Posted by all3 on 8/15/2018 4:08:00 PM (view original):
dskantor brings-up one of the things that has held me back. Expanding on that a bit, what happens if I draft a 1 or 2-year player? I do get to draft another to replace him after the 1 or 2 years, correct? So why then lock the contracts at 3 years for all draftees and force owners to have garbage on their team?
I would like to be able to address your concern but I'm not sure how you define "garbage". If you mean a player who has only one or two serviceable years then I would grant that they do exist. That's why there is one chance every off-season to outright release a player. And an additional chance after the draft to Add / Drop and replace a player(s). The same would hold true for a player at the end of a career with declining stats. And there is an I/R list as well.
We have all had to draft a player we did not want in a single season prog. But in this double era prog there are 622 players in the first draft and only 288 will be drafted. I haven't taken a head count for all the subsequent drafts but I am wagering the numbers will be similar. I think there will be plenty of chances to avoid and / or rid yourself of a player you do not want.
The point of the three year contract is to have roughly one third of every team on a 3 year deal, one third on a 2 year deal and one third on expiring contracts going back into the draft pool. If my vision for how this should work is wrong then I will absolutely be willing to change. But, to the best of my knowledge this particular approach has not been tried before. I think it will work and add new elements of strategy to the mix and I think it's worth a try and evaluation to determine if it works or needs tweaking.
I also think you are too good of an owner to draft "garbage".