I think the issue is more of regeneration. In real life, players play JUCO near the university they want to attend so when you sign an ineligible he shouldn't be sent across the country to play JC ball.
In Knight I signed a 4-star center from Los Angeles while at Fresno St., he went JUCO in Iowa, not something reasonable like NV, AZ, UT or even CO but went 1800 miles away. I obviously lost him the next recruiting period. These scenarios are plain wrong and make no sense.