I'll go ahead and make my final pick of Lee Lacy (Pena). I'm the only one who needs a Pena teammate, and while Lacy was also a teammate of Ripken and John, nobody needs a teammate of those guys either.
I feel like if we did this draft again, with the same players and with the same first round draft order, everyone's team would be like 80% different. It took me a while to get into the rhythm of it and to figure out even a modicum of a coherent strategy, but that challenge made it fun, if frustrating at the beginning. I ended up enjoying it a lot more than I thought I would.