This post could not be converted. To view the original post's thread, click here.

Yeah- except I doubt anyone would have picked Ben Petrick...
But if someone DID want Ben Petrick- speak up now ! He's yours! :-))

Either that or staidmans picks should stand. I dont think its fair to make him available to anyone who hasn't picked yet just because someone posted him who may or may not be a replacement in the league.

I really don't care. I picked after Tulowitski, and don't want him, nor Petrick. I am very happy to get Galarraga at the end of the round (speaking of surprises)

Noon- (Cincinnati Reds) George Foster- OF

So Either

A) you kicked ailse5 out of the league and replaced him with staindman and he has joined the league and his picks stand.

B)someone not a member of this league (standman) picks stand but ailse5 still runs the team

C) standman was never part of this league and his picks are null and void and whoever hasn't picked yet has a crack at one of the best SS

D) standman's picks are void when ailse5 returned and then the next person who posted after standmans void pick would get to draft based on who was then since I obviously was hoping he would drop.

DUDE-- we're talking about Ben Petrick here. Ben Petrick would be the extra guy. Don't think that would affect anyone.
dms3 was the next one to post a pick & he wanted Tulowitzki. Let's move on.
I'm off today and outside of running out for an hour-- I'll be around to update today's picks.

The only round logically up for debate is the Rockies round, since that pick was made more or less on time. The other three picks staindman made, and then were remade by aisle5, were in rounds that had already been completed. If anyone had wanted any of those three players, they could have drafted them.

Since dms posted at his time to draft that he would have taken Tulo, dms should get him. The only problem there is if more than one owner wants Ben Petrick, and really, what are the odds of that?

Quote: Originally Posted By staindman on 12/20/2009Minnesota Twins - P- Steve Lombardozzi
Baltimore Orioles - P-Jim Poole
New York Giants - OF- Spider Jorgensen
Colorado Rockies- SS-Troy Tulowitzki

My vote is for these picks to stand.. I dont think its fair to allow picks to be changed...

Update is in progress. Since aisle5 gave me no update, staindman's picks stand. You can have your team back aisle5 or not. If you don't agree with that, then staindman can take over your team. The picks stand.