Posted by cccp1014 on 5/8/2018 12:06:00 PM (view original):
#1) Both my parents are Jewish and his are not
#2) He celebrates nothing of the traditions and does not see himself as a Jew
#3) You cannot be a Christian and a Jew at the same time
#4) I am a Jew for all the traditions I just don't believe in the higher power. He actually chose a different religion. More specifically I don't believe in the higher power or that Jesus was the Messiah. He believes Jesus was the Messiah so he cannot be a Jew.
#5) He is anti Israel and I am pro Israel
You disagree with me but to me he is as Jewish as Bill Cosby. AKA he is not.
But he played that card to fit his warped narrative.
1. Doesn't matter. According to the Jewish religion, if your mother was Jewish, you are Jewish
2. Obviously he does see himself as a Jew since has repeatedly said he is Jewish. YOU are the one who does not see him as a Jew.
3. If you can be an agnostic and a Jew at the same time, there's no reason you can't be Christian and Jewish at the same time.
5. Well, he says he is not anti Israel. Also, one does not have to be pro Israel to be Jewish.
Personally, I don't care if he identifies himself as Jewish, Christian or a Druid. Its his business and not mine...or yours. I also don't care if you identify yourself as Jewish, agnostic or a Satanist. None of my business.