The other factor worth considering, though, is that Southern California in general is a pretty fertile area for D3 recruiting. Most of the Upstate competes with the SUNY, the CUNY, the Empire 8, and some other schools as well for the handful of decent recruits in NY. NY is a terrible place to have to do D3 recruiting.
And PA is almost as bad. And 3 of my 4 teams are in one or the other of those states... All of which are more successful than my school in the far more fertile Carolinas region. But I still stand by the conviction that NY is a terrible place to recruit in D3.