Midge 52 XCV rosters and commentary Topic

Posted by copernicus on 4/23/2026 12:49:00 PM (view original):
love this! do it even if rift wants to do evals? the more the merrier!
I probably will, I just didn't want to step on any toes OR discourage rift from writing evals if he wanted to.
4/23/2026 12:55 PM
Who would have thought bill russell was third best player in the draft, he was edged out by the second best player, Deandre Jordan.
4/23/2026 1:05 PM
Posted by oddson on 4/23/2026 1:05:00 PM (view original):
Who would have thought bill russell was third best player in the draft, he was edged out by the second best player, Deandre Jordan.
Keep in mind the scores factor in minutes played too. Per minute wise Russell has only the 15th highest score among big men (PFs and Cs). Also, when I look at the scores I don't like to compare players to other players regardless of position, I compare them to other players who will play their position. So For example, Lebron's per minute score (Dork score) is 23.07, while Russell is 23.57. Does that mean draft Russell over Lebron? Of course not. I prefer to compare players to others who will play their position in the Sim. As I mentioned Russell is 15th among big men, but Lebron? He is number 1 among guards in the sim (PG/SG). He is has +2.14 points over the next guard (which is Luka per minute btw).
4/23/2026 1:16 PM
Here what I think of ARC

Looking back Haliburton & Jrue could have been my backcourt with DRob
That would have been sweet! Oh well went with 75-76 Dr. J SF
51.6 efg% @ 29U% at bit too low. but solid everywhere else 100 D.
25-26 Jamal Murray adv% have some Steph vibes but fall short w/ 43D & 48.3 FG%
his 563 3FGA is curryesk TO% is very low & 57.3 efg% is good w/ 28U%. Plus
I can play him at 1 or 2 w/ Tyreke.
17-18 Tyreke Evans with back up both Murray at 1 or 2 and will also sub in
for Dr. J at 3 when needed. Good versatilty but 52.3 efg% is below average in this
league. 28 U% matches both DrJ & Jamal.
23-24 Caruso & 93-94 McMillan will fill out backcourt. both lo U% & 90D+ will
help cover Jamal weakness. Bogut & Hartensein tandem Robinson. lo U% w/ 60+ efg%
and good creb with both. Feeling good about front court.
Robinson Caruso should be in playoff race. 25-26 Murray is a question mark and
we'll see how he shares the ball with The Good Doctor. Like I said a Holiday/Haliburton backcourt
was there for the taking in this draft and I missed them and maybe any chance for a chip.
"It's So Easy To Slip"
GL and so many well built teams!
4/25/2026 9:47 PM (edited)
This is great. Sorry, but I just don't have time to do evals.
4/26/2026 9:56 PM
Reminder of what these scores DON'T factor:
  • If your team meets the minimum usage points and has optimal cumulative usage

  • If your team has the minimum amount of assist% as a team on the floor at a time not to be penalized

  • Blocks. This is mainly for 2 reasons. 1. I have determined how much weight to give it. And. 2. Even if I do add it to the formula it won’t have much weight. I have noticed that Def rating matters much more to lowering an opponent's FG% than Blk%, and a blocked shot does not automatically mean a changed possession, unlike a steal or a rebound.

    Also, these scores aren't perfect, I am sure I have different factors that could be weighed differently to make this formula more accurately measure a teams likelihood of success but I think they do a decent job. If your total Dork score is high and you don't have usage or assist% issues, then your team is likely to be good.

4/27/2026 12:55 PM

52 Draft York Scores. (Some math on the previous scores were corrected.)


24kpyrite

66-67 Wilt Chamberlain: 29.30

86-87 Kevin McHale: 12.96

18-19 Paul George: 10.87

03-04 Donyell Marshall: 10.76

25-26 Justin Champagnie: 5.18

85-86 Isiah Thomas: 2.93

23-24 Terry Rozier: 2.18

17-18 Cheick Diallo: 2.17

21-22 Bismack Biyombo: 1.72

22-23 Kris Dunn: 1.56

05-06 Antoine Wright: -0.77

99-00 Eric Montross: -0.77

Total= 78.09



Dlsmooth74

12-13 LeBron James: 16.86

22-23 Nic Claxton: 12.31

80-81 Robert Parish: 8.97

23-24 Daniel Gafford: 8.87

17-18 Victor Oladipo: 7.65

13-14 Terrence Jones: 7.39

16-17 Pau Gasol: 6.51

19-20 Khris Middleton: 4.99

18-19 Boban Marjanovic: 2.82

95-96 Chris Gatling: 2.00

89-90 Micheal Williams: 0.27

62-63 Howie Jolliff: -0.53

Total=78.11



Midge

Nikola Jokic- 16.25

Tim Duncan- 13.87

Shawn Marion- 13.07

Jimmy Butler- 9.29

Otto Porter- 7.91

Mark Williams- 5.59

Andrew Bynum- 4.93

Keon Ellis- 4.81

Jameer Nelson- 2.46

Jae Crowder- 2

Kai Jones- 1.33

Tosan Evboumwan- 0.67

Total=82.18



Oddson

Bill Russell- 19.79

Tyson Chandler- 14.97

Stephen Curry- 12.95

James Harden- 10.5

Richaun Holmes- 7.78

Anderson Varejao- 4.02

Day’Ron Sharpe-3.86

David West- 3.37

Isaiah Jackson- 3.26

Charlie Ward- 1.93

Rodrigue Beaubois- 1.14

Darius Garland- 1.14

Total= 84.71



Uptowngbv

Giannis Antetokounmpo- 13.66

Marcus Camby- 11.84

John Stockton- 11.42

Emeka Okafor- 10.24

Jayson Tatum- 9.19

Christian Wood- 9.14

Larry Sanders- 7.4

Cedric Ceballos- 5.17

Andrew Bynum- 4.93

Isaiah Jackson- 1.39

Kai Jones- 1.33

Isaac Jones- 0.83

Total= 86.54



PBandJ

Bill Walton- 11.9

Shai Gilgeous Alexander- 10.54

Joel Embiid- 10.5

Joakim Noah- 9.02

Steven Adams- 8.08

Precious Achiuwa- 6.1

Obi Toppin- 4.89

Ja Morant- 4.83

John Henson- 4.05

Collin Murray-Boyles- 3.86

Charles Bassey- 1.99

Josh Hart- 1.05

Total= 76.81



JJMurphy1127

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar- 16.01

Dwyane Wade- 10.8

Chet Holgren- 9.98

Myles Turner- 6.69

Ryan Kalkbrenner- 6.69

Brandan Wright- 6.1

Brandon Clarke- 5.65

Tyus Jones- 5.29

Jonathan Isaac- 4.97

Paul Reed-4.69

Jaylin Williams- 3.6

Robert Covington-2.28

Total= 82.75



Copernicus

Rudy Gobert- 18.5

Karl Anthony-Towns- 12.46

Jason Kidd- 11.13

Amare Stoudemire- 9.66

Aaron Gordan- 7.68

Montrezl Harrell- 7.1

CJ McCollum- 5.69

Collin Murray-Boyles- 3.86

Isaiah Jackson- 1.39

Dewayne Dedmon- 1.24

Jeremy Evans- 1.15

Bones Hyland- 0.35

Total= 80.21



HDS1

Andre Drummond- 14.24

Victor Wembanyama- 12.15

Walker Kessler- 10.16

Scottie Barnes- 9.53

Michael Porter-9.17

Tyler Herro- 7.39

Mike Conley- 6.4

JaVale McGee- 5.42

Adem Bona- 3.47

Isaiah Jackson- 3.27

Greg Oden- 2.23

Rajon Rondo- 1.09

Total= 84.52



Gerryred

Dikembe Mutombo- 15.34

Evan Mobley- 11.8

Bam Adebayo- 11.25

Michael Jordan- 10.99

Brent Barry- 9.49

Kenneth Faried- 8.08

Jalen Williams- 6.36

Isaiah Jackson- 2.03

Jordan Bell- 1.08

Jim Cleamons- 0.62

KJ Simpson- 0.03

Mike Evans- -0.56

Total= 75.96



Berkelon

Hakeem Olajuwon- 14.6

Nikola Vucevic- 11.91

Chris Paul- 11.58

Magic Johnson- 11.45

Chris Andersen- 8.22

Kevin Love- 6.7

Bobby Portis- 6.35

Enes Kanter- 5.14

Moses Brown- 4.7

Tosan Evbuomwan- 0.67

Sam Merrill- 0.3

DeAndre Liggins- 0.11

Total= 81.73



Amerk1180

Anthony Davis- 15.33

Donovan Clingan- 11.5

Scottie Pippen- 10.33

Derrick Favors- 8.84

Eric Bledsoe- 7.11

Donovan Mitchell- 6.26

Nate McMillan- 5.36

Marvin Bagley- 4.93

Collin Murray-Boyles- 3.86

Scotty Pippen- 1.12

Geroge T Johnson- 0.96

Total= 78.76



Chewy3344

Dwight Howard-18.51

Bobby Jones- 10.37

Jonas Valanciunas- 9.96

Tyrese Haliburton- 9.55

Bob Lanier- 7.82

John Collins- 7.64

Kevon Looney- 6.32

Trayce Jackson-Davis- 5.87

Renaldo Balkman- 3.63

George Hill- 2.93

Alize Johnson- 1.23

Ja Morant- 0.72

Total=84.54



Samuelyork93

Ben Wallace- 17.88

Luka Doncic-12.92

Elton Brand- 12.31

Jarrett Allen- 12.14

Mason Plumlee- 9.85

Amen Thompson- 8.87

Andrei Kirilenko- 5.73

LaMelo Ball- 2.54

Brandan Wright- 1.67

Tristan Vukcevic- 1.65

Ekpe Udoh- 1.55

Ron Harper- 0.49

Total= 87.61



Seapilots

David Robinson- 15.79

Julius Erivng- 12.17

Andre Bogut- 7.62

Jamal Murray- 7.27

Isaiah Hartenstein- 6.57

Alex Caruso- 5.67

Nate McMillan- 5.36

Tyreke Evans- 4.12

Marcin Gortat- 3.07

Roy Tarpley- 2.52

Collin Sexton- 1.03

Jusuf Nurkic- 0.6

Total= 71.79



dh555 -

Shaquille O’Neal- 16.32

Horace Grant- 12.92

Kel’el Ware- 9.27

Chauncey Billups- 9.18

Mitchell Robinson- 7.87

Klay Thompson- 5.89

Cade Cunningham- 5.89

Isaiah Jackson- 3.27

Patrick Ewing- 2.84

Brandan Wright- 1.68

Josh Minott- 1.08

Total= 80.97



Cem6989

Moses Malone- 19.27

Oscar Robertson- 11.49

Alonzo Mourning- 10.79

Moussa Diabate- 8.74

Sandro Mamukelashili- 5.65

Enes Kanter-5.14

Andre Iguodala- 4.88

Nicolas Batum- 4.73

Isaiah Jackson- 3.26

Nerlens Noel- 2.05

John Konchar- 1.56

Total= 80.15



Riftonapple

Shawn Kemp- 11.48

Larry Nance- 11.18

Jalen Duren- 10.6

Jakob Poeltl- 8.72

Jrue Holiday- 7.21

Anthony Edwards- 6.28

Ausar Thompson- 6.28

Kyle O’Quinn- 4.42

Dereck Lively- 3.62

Ty Jerome- 3.57

Kevin Porter- 1.71

Cameron Johnson

Total= 76.31



Dakjd901

Dennis Rodman- 20.99

Clint Capela- 14.11

Serge Ibaka-9.71

Kyrie Irving- 6.68

Goga Bitadze- 6.65

Thaddeus Young- 5.92

Desmond Bane- 5.32

Tyus Jones- 5.29

Cedric Maxwell- 4.12

Cole Aldrich- 3.2

Jordan McLaughlin- 2.08

Isaiah Jackson- 1.65

Total= 85.73



Lukemikk

Larry Bird- 11.78

Kawhi Leonard- 10.85

Robert Williams- 9.49

Jakob Poeltl- 8.56

Neemias Queta- 8.48

Zion Williamson- 8.18

Derrick White- 6.9

Kyle O’Quinn- 4.42

Mo Bamba- 3.87

Lonzo Ball- 3.4

Kevin Porter- 1.71

Oscar Tshiebwe- 1.37

Total= 79.01



Steelers821

Ivica Zubac- 15.95

Kevin Durant- 12.11

Domantas Sabonis- 12.03

Anfernee Hardaway- 10.14

Chris Boucher- 7.63

Jaren Jackson Jr- 6.56

Kristaps Porzingas- 6.48

Donte DiVincenzo- 3.6

Moses Brown- 1.89

Alize Johnson- 1.22

Javonte Green- 1.19

Tony Massenburg

Total= 79.89





Jethroeg

Hassan Whiteside- 14.01

Draymond Green- 12.32

Kevin Garnett- 11.52

Ben Simmons- 10.63

Jarred Vanderbilt- 7.54

Tyrese Maxey- 6.94

Delon Wright- 6.43

Pascal Siakim- 5.83

Charles Bassey- 0.86

Calvin Booth- 0.16

Tree Rollins- 0.1

Lindsey Hunter- -0.12

Total= 76.2



Longtallbrad

DeAndre Jordan- 22.19

Karl Malone- 15.08

Jalen Johnson- 9.79

Manu Ginobili- 7.19

Danny Green- 6.81

Andrew Bynum- 4.93

Clyde Drexler- 4.31

JaMychal Green- 3.97

TJ McConnell- 3.64

DeMarcus Cousins- 2.12

Jeremy Lin- 1.85

Carl Landry- 0.16

Total= 82.04



Kammeyer

Buck Williams- 13.73

Charles Barkley- 13.69

Artis Gilmore- 12.79

Damian Lillard- 7.87

Steve Nash- 7.54

Zach Lavine- 5.47

Al Horford- 3.39

Jakob Poeltl- 3.64

Larry Nance Jr- 2.12

Tony Bradley- 1.52

Alize Johnson- 1.23

Jannero Pargo- 0.43

Total= 73.14

4/27/2026 3:31 PM (edited)
82.18! That’s right *******!
4/27/2026 6:44 PM
I’m truly impressed by J.J. Murphys Dork score of 1127.
4/27/2026 6:46 PM
◂ Prev 12
Midge 52 XCV rosters and commentary Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.