So far, I have...
HITTING
'55 Campanella (.318, .395, .583)
'xx Pujols (TBD)
'xx Stanky (TBD)
'47 B.Elliott* (.317, .410, .517)
'39 Vaughan* (.306, .385, .424)
'46 Musial* (.365, .434, .587)
'49 Kiner .(310, .432, .658)
'94 D.Sanders (.283, .342, .381)
STARTING PITCHING
'94 Maddux* (288 ip, 1.56 era, .207 oav, 0.90 whip, 0.18 hr/9)
'72 Sutton* (285 ip, 2.08 era, .189 oav, 0.91 whip, 0.43 hr/9)
'10 Wainwright* (230 ip, 2.36 era, .224 oav, 1.05 whip, 0.59 hr/9)
'75 Hooton* (224 ip, 2.82 era, .210 oav, 1.06 whip, 0.64 hr/9)
BULLPEN
'09 Peavy (102 ip, 3.45 era, .216 oav, 1.12 whip, 0.71 hr/9)
'72 Rau (35 ip, 2.20 era, .159 oav, 0.89 whip, 0.28 hr/9)
'09 M.Adams* (37 ip, 0.73 era, .111 oav, 0.59 whip, 0.24 hr/9)
MOPUP
'47 Cooper (50 ip, 4.05 era, .271 oav, 1.31 whip, 0.39 hr/9)
'39 Swift (138 ip, 3.89 era, .293 oav, 1.37 whip, 0.42 hr/9)
I still have one teammate to add (RP).