Posted by laramiebob on 1/19/2018 12:35:00 PM (view original):
I think I get your argument wylie and even agree with the logic......... at least partially.
BUT, one simple question.
All those humans who shared the opinion that the Earth was flat.... remember them?
Later on it was pretty much proved to most of them (all but the lunatics who refuse to acknowledge new factual information) that the Earth was NOT flat... that indeed it was a sphere/globe.
Was their (shared) opinion wrong?
And if not, why not?
Why can a human not cling to an opinion that is flat wrong?
Have you ever studied the history/(creation story) of the LDS faith (Mormons).??
Most Mormons are GOOD people, excellent neighbors quality citizens, etc........ I very much like and respect them for their life practices!!!
BUT, they believe in (HOLD the opinion That) Joseph Smith was some sort of Prophet/Seer chosen by God to found their religion.
They have every right to share that opinion.
Known facts clearly dispute that opinion of Joseph Smith and (in fact) the entire timeline and basic LDS story of Christ's reappearance on earth to the Laamanites(?) (I think it was)
I mean basic geologic global knowledge!!
I don't mean to disparage anyone's belief, BUT to believe in the actual timeline as laid out in the Mormon doctrine is just clearly wrong! (Not necessarily their belief in their God, but their timeline and explanation!) Thus all Mormons either share a wrong opinion OR just choose to kind of ignore that little detail of their religion story.
Perhaps a better example. You can't hold the opinion that Paul Bunyan created the Grand Canyon by dragging his axe (or whatever) and ignore geological fact without (clearly) holding an incorrect opinion. Thus, that opinion (Paul Bunyan did it) is wrong.
Where am I wrong logically?
I think that's more than 1 question, but....:)
Those people who believed the earth was flat before it was proved it is a sphere? They're opinion was not wrong, because at the time, it was not a proven fact that the earth is round. Those who still believe the earth if flat are just crazy. Saying the earth is flat now is not an opinion because most rational people KNOW it has been scientifically proven not to be flat.
I have not studied Mormon history but most of the Mormons I know are good people also. Their beliefs that Joseph Smith was a prophet /seer chosen by God to found their religion can not be disproven, so their opinions can not be wrong. Just as a Christian who believes Jesus was the son of God is not wrong, since no one can prove whether Jesus was or was not the son of God. Heck, the existence of God can't be proven, let alone whether or not he had a son.
Also, a lot of this is not just opinion, but faith as well. That is an entirely different ball of wax, which I don't want to touch!
There are things in the Bible that are clearly wrong as well.
Saying Paul Bunyan create the Grand Canyon by dragging his axe is not an opinion. Im not sure what it is, but it is not an opinion. Is there actually anyone out there who believes that?