Favorite Player You’ve Ever Had? Topic

All effort
3/22/2020 4:27 PM
This is my actual favorite player. I've won nearly 1500 games including 3 national championships across probably 50+ seasons in Knight (and played across a bunch of other worlds) but I've always liked this guy the most. Unfortunately he's so old he predates the potential system so there are no ratings on him. I used to have ratings for my old players backed up in a spreadsheet but lost track of it when I moved over to a new laptop...

He committed to my tiny Indiana-based D3 school all the way from Honolulu, HI. He set a bunch of school records by the end of his career (season 8 in Knight) including points, rebounds, and I believe steals. In the 130+ seasons since then he's been knocked completely off the records list at DePauw in Knight but I still appreciate the dude who helped lift me to my first sweet 16 in HD.

I don't remember his exact ratings, by today's D3 standards they were mediocre but they were something like:

60 ATH
50 SPD
60 REB
60 DEF
70 LP
70 PER
35 BH
50 PASS
80 WE
90 STA
?? DU
C+ FT
3/22/2020 8:37 PM
How do you connect with players? I need help. They just seem like arbitrary pieces of code to me, and I’d like to learn to love them.
3/22/2020 11:22 PM
Posted by zanesville20 on 3/22/2020 11:22:00 PM (view original):
How do you connect with players? I need help. They just seem like arbitrary pieces of code to me, and I’d like to learn to love them.
Read the play-by-plays
3/23/2020 5:25 PM
Casey White

12th all time scorer in D3 Wooden, 4th in 3 pointers made... and he barely played his freshman year. The only player I've ever had that I regularly set his distribution above 30, and he was more towards 50. Hit 657 three's at a 44.8% clip, and still had nearly 400 assists and 200 steals.

I've had a lot of great players over the years, but White was by far the most fun.
3/24/2020 2:33 PM
James King in Rupp, Eastern Mennonite University Season 1 and 2. He was probably the best computer generated player in Div III at the start of the game. That guy could flat out score.
3/25/2020 9:33 AM (edited)
Posted by zanesville20 on 3/22/2020 11:22:00 PM (view original):
How do you connect with players? I need help. They just seem like arbitrary pieces of code to me, and I’d like to learn to love them.
I see you have 0 seasons.

It takes time, but when I got into this game, sucked for maybe 7-10 seasons, and then finally got my first great recruit and my second great recruit you start to fall in love with the guy. I watched him grow up over 5-7 months and eventually take me to my first NT ever. Its pretty crazy what happens.
6.8.0
3/24/2020 5:23 PM (edited)
In 2.0 I had a rare find at D3. I don't have his overall numbers anymore but he gained 45+ points in ATH, SP, ST, and DEF in his career and wound up 95ath, 90 SP, 95 DEF, 95 ST, and had about 60 LP. He was a monster and lived at the FT line. Racked up over 200 career steals playing zone-can't imagine what he would have done in the press.
3/25/2020 11:01 AM
I've only played three seasons under this moniker after like a 3 or 4 real-life-year hiatus.

Right now I really like this guy: https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=0&pid=4425062

Great LP scorer and a developing 3 pt shot, excited to see what he does next year. I am also really, really enjoying watching my first couple of recruiting classes grow up at LIU Southampton -- starting next year some players I actually recruited should be big time players I'm excited about that
3/25/2020 3:40 PM
William Eatmon

Career scoring leader in Smith (all divisions) - 3,364 points
Career 3-point shots made leader in Smith (all divisions) - 793
2-time National Player of the Year
2-time D3 season scoring leader (finished second his second season)

Made it to 2 Final Four's and 1 Elite 8

Despite not winning a NT, easily my most enjoyable and memorable player.
3/25/2020 4:12 PM (edited)
Although this is no where near close to one of the best players I've had, he's my favorite.

Elmer Harris is a player who lead my loaded season 131 CSU Eastbay squad to my first title. I contreversially senior redshirted him and he is a running joke among me and some of my HD colleagues because of the amount of times I used to mention him.
3/25/2020 6:15 PM

Brent Whitley had my most memorable season for a guy with pretty much nothing but 3pt shooting as a 6th man in my D2 championship season. Loved that guy

3/26/2020 3:15 AM
https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerHistory/Ratings.aspx?&pid=3288028

Joseph Hendrickson - Texas, Tyler (I think D2 pulldown recruit)
124-11 Career Record
3x National Champ
1x NPOY
1x NDPOY
2x 1st Team AA
2x CPOY
3x CDPOY
2x 1st Team AC
#2 D3 All Time Steals Leader
#16 D3 All Time Scoring Leader

Scored over 1,100 points and had over 100 steals his senior year. He was special for me during that stretch.
3/26/2020 1:54 PM
I'm trying to do the fancy paste options you guys are but I just can't figure it out Haha. So here is likely my favorite player. He's currently on the roster now.

1x NPOY and likely a 2x when season ends, has finished in a S16 and 2 title games so far, winning one of those. Already leading scorer in school history, led the nation last season, and is currently leading this season by a fairly large margin. Lots of accolades. I expect him to finish a 2x NPOY, 2x scoring champ, AND a 2x champion.

Meet Arthur Sprague 100 SPD, 100 PER, 94 BH, and 99 ST is a deadly combination

https://www.whatifsports.com/hd/PlayerProfile/Ratings.aspx?tid=0&pid=4364115
3/26/2020 2:46 PM
12 Next ▸
Favorite Player You’ve Ever Had? Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.