansford
9/15/2026 8:27 PM (edited)
esplanade
Posts: 3696 (4)
Hall of Famer
76
Prospect
CLASSIC BOX SET
A B C D E
Babe Herman Alvin Dark Bill Bradley Bobby Wallace Billy Herman
Claude Hendrix Cy Young Chuck Klein Buck Ewing Chick Robitaille
George Shoch Earl Averill Eddie Cicotte Ed Reulbach George Stone
Harry Krause Jack Hallett Harry Steinfeldt Honus Wagner Harry Coveleski
Johnny Miljus Louis Leroy Jesse Burkett Lave Cross Lady Baldwin
Mike Donlin Patsy Dougherty Riggs Stephenson Rogers Hornsby Roger Connor
Ty Cobb Willie Mays Yogi Berra Stan Musial Tony Lazzeri
F G H I J
Al Grabowski Arky Vaughan Bill Terry Bill Sweeney Addie Joss
Cy Falkenburg Dan Brouthers Buck O'Brien Casey Hageman Charlie Smith
Ed Delahanty Eddie Collins Ed Walsh George Sisler George McQuillan
Jackie Robinson Jack Quinn Hal Newhouser Jack Glasscock Harry Lord
Johnny Rigney Johnny Niggeling John Shaffer Joe Medwick John Weyhing
Nick Maddox Nap Lajoie Mort Cooper Red Ruffing Red Schoendienst
Whit Wyatt Roy Mitchell Tip O'Neill Sam Thompson Zack Wheat
K L M N O
Billy Hamilton (88-01) Bill Bartley Bob Elliott Babe Ruth Al Mamaux
Carl Hubbell Buddy Myer Dizzy Dean Chicken Wolf Doc White
Frank Baker Ernie Lombardi Frank Chance Elton Chamberlain George Dumont
Harry Brecheen Hughie Jennings Harry Heilmann Jack O'Connor Jack Pfiester
John Ward Lou Gehrig King Kelly Johnny Evers Luke Appling
Pete Alexander Orlie Weaver Mordecai Brown Mickey Cochrane Roy Campanella
Tommy Holmes Sam Crawford Warren Spahn Steve O'Neill Tris Speaker
P Q R S T
Al Rosen Bob Steele Al Simmons Bill Dickey Babe Adams
Dave Orr Christy Mathewson Chief Bender Carl Weilman Cy Seymour
Ginger Beaumont Eddie Plank Frank Arellanes Gaavy Cravath Frank Dwyer
Hooks Wiltse Jake Northrop Hugh Duffy Hank Severeid Heinie Groh
Joe Jackson Lefty O'Doul Jimmie Foxx Joe Gordon Joe Dimaggio
Roger Bresnahan Ray Chapman Mickey Vernon Orval Overall Oscar Tuero
Spud Chandler Tim McCabe Ted Williams Sherry Magee Stan Hack
U V W X Y
Bobby Veach Boom-Boom Beck Bill George Art Devlin Adonis Terry
Charlie Gehringer Carmen Hill Dazzy Vance Dolf Luque Cap Anson
Dutch Leonard (13-25) Frank Snyder Geroge Kell Freddy Lindstrom Hal Haid
Jack Coombs Harry Danning Heine Manush Jake Daubert Howie Pollet
Johnny Pesky Joe Wood Jesse Tannehill Mellie Wolfgang Lou Boudreau
Pete Reiser Phil Cavarretta Nellie Fox Paul Waner Ray Caldwell
Sadie McMahon Willie Keeler Walter Johnson Willie Ramsdell Russ Ford
9/15/2026 8:23 PM (edited)
esplanade
Posts: 3696 (4)
Hall of Famer
76
Prospect
Jnavies picks Modern
9/15/2026 8:38 PM
totalpkg504
Posts: 34 (1)
Hall of Famer
141 3 85 63 43
Prospect
I will take modern.
9/15/2026 9:35 PM
The Boxes: Modern v Classic ($120M) Topic
△Top△Bottom

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.