OK, I read that because you're new. Otherwise, it's too long.
I'm rather blunt. I don't have the time nor the inclination to beat around the bush. I'm that way in the real world(personally but not in business because you have to step around people's feelings to maintain a working relationship). It carries over into the internet world. So, yes, had you said that "to my face", I'd have said "Seriously? That's illogical and stupid." Some people respect that, some people think I'm an *******. I can live with either.
As for respect, don't wait for it on the internet. However, it can be earned. It is not given.
As for your "point", it wasn't thought out. I called you on it. It's been made many times and, every time, someone has pointed out the flaws. In the future, if you want to be "respected", examine the possible flaws in your idea before posting. Otherwise, it will be mocked. And some won't be as nice as I am about it.