FINAL STANDINGS

The following owners/teams get to participate in round 3 due to contrarian23 opting out of round 3.
njbigwig (Indians)
emanes10 (White Sox)
emanes10 (Phillies) & mars2010 (Phillies) - result of playoff game no longer matters
joerat1 (Giants)
njbigwig (Athletics)
barracuda3 (Cubs) - pedrocerrano already has 8 teams

The following teams get in due to footballmm11 and I each having more than 8 qualifying teams.
toysboys for schwarze (Braves)
3dayrotatiojn for schwarze (Dodgers)
chewy3344 for footballmm11 (Pirates)
bigsteve12 for schwarze (Cardinals)
ejstockman for football11mm (Red Sox)
barracuda3 for schwarze (Reds)
farleyfustle for footballmm11 (Athletics)
joerat1 for footballmm11 (Cubs)

The standings below have already factored this in.
2/26/2025 7:13 PM
These are the 96 owners/teams that advance to Round 3. Blue represents those moving up due to contrarian23's opting out. Green represents the teams getting in only because me and FBM having more than 8 qualifying teams.
.
Rank Owner Franchise Season Pick-Lg Pick-Fr W-L Exp W% Playoff Rd 3
--------- ------------------- ------------------- ---------- --------- --------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ----------
1 schwarze Cubs 1912 1 1 109-53 0.711 1 1
2 pedrocerrano Pirates 1914 1 1 104-58 0.628 1 1
3 footballmm11 Tigers 1925 15 8 104-58 0.610 1 1
4 crazyamos Indians 1919 2 1 101-61 0.590 1 1
5 Bill_James47 Dodgers 2015 13 6 99-63 0.608 1 1
6 ronthegenius Phillies 1980 6 4 99-63 0.590 1 1
7 footballmm11 Braves 2010 5 4 98-64 0.615 1 1
9 footballmm11 Reds 1987 7 3 98-64 0.597 1 1
10 pedrocerrano White Sox 1920 2 1 97-65 0.587 1 1
11 pedrocerrano Red Sox 1907 3 1 97-65 0.583 1 1
12 jfranco77 Yankees 2007 1 1 97-65 0.550 1 1
13 barracuda3 Yankees 1938 6 2 96-66 0.633 1 1
14 schwarze Athletics 1913 16 10 96-66 0.599 1 1
15 calhoop Cubs 1920 20 11 96-66 0.564 1 1
16 pedrocerrano Giants 1921 3 2 95-67 0.590 1 1
17 ronthegenius Pirates 1909 2 2 95-67 0.583 1 1
19 schwarze Pirates 1902 7 4 94-68 0.609 0 1
20 redcped Dodgers 2023 18 10 94-68 0.591 1 1
21 footballmm11 Cardinals 2004 1 1 94-68 0.580 1 1
22 footballmm11 Phillies 1984 12 8 94-68 0.557 1 1
23 footballmm11 Dodgers 2018 6 3 93-69 0.627 0 1
24 84champs Reds 1963 13 8 92-70 0.577 1 1
25 barracuda3 Phillies 1978 22 11 92-70 0.560 0 1
26 danidon Indians 1914 23 12 92-70 0.558 1 1
27 footballmm11 Orioles 1999 3 1 92-70 0.555 1 1
27 cstrohmier Orioles 1972 4 2 92-70 0.555 1 1
29 toysboys White Sox 1914 15 8 92-70 0.540 1 1
30 schwarze Twins 1921 5 4 92-70 0.538 1 1
31 schwarze Giants 1907 2 1 91-71 0.584 1 1
32 redcped Orioles 1974 10 4 91-71 0.568 1 1
33 footballmm11 White Sox 1995 9 5 91-71 0.566 1 1
34 barracuda3 Pirates 1916 11 6 91-71 0.521 0 1
35 kstober Pirates 1921 20 10 91-71 0.503 1 1
36 emanes10 Yankees 2003 14 9 90-72 0.559 1 1
37 schwarze Orioles 1975 18 9 90-72 0.533 0 1
38 schwarze Indians 1907 11 5 89-73 0.558 0 1
39 ejstockman Reds 1918 6 2 89-73 0.547 1 1
40 firesalt Braves 2021 4 3 89-73 0.541 1 1
43 Jtpsops White Sox 1908 21 10 88-74 0.533 1 1
44 schwarze Tigers 1909 13 7 88-74 0.527 1 1
45 ronthegenius Braves 1913 17 9 88-74 0.524 1 1
46 bigsteve12 Reds 1976 9 5 88-74 0.521 0 1
47 nocomm999 Dodgers 1962 10 5 88-74 0.512 1 1
48 pedrocerrano Indians 1913 4 2 87-75 0.579 0 1
49 pedrocerrano Braves 1993 1 1 87-75 0.567 1 1
50 Jtpsops Tigers 1946 3 1 87-75 0.545 1 1
50 barracuda3 Dodgers 2017 2 2 87-75 0.545 0 1
52 harrelson Red Sox 1918 11 6 87-75 0.540 1 1
54 redcped Twins 2004 1 1 87-75 0.526 1 1
55 njbigwig Indians 1908 18 9 87-75 0.509 0 1
56 ronthegenius Reds 1924 8 4 86-76 0.557 1 1
57 kstober Twins 1917 20 9 86-76 0.531 0.5 1
58 nocomm999 Twins 1909 17 6 86-76 0.528 0.5 1
59 crazyamos White Sox 1934 14 7 86-76 0.526 0 1
60 chewy3344 Giants 1923 24 12 86-76 0.520 1 1
62 emanes10 White Sox 2021 7 4 86-76 0.495 0 1
63 3dayrotation Braves 2011 21 11 85-77 0.534 0 1
64 thejuice6 Tigers 1908 19 9 85-77 0.531 0 1
65 chewy3344 Cardinals 2006 5 3 85-77 0.516 1 1
66 Jtpsops Red Sox 1919 4 2 84-78 0.557 1 1
67 barracuda3 Tigers 2007 7 3 84-78 0.542 1 1
70 calhoop Athletics 1988 10 5 84-78 0.527 1 1
70 3dayrotation Orioles 1996 19 10 84-78 0.527 0 1
72 pedrocerrano Twins 1930 4 3 84-78 0.525 1 1
73 crazyamos Yankees 1937 8 4 84-78 0.507 0 1
76 gworear Cardinals 1950 7 5 83-79 0.534 0 1
77 Bill_James47 Athletics 1910 5 2 83-79 0.532 0 1
78 kstober Tigers 2015 9 5 83-79 0.522 0 1
79 calhoop Yankees 2019 7 3 83-79 0.517 0 1
82 kstober Orioles 1908 13 5 83-79 0.491 1 1
83 kstober Cardinals 1921 9 6 83-79 0.483 1 1
85 calhoop Twins 1912 2 2 82-80 0.555 0 1
87 redcped Yankees 1922 9 5 82-80 0.528 1 1
88 Relkcirts Indians 1952 15 7 82-80 0.514 1 1
89 kstober Giants 1918 17 8 82-80 0.511 0 1
90 kstober Red Sox 1971 5 3 82-80 0.503 0 1
93 pedrocerrano Phillies 1910 8 6 82-80 0.472 0 1
94 bigsteve12 Red Sox 2005 22 10 82-80 0.406 0 1
95 emanes10 Phillies 2014 20 10 81-81 0.544 0.5 1
97 calhoop Cardinals 1934 6 4 81-81 0.513 0 1
100 mars2010 Phillies 2021 24 12 81-81 0.487 0.5 1
101 joerat1 Giants 1922 5 4 81-81 0.482 0 1
116 ronthegenius Cubs 1944 13 7 79-83 0.478 0 1
119 glowguy Athletics 1932 22 11 79-83 0.473 0.5 1
121 danidon Cubs 2006 6 3 78-84 0.530 0 1
123 njbigwig Athletics 1914 6 3 78-84 0.487 0 1
131 barracuda3 Cubs 2016 3 2 76-86 0.487 0 1
139 DarthDurron Giants 1961 21 9 76-86 0.458 1 1
--------- ------------------- ------------------- ---------- --------- --------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ----------
81 toysboys Braves 1994 12 6 83-79 0.499 0 1
91 3dayrotation Dodgers 1959 1 1 82-80 0.488 0 1
96 chewy3344 Pirates 1924 17 7 81-81 0.517 0 1
102 bigsteve12 Cardinals 1988 24 12 81-81 0.469 0 1
104 ejstockman Red Sox 1916 9 5 80-82 0.524 0 1
106 barracuda3 Reds 1991 10 6 80-82 0.493 0 1
125 farleyfustle Athletics 1971 12 6 78-84 0.458 0 1
137 joerat1 Cubs 1918 17 8 76-86 0.466 0 1
2/26/2025 7:18 PM
These are the remaining teams. These 96 teams are not advancing.
.
Rank Owner Franchise Season Pick-Lg Pick-Fr W-L Exp W% Playoff Rd 3
--------- ------------------- ------------------- ---------- --------- --------- ----------- ----------- ---------- ----------
8 contrarian23 Athletics 1911 4 1 98-64 0.602 1 1
18 contrarian23 Indians 1904 10 4 95-67 0.555 1 1
41 footballmm11 Red Sox 2007 23 11 89-73 0.538 1 1
42 footballmm11 Cubs 1987 8 4 88-74 0.579 1 1
53 contrarian23 White Sox 1912 4 2 87-75 0.535 0 1
61 contrarian23 Phillies 1966 17 9 86-76 0.508 1 1
68 schwarze Cardinals 1982 22 11 84-78 0.537 1 1
69 schwarze Braves 1911 2 2 84-78 0.530 0 1
75 contrarian23 Giants 1929 12 5 83-79 0.545 0 1
80 schwarze Reds 1923 21 12 83-79 0.506 0 1
84 contrarian23 Cubs 1932 18 9 83-79 0.476 1 1
105 footballmm11 Pirates 1989 3 3 80-82 0.523 1 1
112 schwarze Dodgers 1941 19 11 79-83 0.502 1 1
115 footballmm11 Athletics 1969 15 9 79-83 0.486 0.5 1
74 contrarian23 Braves 1973 11 5 84-78 0.477 0 0
86 footballmm11 Yankees 1929 13 8 82-80 0.535 0 0
92 chewy3344 Tigers 1919 10 6 82-80 0.487 0 0
98 gworear Braves 2024 14 7 81-81 0.509 0 0
99 happyhours Orioles 1988 21 11 81-81 0.501 0 0
103 Jtpsops Giants 1909 15 6 81-81 0.458 0 0
107 PrimeTimeTW White Sox 1960 16 9 80-82 0.491 0 0
108 Jtpsops Twins 1929 23 11 80-82 0.481 0 0
109 glowguy Tigers 1912 22 11 80-82 0.476 0 0
110 3dayrotation Twins 2010 18 7 80-82 0.458 0 0
111 mllama54 Tigers 1922 23 12 80-82 0.453 0 0
113 schwarze Phillies 1912 2 2 79-83 0.499 0 0
114 emanes10 Indians 1948 16 8 79-83 0.494 0 0
117 Jtpsops Cardinals 1925 20 10 79-83 0.477 0 0
118 schwarze Yankees 1966 19 11 79-83 0.474 0 0
120 toysboys Yankees 1999 10 6 79-83 0.462 0 0
122 chewy3344 Reds 1922 14 9 78-84 0.519 0 0
124 toysboys Cardinals 1942 3 2 78-84 0.468 0 0
126 chewy3344 Red Sox 1996 20 9 77-85 0.491 0 0
127 SteveIzzy Reds 1940 11 7 77-85 0.479 0 0
128 chewy3344 Phillies 2005 7 5 77-85 0.478 0 0
129 nocomm999 Phillies 1908 11 7 77-85 0.467 0 0
130 nocomm999 White Sox 1907 22 11 76-86 0.512 0 0
132 pedrocerrano Cubs 1931 24 12 76-86 0.486 0 0
133 84champs Red Sox 1976 24 12 76-86 0.481 0 0
134 3dayrotation Cardinals 1969 17 9 76-86 0.478 0 0
135 Taxman2008 Yankees 1921 11 7 76-86 0.473 0 0
136 mllama54 Orioles 1922 15 7 76-86 0.471 0 0
138 mllama54 Athletics 1926 8 4 76-86 0.464 0 0
140 footballmm11 Twins 2023 19 8 75-87 0.491 0 0
141 DarthDurron Dodgers 1968 16 8 75-87 0.487 0 0
142 SteveIzzy Athletics 1925 23 12 75-87 0.474 0 0
143 njbigwig Red Sox 1951 12 7 75-87 0.465 0 0
144 footballmm11 Giants 2001 4 3 75-87 0.440 0 0
144 DarthDurron Phillies 1994 5 3 75-87 0.440 0 0
146 danidon Reds 1927 16 11 75-87 0.438 0 0
147 pedrocerrano Athletics 1973 13 7 74-88 0.481 0 0
148 jfranco77 Twins 1943 12 5 74-88 0.477 0 0
149 toysboys Twins 1971 22 10 74-88 0.452 0 0
150 3dayrotation Yankees 1925 20 12 74-88 0.444 0 0
151 Jtpsops Braves 2022 24 12 74-88 0.439 0 0
152 spinaldog Pirates 1987 19 9 74-88 0.432 0 0
153 bigsteve12 Giants 2014 23 11 73-89 0.464 0 0
154 Bill_James47 Tigers 1988 8 4 73-89 0.460 0 0
155 Taxman2008 Red Sox 1988 15 8 73-89 0.447 0 0
156 calhoop Dodgers 1958 17 9 73-89 0.438 0 0
157 jfranco77 Indians 2000 12 6 73-89 0.424 0 0
158 mllama54 Cardinals 1964 13 7 72-90 0.462 0 0
159 glowguy Reds 1919 3 1 72-90 0.457 0 0
160 danidon Yankees 1927 18 10 72-90 0.422 0 0
161 ff09 Athletics 1986 14 8 72-90 0.416 0 0
162 thejuice6 Cubs 1905 10 5 72-90 0.387 0 0
163 firesalt Orioles 1921 14 6 71-91 0.478 0 0
164 contrarian23 Pirates 1975 24 12 71-91 0.455 0 0
165 kstober Dodgers 1943 21 12 70-92 0.469 0 0
166 Taxman2008 Cubs 1904 12 6 70-92 0.436 0 0
167 schwarze White Sox 1962 11 6 70-92 0.402 0 0
168 ejstockman Orioles 1907 16 8 69-93 0.455 0 0
169 schwarze Red Sox 1910 8 4 69-93 0.448 0 0
170 Jtpsops Orioles 2010 9 3 69-93 0.434 0 0
171 DarthDurron Cardinals 2009 14 8 69-93 0.416 0 0
172 calhoop Braves 1915 16 8 68-94 0.480 0 0
173 emanes10 Pirates 1938 21 11 68-94 0.442 0 0
174 kstober White Sox 1905 5 3 68-94 0.428 0 0
175 je3rd Giants 1904 22 10 68-94 0.421 0 0
175 glowguy Dodgers 1916 7 4 68-94 0.421 0 0
177 footballmm11 Indians 1998 8 3 67-95 0.475 0 0
178 chewy3344 Cubs 1971 19 10 67-95 0.401 0 0
179 DarthDurron Twins 1966 24 12 66-96 0.404 0 0
180 calhoop Phillies 2012 1 1 65-97 0.487 0 0
181 ybjsports Pirates 1939 18 8 65-97 0.443 0 0
182 contrarian23 Dodgers 1932 14 7 65-97 0.389 0 0
183 je3rd Indians 1906 21 11 64-98 0.401 0 0
184 SteveIzzy Indians 2017 19 10 63-99 0.387 0 0
185 SteveIzzy Tigers 1961 6 2 61-101 0.423 0 0
186 contrarian23 Reds 1933 15 10 60-102 0.367 0 0
187 SAKABAKBRG Giants 2006 16 7 59-103 0.409 0 0
188 joerat1 Braves 1970 18 10 59-103 0.404 0 0
189 Jtpsops Pirates 1933 9 5 58-104 0.372 0 0
190 fatboydad54 Orioles 1959 23 12 58-104 0.353 0 0
191 pedrocerrano Tigers 1934 20 10 57-105 0.362 0 0
192 DarthDurron White Sox 1974 23 12 53-109 0.378 0 0
2/26/2025 7:25 PM (edited)
Here is a summary of teams advancing by owner.
.
Owner Teams Rd 3
--------------------- ---------- ----------
footballmm11 16 8
schwarze 16 8
pedrocerrano 11 8
kstober 9 7
barracuda3 7 7
calhoop 8 5
ronthegenius 5 5
redcped 4 4
Jtpsops 9 3
chewy3344 8 3
3dayrotation 6 3
emanes10 5 3
bigsteve12 4 3
crazyamos 3 3
toysboys 5 2
nocomm999 4 2
danidon 4 2
Bill_James47 3 2
njbigwig 3 2
ejstockman 3 2
joerat1 3 2
DarthDurron 6 1
glowguy 4 1
jfranco77 3 1
84champs 2 1
gworear 2 1
firesalt 2 1
thejuice6 2 1
cstrohmier 1 1
harrelson 1 1
Relkcirts 1 1
mars2010 1 1
farleyfustle 1 1
2/26/2025 7:28 PM
Time to post some other fun stats...
2/27/2025 4:03 PM
Best records that failed to make the playoffs. barracuda3 and I have 6 of the top 11 teams.
.
Owner Franchise Season W-L
------------------- ------------------- ---------- -----------
schwarze Pirates 1902 94-68
footballmm11 Dodgers 2018 93-69
barracuda3 Phillies 1978 92-70
barracuda3 Pirates 1916 91-71
schwarze Orioles 1975 90-72
schwarze Indians 1907 89-73
bigsteve12 Reds 1976 88-74
pedrocerrano Indians 1913 87-75
barracuda3 Dodgers 2017 87-75
njbigwig Indians 1908 87-75
contrarian23 White Sox 1912 87-75
2/27/2025 4:04 PM
Best winning% in 1-run games. Note my Cubs were the only team (in the top 10) to have a better record in 2+ run games than 1-run games.
.
Owner Franchise Season 1-Run 1-R W% 2+Run 2+R W% Diff
------------------- ------------------- ---------- ---------- --------- --------- --------- ---------
mars2010 Phillies 2021 24-9 0.727 57-72 0.442 -0.285
njbigwig Indians 1908 21-10 0.677 66-65 0.504 -0.174
kstober Pirates 1921 30-15 0.667 61-56 0.521 -0.145
joerat1 Giants 1922 37-19 0.661 44-62 0.415 -0.246
schwarze Cubs 1912 33-17 0.660 76-36 0.679 0.019
cstrohmier Orioles 1972 33-17 0.660 59-53 0.527 -0.133
Bill_James47 Dodgers 2015 27-15 0.643 72-48 0.600 -0.043
jfranco77 Yankees 2007 25-14 0.641 72-51 0.585 -0.056
emanes10 White Sox 2021 32-18 0.640 54-58 0.482 -0.158
84champs Reds 1963 19-11 0.633 73-59 0.553 -0.080
2/27/2025 4:09 PM
Worse teams in 1-run games...
.
Owner Franchise Season 1-Run 1-R W% 2+Run 2+R W% Diff
------------------- ------------------- ---------- ---------- --------- --------- --------- ---------
calhoop Phillies 2012 8-28 0.222 57-69 0.452 0.230
joerat1 Braves 1970 10-28 0.263 49-75 0.395 0.132
barracuda3 Yankees 1938 8-18 0.308 88-48 0.647 0.339
pedrocerrano Indians 1913 12-26 0.316 75-49 0.605 0.289
nocomm999 White Sox 1907 14-30 0.318 62-56 0.525 0.207
DarthDurron White Sox 1974 19-37 0.339 34-72 0.321 -0.019
ejstockman Orioles 1907 15-28 0.349 54-65 0.454 0.105
barracuda3 Tigers 2007 14-26 0.350 70-52 0.574 0.224
firesalt Orioles 1921 15-27 0.357 56-64 0.467 0.110
footballmm11 Indians 1998 14-23 0.378 53-72 0.424 0.046
2/27/2025 4:10 PM
Using ExpWin% as a proxy for "Power Rating", these were the 20 best teams from Round 2.
.
Rank Owner Franchise Season Pick-Lg Pick-Fr W-L Exp W%
--------- ------------------- ------------------- ---------- --------- --------- ----------- -----------
1 schwarze Cubs 1912 1 1 109-53 0.711
13 barracuda3 Yankees 1938 6 2 96-66 0.633
2 pedrocerrano Pirates 1914 1 1 104-58 0.628
23 footballmm11 Dodgers 2018 6 3 93-69 0.627
7 footballmm11 Braves 2010 5 4 98-64 0.615
3 footballmm11 Tigers 1925 15 8 104-58 0.610
19 schwarze Pirates 1902 7 4 94-68 0.609
5 Bill_James47 Dodgers 2015 13 6 99-63 0.608
8 contrarian23 Athletics 1911 4 1 98-64 0.602
14 schwarze Athletics 1913 16 10 96-66 0.599
9 footballmm11 Reds 1987 7 3 98-64 0.597
20 redcped Dodgers 2023 18 10 94-68 0.591
4 crazyamos Indians 1919 2 1 101-61 0.590
16 pedrocerrano Giants 1921 3 2 95-67 0.590
6 ronthegenius Phillies 1980 6 4 99-63 0.590
10 pedrocerrano White Sox 1920 2 1 97-65 0.587
31 schwarze Giants 1907 2 1 91-71 0.584
17 ronthegenius Pirates 1909 2 2 95-67 0.583
11 pedrocerrano Red Sox 1907 3 1 97-65 0.583
21 footballmm11 Cardinals 2004 1 1 94-68 0.580
2/27/2025 4:17 PM
These are the worst teams (based on winning%) to make the playoffs. (In case of a 1-game playoff, I included both teams since I am posting this before those two playoff games take place).
.
Owner Franchise Season W-L Exp W% Playoff
------------------- ------------------- ---------- ----------- ----------- ----------
DarthDurron Giants 1961 76-86 0.458 1
schwarze Dodgers 1941 79-83 0.502 1
footballmm11 Athletics 1969 79-83 0.486 0.5
glowguy Athletics 1932 79-83 0.473 0.5
footballmm11 Pirates 1989 80-82 0.523 1
emanes10 Phillies 2014 81-81 0.544 0.5
mars2010 Phillies 2021 81-81 0.487 0.5
redcped Yankees 1922 82-80 0.528 1
Relkcirts Indians 1952 82-80 0.514 1
kstober Orioles 1908 83-79 0.491 1
kstober Cardinals 1921 83-79 0.483 1
contrarian23 Cubs 1932 83-79 0.476 1
2/27/2025 4:22 PM
The NL East division in League 4 was the toughest division, and it's not close.
.
East W-L PCT GB Division 1-Run G Extra Inn RS RA Exp.% Owner
1914 Pittsbugh Pirates 104-58 0.642 - 21-21 20-22 11-8 1201 935 0.628 pedrocerrano
Chief Wilson’s 1909 Pirates 95-67 0.586 9 20-22 20-17 5-4 1000 845 0.583 ronthegenius
1902 Pittsburgh Pirates 94-68 0.580 10 23-19 19-18 5-12 1080 869 0.609 schwarze
1916 Pittsburgh Pirates 91-71 0.562 13 20-22 20-17 10-4 1060 1017 0.521 barracuda3
2/27/2025 4:24 PM
Here are the two worst divisions. The Giants division has 283 wins, but has the lowest division winner. The Dodgers division has 282 wins, which is the lowest of any division in any league.
.
League 1, NL West W-L PCT GB Division 1-Run G Extra Inn RS RA Exp.% Owner
1961 San Francisco Giants 76-86 0.469 - 21-21 20-26 6-8 768 839 0.458 DarthDurron
2001 Giants 75-87 0.463 1 29-13 16-12 6-3 918 1034 0.440 footballmm11
Pick 23: 2014 SF Giants 73-89 0.451 3 20-22 20-26 7-10 769 829 0.464 bigsteve12
2006 San Francisco Giants 59-103 0.364 17 14-28 18-21 2-11 833 1002 0.409 SAKABAKBRG
.
League 2, NL East W-L PCT GB Division 1-Run G Extra Inn RS RA Exp.% Owner
1941 Brooklyn Dodgers 79-83 0.488 - 26-16 17-20 7-3 948 944 0.502 schwarze
1943 Brooklyn Dodgers 70-92 0.432 9 22-20 15-18 3-7 1016 1079 0.469 kstober
Twist of 1916 Brooklyn Robins 68-94 0.420 11 17-25 21-26 6-11 652 774 0.421 glowguy
1932 Dodgers 65-97 0.401 14 19-23 19-22 8-9 878 1096 0.389 contrarian23

2/27/2025 4:27 PM
Didn't get a high pick in round 2? Here are 13 teams that were picked in the bottom half of their league's draft and won 90+ games.
.
Rank Owner Franchise Leag Season Pick-Lg Pick-Fr W-L
--------- ------------------- ------------------- -------- ---------- --------- --------- -----------
3 footballmm11 Tigers 6 1925 15 8 104-58
5 Bill_James47 Dodgers 2 2015 13 6 99-63
15 calhoop Cubs 5 1920 20 11 96-66
14 schwarze Athletics 4 1913 16 10 96-66
20 redcped Dodgers 2 2023 18 10 94-68
22 footballmm11 Phillies 7 1984 12 8 94-68
26 danidon Indians 3 1914 23 12 92-70
25 barracuda3 Phillies 7 1978 22 11 92-70
29 toysboys White Sox 5 1914 15 8 92-70
24 84champs Reds 8 1963 13 8 92-70
35 kstober Pirates 4 1921 20 10 91-71
37 schwarze Orioles 7 1975 18 9 90-72
36 emanes10 Yankees 1 2003 14 9 90-72
.
Also, picking early doesn't guarantee anything... These below-500 teams were picked in the top 6 in their league's draft.
.
Rank Owner Franchise Leag Season Pick-Lg Pick-Fr W-L
--------- ------------------- ------------------- -------- ---------- --------- --------- -----------
185 SteveIzzy Tigers 6 1961 6 2 61-101
180 calhoop Phillies 7 2012 1 1 65-97
174 kstober White Sox 5 1905 5 3 68-94
159 glowguy Reds 8 1919 3 1 72-90
144 footballmm11 Giants 1 2001 4 3 75-87
144 DarthDurron Phillies 7 1994 5 3 75-87
131 barracuda3 Cubs 5 2016 3 2 76-86
124 toysboys Cardinals 3 1942 3 2 78-84
121 danidon Cubs 5 2006 6 3 78-84
123 njbigwig Athletics 4 1914 6 3 78-84
113 schwarze Phillies 7 1912 2 2 79-83
105 footballmm11 Pirates 4 1989 3 3 80-82
2/27/2025 4:35 PM
That being said, picking early is an advantage, as it should be.
.
Pick-Lg Win Loss Win% Playoff Rd 3 Rd 3% Grp 4
------------- ---------- ---------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ---------- ----------
1 725 571 0.559 6.00 7.0 88% 0.543
2 716 580 0.552 4.00 6.0 75%
3 677 619 0.522 5.00 5.0 63%
4 696 600 0.537 5.00 5.0 63%
5 664 632 0.512 3.00 6.0 75% 0.509
6 675 621 0.521 3.00 7.0 88%
7 673 623 0.519 2.00 6.0 75%
8 625 671 0.482 2.00 3.0 38%
9 634 662 0.489 3.00 6.0 75% 0.499
10 671 625 0.518 4.00 4.0 50%
11 651 645 0.502 1.00 3.0 38%
12 630 666 0.486 1.00 3.0 38%
13 669 627 0.516 4.00 5.0 63% 0.488
14 612 684 0.472 1.00 2.0 25%
15 647 649 0.499 3.50 3.0 38%
16 601 695 0.464 1.00 1.0 13%
17 648 648 0.500 2.50 5.0 63% 0.487
18 630 666 0.486 2.00 3.0 38%
19 606 690 0.468 1.00 2.0 25%
20 641 655 0.495 3.00 4.0 50%
21 615 681 0.475 2.00 3.0 38% 0.475
22 635 661 0.490 1.50 3.0 38%
23 600 696 0.463 2.00 1.0 13%
24 611 685 0.471 1.50 3.0 38%
------------- ---------- ---------- ------------- ------------- ------------- ----------
Total 15552 15552 0.500 1.000 96 50%
2/27/2025 4:37 PM
Franchise Winning% Run/Gm League# Run/Gm
-------------------------- ------------ ------------ ------------ ------------
Yankees 0.511 6.57 1 5.88
Giants 0.489 5.19 1
Red Sox 0.499 5.32 2 5.20
Dodgers 0.501 5.08 2
Cardinals 0.496 5.52 3 5.54
Indians 0.504 5.56 3
Pirates 0.500 6.49 4 6.04
Athletics 0.500 5.59 4
Cubs 0.499 5.37 5 4.80
White Sox 0.501 4.23 5
Tigers 0.496 6.85 6 5.91
Braves 0.504 4.98 6
Orioles 0.492 4.93 7 5.06
Phillies 0.508 5.18 7
Reds 0.503 5.61 8 5.43
Twins 0.497 5.26 8
-------------------------- -------- -------- --------
Overall Average 0.500 5.48
2/27/2025 4:39 PM
◂ Prev 1...4|5|6|7 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.