Posted by cccp1014 on 10/30/2018 6:35:00 PM (view original):
Posted by wylie715 on 10/30/2018 6:31:00 PM (view original):
so, its just culture...it can't be the same for tangplay? or whoever the hell that guy was in that thing BL posted? How come you are the only one who can claim to be a Jew by culture but not religion?
I am on an airplane and a Muslim extremist is on there and sees my Star of David. Do you think he cares if I am Atheist before he shoots me? No. Belief in God has left me. My culture and love and respect for fellow Jews and Israel have not. I have Not chosen another religion I have chosen to follow my heart and logic that God is a myth. I could be wrong. I am still a Jew by culture. 100%.
Tang chose a different religion and culture. That is different IMO.
"Love and respect for fellow Jews*"
*Fellow Jews does not include any Jews who are progressive or who have different religious beliefs**
**different religious beliefs doesn't include atheism, you can be atheist and still a "real Jew" as long as you have love and respect for the right kinds of Jews***
***Right kinds of Jews don't get offended by antisemitism from nationalists. They only get offended when someone dares to argue that maybe Palestinians need help.