I am going to get crushed, but I want to represent my school, so here's my team:
Cornell University (15), Ithaca College (5), and Bucknell University (24)
We would do better in hockey, but it is what it is. With Christy Mathewson and Billy Rhines from Bucknell, we can pitch anyway.
One question: why no AAA?? There are loads of players listed from all schools who didn't get to the majors, and it would be nice to include them. Cornell's best player ever was probably Frank Olin, who played in 1884-85 while he was still in college. He hit .312 in 1884, but didn't qualify in '85, so he turned in his glove and made his fortune as an engineer, ultimately donating enough money to build the engineering building on campus, Olin Hall.
I'd love to use him as an AAA player, plus I need some PA at 2B. My offense sucks!