Posted by ejstockman on 8/22/2018 6:15:00 AM (view original):
Posted by homiealiens on 8/21/2018 11:43:00 PM (view original):
Biggest surprise for me so far has been the overall lack of errors and minus plays for the $90 mil Coors league versus what I expected, even given the small sample size. Average around 2 errors/minus plays a game. Looked at league averages across the different themes and lowest of which were $100 and $110 which are around 1. Expected those the lowest given the number of clones of pitchers (Maddux/Smoltz/another pitcher/any Braves hitter) and the pitching dominant teams with the deadball era string of years.
Played in back to back games in which the opponent struck me out zero and one time with only one error and zero minus plays between the two games. Lot of balls in plays and successful chances. Will be interesting to see the league progress.
I agree. I am seeing +/- 2 errors a game. Is this WIS self-correcting for the debacle of D/D fielding? I thought deadball era pitchers would get killed in this league. May have been wrong about that.
My thinking when I was constructing my Coors team, was:
Using straight forward math and arbitrary numbers, in the course of a 9 inning game, a team with a .925 fielding percentage (which is low for a team of D/D+ fielders), on average would make 2.025 errors a game if they didn't strike anybody out. If, a team struck out 9 batters/game (a little high to carry out for a whole season in WIS) and your team defense improved to .950 because modern day pitchers improve fielding percentages, you would make an average 0.9 errors a game. That is only a difference of about 1 extra runner a game.
Using WIS performance history, the average number of minus plays you would expect a team of D range fielders to make is about 1 game. While the stadium doesn't effect fielding percentages, the stadium would play a roll in plus/minus plays but not by that much in what you would see in a per game average over the course of an entire season. Since everyone is using the same stadium, the difference in plus/minus plays between the two sets of pitchers in this league would be minimal over 162 games.
Of course, during the course of 2-4 games, teams will over-perform the average, make no errors or minus plays and under-perform, make 4 errors and 3 minus plays a game but, over the entire season, the numbers above is what I would expect the average team to average in errors and minus plays during the whole season.
So, considering dead ball pitchers will keep the ball in the park more than modern day pitchers, I would guess the 1 extra runner a game would hurt less than the extra home runs allowed by modern day pitchers. After all, not every extra runner as a result of bad defense will score when they get on base against a dead ball pitcher but, every extra home run given up by a modern day pitcher will score at least 1 extra run.
So using that logic, I went with dead ball pitchers. We'll see if the logic I employed will hold through the entire season and not just a SSS.
8/22/2018 11:46 AM (edited)