Franchise Draft 4.0 Draft Topic

My understanding of the "mulligan" is that you can repick your last pick, not trade it.. Last season I had a combined player and when I changed him to a partial player their salary went down. So I went to my last pick and replaced them with a more expensive player that would fit me under the cap.

The interesting thing this season is that there is a good chance my #24 round pick will not be my last pick and that could be a bad break finishing up my team.
2/11/2026 4:46 PM (edited)
chewy3344 (2)

Rd 20 White Sox Alejandro De Aza
2/11/2026 4:39 PM
Posted by YOGI256 on 2/11/2026 4:46:00 PM (view original):
My understanding of the "mulligan" is that you can repick your last pick, not trade it.. Last season I had a combined player and when I changed him to a partial player their salary went down. So I went to my last pick and replaced them with a more expensive player that would fit me under the cap.

The interesting thing this season is that there is a good chance my #24 round pick will not be my last pick and that could be a bad break finishing up my team.
Man sorry but I am really confused now. In other words I can't replace one and only one of my # 6 or # 13 or 19 round picks (examples) if I need to as long as that franchise has gone through with every owner getting a chance at a player with that franchise? All 24 (25) picks for that franchise has been chosen??
2/11/2026 4:47 PM
Posted by pick1or2 on 2/11/2026 4:47:00 PM (view original):
Posted by YOGI256 on 2/11/2026 4:46:00 PM (view original):
My understanding of the "mulligan" is that you can repick your last pick, not trade it.. Last season I had a combined player and when I changed him to a partial player their salary went down. So I went to my last pick and replaced them with a more expensive player that would fit me under the cap.

The interesting thing this season is that there is a good chance my #24 round pick will not be my last pick and that could be a bad break finishing up my team.
Man sorry but I am really confused now. In other words I can't replace one and only one of my # 6 or # 13 or 19 round picks (examples) if I need to as long as that franchise has gone through with every owner getting a chance at a player with that franchise? All 24 (25) picks for that franchise has been chosen??
You can't replace the player, but many of the players people have drafted have many different versions. For example, it seems likely I will be using versions of Kirby Puckett & Steve Carlton which are not what I would call the "best" versions. So long as it was a full/partial (not combined) season for the club you picked them under, it's fine.

Exchanging out a player before round 24 is a problem because everyone picking after you was denied that player as an option.
2/11/2026 5:05 PM
pick1or2 (1) Round 20 Milw Brewers Pete Ladd RP
2/11/2026 5:22 PM
Cleve 18th Rd
Victor Martinez
2/11/2026 5:45 PM
Round 20
Cal/Ana/LA Angels - Erick Aybar

Round 23
San Diego Padres - Craig Shipley

Roster

Rd 1 Red Sox - Pedro Martinez SP1
Rd 1 Red Sox - Wade Boggs 3B
Rd 2 Reds - Pete Rose OF
Rd 3 Dodgers - Don Sutton SP2
Rd 4 A's - Dennis Eckersley Closer
Rd 5 Mets - Matt Harvey SP3
Rd 6 Tigers - Victor Martinez DH
Rd 7 Cubs Bruce - Sutter SU1
Rd 8 Nats/Expos - Alex Escobar - BuOF
Rd 9 Phillies - Jonathan Papelbon SU2
Rd 10 Orioles - Javy Lopez C
Rd 11 Brewers - Paul Mirabella LR
Rd 12 Indians - Trevor Bauer SP4
Rd 13 Twins - Brian Dozier 2B
Rd 14 Pirates - Zane Smith SP6
Rd 15 Astros - Bob Knepper SP5
Rd 16
Rd 17 White Sox - Danny Mendrick BuMIF
Rd18 Cardinals - Jason Motte SU3
Rd 19 Giants - Will Clark 1B
Rd 20 Angels - Erick Aybar SS
Rd 21
Rd 22
Rd 23 Padres - Craig Shipley BUSS
Rd 24
2/11/2026 8:29 PM (edited)
RE-PICK Padres - Craig Shipley
2/11/2026 6:34 PM
Rd 22 Phillies

Todd Pratt
2/11/2026 6:44 PM
Round 21, Angels: Bobby Rose
2/11/2026 6:45 PM
chewy3344

Rd 20 Tigers Willi Castro
Rd 21 Brewers Jonathan Lucroy
2/11/2026 8:16 PM
pick1or2 (1) Round 19 Cleveland Josh Donaldson 3B
Dang I did it again I picked Donaldson for the wrong team thinking I need a 3B but I don't
CAN I WITHDRAW MY PLAYER AND REPICK? NO HAS POSTED SINCE I MADE THIS MISTAKE
IF NOT I WILL BITE THE BULLET AND STAY WITH MY PICK STUPID ME
2/11/2026 9:27 PM (edited)
Posted by pick1or2 on 2/11/2026 9:27:00 PM (view original):
pick1or2 (1) Round 19 Cleveland Josh Donaldson 3B
Dang I did it again I picked Donaldson for the wrong team thinking I need a 3B but I don't
CAN I WITHDRAW MY PLAYER AND REPICK? NO HAS POSTED SINCE I MADE THIS MISTAKE
IF NOT I WILL BITE THE BULLET AND STAY WITH MY PICK STUPID ME
Yeah go for it. I am up next. SM me when you repick.
2/11/2026 9:30 PM
THANKS GIVE ME 10 MINUTES trying to run two teams and trying to not hold anybody up my bad
2/11/2026 9:33 PM
pick1or2 (1) Round 19 Cleveland ANTHONY REYES
thanks for understanding !!!!
2/11/2026 9:40 PM (edited)
◂ Prev 1...26|27|28|29|30...39 Next ▸
Franchise Draft 4.0 Draft Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.