Savage V Rosters/Commentary Topic

Price / Dumars (Jordan)
Jordan / Lavine / Booker
Mcdyess / Amir Johnson / Rudy Gay
Noah / Love
Russell / Noah /Miller

Probably light on SF spot, but quite like the rest of the team with some Frontcourt passing
7/12/2021 8:17 AM
D.Williams / Conley
Oladipo / R.Harper / E.Jones / Hield
Nance / Zion / Jo.Green
J.Lucas / Bamba
Chamberlain

Not sure how I feel about this squad. Definitely not my best drafting effort.
7/12/2021 9:30 AM
Posted by albiband0 on 7/12/2021 8:17:00 AM (view original):
Price / Dumars (Jordan)
Jordan / Lavine / Booker
Mcdyess / Amir Johnson / Rudy Gay
Noah / Love
Russell / Noah /Miller

Probably light on SF spot, but quite like the rest of the team with some Frontcourt passing
Lavine/Booker behind Jordan is some smart drafting.
7/12/2021 10:08 AM
Posted by robusk on 7/12/2021 10:08:00 AM (view original):
Posted by albiband0 on 7/12/2021 8:17:00 AM (view original):
Price / Dumars (Jordan)
Jordan / Lavine / Booker
Mcdyess / Amir Johnson / Rudy Gay
Noah / Love
Russell / Noah /Miller

Probably light on SF spot, but quite like the rest of the team with some Frontcourt passing
Lavine/Booker behind Jordan is some smart drafting.
Thanks Robusk, I though about Beal initially but it went early. I only regret I had to double up with Lavine and Booker, and I only plan to use some seasons from each of them - in some teams one of the 2 will never play
7/12/2021 10:09 AM
Two findings from my team, both related:
Giannis, Whiteside, Drexler, Moncrief, Webber, Nerlens all have pretty inconsistent position effectiveness. Sometimes they can play some positions, other times they can't. It made it really, really challenging to draft.

Additionally, I am finding that it makes it kind of impossible to go with the two teams strategy because I get kind of hamstrung on which seasons I have to pair to make the positions and minutes work.
7/12/2021 10:29 AM
Posted by albiband0 on 7/12/2021 10:09:00 AM (view original):
Posted by robusk on 7/12/2021 10:08:00 AM (view original):
Posted by albiband0 on 7/12/2021 8:17:00 AM (view original):
Price / Dumars (Jordan)
Jordan / Lavine / Booker
Mcdyess / Amir Johnson / Rudy Gay
Noah / Love
Russell / Noah /Miller

Probably light on SF spot, but quite like the rest of the team with some Frontcourt passing
Lavine/Booker behind Jordan is some smart drafting.
Thanks Robusk, I though about Beal initially but it went early. I only regret I had to double up with Lavine and Booker, and I only plan to use some seasons from each of them - in some teams one of the 2 will never play
I think doubling up on Jordan's backups at the end of the draft is a lot more effective than reaching for someone early.

I had to do so on Giannis since he plays so few minutes for an early pick (as do my 2nd rounder and my 3rd rounder...... yikes).
7/12/2021 10:31 AM
Posted by robusk on 7/12/2021 10:31:00 AM (view original):
Posted by albiband0 on 7/12/2021 10:09:00 AM (view original):
Posted by robusk on 7/12/2021 10:08:00 AM (view original):
Posted by albiband0 on 7/12/2021 8:17:00 AM (view original):
Price / Dumars (Jordan)
Jordan / Lavine / Booker
Mcdyess / Amir Johnson / Rudy Gay
Noah / Love
Russell / Noah /Miller

Probably light on SF spot, but quite like the rest of the team with some Frontcourt passing
Lavine/Booker behind Jordan is some smart drafting.
Thanks Robusk, I though about Beal initially but it went early. I only regret I had to double up with Lavine and Booker, and I only plan to use some seasons from each of them - in some teams one of the 2 will never play
I think doubling up on Jordan's backups at the end of the draft is a lot more effective than reaching for someone early.

I had to do so on Giannis since he plays so few minutes for an early pick (as do my 2nd rounder and my 3rd rounder...... yikes).
Agreed. I went relatively early (9th round) to get DRose as Payton's backup because I thought he was clearly the best option if I wanted to back him up with just one other player. But I had also considered a De'aaron Fox/D'Angelo Russell platoon behind Payton; the exact thing ben ultimately did in rounds 11/12 to back up Lebron. Hard to say which is the right choice - I had to use an earlier pick, but saved another roster slot to use elsewhere - but either way I think Booker/Lavine as a late-round platoon was a better call than trying to get Beal in, like, the 5th or 6th, if he had lasted that long, just to play 600-1000 backup minutes behind MJ.
7/12/2021 1:17 PM
Well, here's how we ended up.

Payton/Rose
Iguodala/Miller/Hawkins
Marion/West
Garnett/Cousins
Okafor/Ayton/Daniels

Thought my first three picks couldn't have fallen much better; was planning on picking another big man in the 3rd round but the value on Marion was too good to pass up. Made a mistake in the 4th, where I should have gone with Brent Barry over Okafor but had to rush to make that pick. Still not bad to get Iggy in the 5th, but I think I would have been better off with Barry. Was mostly picking to make sure I filled needs in rounds 6-9 and didn't get a whole lot of great value there, but was happy with the guys I was able to add in the 10th-12th (even if dBKC did snatch Nick Anderson right from under my nose). Hawkins can approximate about 90-95% of what I would have asked Anderson to do; frankly I've always been surprised he's never picked in this draft.

Overall though: I'm not sure. It's pretty boring. Loaded up early on guys with good D and low fouls/turnovers, but not very efficient scoring, and I'm not sure I ever made up for that enough. So we'll probably struggle to do the one thing - score efficiently - that I've always thought was most important in the SIM. Hopefully the rest can make up for it.
7/12/2021 2:11 PM
Marion going to get any time at SG and Garnett any time at SF?
7/12/2021 2:58 PM
Alvin Robertson/Jon Barry/TJ McConnell
Gerald Wallace/James Johnson/Nick Anderson
Draymond Green/Kyle Anderson/J Johnson/Barkley
Charles Barkley/Domantas Sabonis/Jokic
Nikola Jokic/Tom Boerwinkle/Sabonis

The strategy is to get to 90%+ AST with Jokic/Draymond/Boerwinkle/Domantas/SloMo boosting us from the frontcourt, while playing with a rebounding advantage from Alvin Robertson and Crash in the backcourt. Jon Barry and Nick Anderson hopefully supplement Jokic and Draymond/Barkley’s 3s enough to make it not a weakness. No real usage hogs aside from the super efficient Barkley and Jokic so hopefully they take most of our shots with a bump on efficiency from all of the passing. We’ll see.
7/12/2021 3:05 PM
Posted by robusk on 7/12/2021 2:58:00 PM (view original):
Marion going to get any time at SG and Garnett any time at SF?
As of now, Marion will get no time at SG but Garnett's 02-03 season will play exclusively at SF.
7/12/2021 3:28 PM
Frazier/Dragic
Mullin/Dragic/Hawkins
Covington/Spoon/Vanderbilt/Diallo
Embiid/Vucevic
Gobert/McGee

To me, at least, there's no justification for taking the Admiral over Rudy, now that 20-21 exists. Now that he has five seasons over 60 eFG%/25 DReb%/2100 min/80 D, there's no better low usage pick. He now has three seasons that cost more per minute than Tim Duncan's 06-07 and two that cost more per minute than 17-18 AD, which is just wild, especially in this league.

Wanted a defensive point guard & an early start on boards, so Frazier was easy. Oscar probably has a higher ADP in this league but I don't understand that. Easy enough to build around Walt at SG. Figured that would be the case but was looking at Dame to be the highest usage option. When that didn't happen, Embiid, despite his minutes, was too good to pass up. If Bill Walton has gone in the 3rd in the last two seasons, why can't Embiid with 20-21? One Gobert season that is 99% at PF will have to move up, but that's fine.

Didn't think Vucevic would make it to me in the 4th, but too much value and one of the only guys who could back up Embiid so I could draft some low usage guys later. Mullin is as efficient for five seasons as there is, and he's a better passer in his later seasons than you might think. Covington not only closed the gap on 3s for all teams, but also defensively, since he can switch up to the 2. McGee is an ideal Gobert backup, and I've seen the difference between having efficient backup bigs and not having them. In this league, having two paint monsters for five seasons is preferable. Dragic fills in the passing gaps, and 13-14 is good enough to start.

I'm not so sure about the last part of the draft, though. Once you hit Round 9, you have to make some tough choices. I needed 00-01 Spoon for one squad, but I'm not wild about the other four seasons I have. Vanderbilt was a nice shot in the arm for one team, although I wonder if I could've found someone there with multiple comparable seasons. 73-74 Connie comes in and plays SG on one squad (should've picked _______?) while Cheick gives me 25 total minutes of things no other SF does.

Overall, is it good enough to crack the top 10 in standings? I really don't know. Much depends on whether Mullin and Rudy can compensate for Frazier and Embiid's meh eFG%. There are a few teams I would fear more than my own. Whether or not this team is good enough, it's the result of 13 years in this racket. Would've been easier with Harden, but it is what it is. If I haven't learned by now, I can live with that. This is my final test.
7/12/2021 4:13 PM
Posted by bds9992 on 7/12/2021 4:14:00 PM (view original):
Frazier/Dragic
Mullin/Dragic/Hawkins
Covington/Spoon/Vanderbilt/Diallo
Embiid/Vucevic
Gobert/McGee

To me, at least, there's no justification for taking the Admiral over Rudy, now that 20-21 exists. Now that he has five seasons over 60 eFG%/25 DReb%/2100 min/80 D, there's no better low usage pick. He now has three seasons that cost more per minute than Tim Duncan's 06-07 and two that cost more per minute than 17-18 AD, which is just wild, especially in this league.

Wanted a defensive point guard & an early start on boards, so Frazier was easy. Oscar probably has a higher ADP in this league but I don't understand that. Easy enough to build around Walt at SG. Figured that would be the case but was looking at Dame to be the highest usage option. When that didn't happen, Embiid, despite his minutes, was too good to pass up. If Bill Walton has gone in the 3rd in the last two seasons, why can't Embiid with 20-21? One Gobert season that is 99% at PF will have to move up, but that's fine.

Didn't think Vucevic would make it to me in the 4th, but too much value and one of the only guys who could back up Embiid so I could draft some low usage guys later. Mullin is as efficient for five seasons as there is, and he's a better passer in his later seasons than you might think. Covington not only closed the gap on 3s for all teams, but also defensively, since he can switch up to the 2. McGee is an ideal Gobert backup, and I've seen the difference between having efficient backup bigs and not having them. In this league, having two paint monsters for five seasons is preferable. Dragic fills in the passing gaps, and 13-14 is good enough to start.

I'm not so sure about the last part of the draft, though. Once you hit Round 9, you have to make some tough choices. I needed 00-01 Spoon for one squad, but I'm not wild about the other four seasons I have. Vanderbilt was a nice shot in the arm for one team, although I wonder if I could've found someone there with multiple comparable seasons. 73-74 Connie comes in and plays SG on one squad (should've picked _______?) while Cheick gives me 25 total minutes of things no other SF does.

Overall, is it good enough to crack the top 10 in standings? I really don't know. Much depends on whether Mullin and Rudy can compensate for Frazier and Embiid's meh eFG%. There are a few teams I would fear more than my own. Whether or not this team is good enough, it's the result of 13 years in this racket. Would've been easier with Harden, but it is what it is. If I haven't learned by now, I can live with that. This is my final test.
Good breakdown. I think this team has a lot of positives. As I said before, my main concern is assists. What do the assist %s of your starting lineups look like? It looks to me like you're going to mostly be below 60%, with some maybe around 50%, depending on how often Dragic is starting.
7/12/2021 4:22 PM
Posted by tarheel1991 on 7/12/2021 4:22:00 PM (view original):
Posted by bds9992 on 7/12/2021 4:14:00 PM (view original):
Frazier/Dragic
Mullin/Dragic/Hawkins
Covington/Spoon/Vanderbilt/Diallo
Embiid/Vucevic
Gobert/McGee

To me, at least, there's no justification for taking the Admiral over Rudy, now that 20-21 exists. Now that he has five seasons over 60 eFG%/25 DReb%/2100 min/80 D, there's no better low usage pick. He now has three seasons that cost more per minute than Tim Duncan's 06-07 and two that cost more per minute than 17-18 AD, which is just wild, especially in this league.

Wanted a defensive point guard & an early start on boards, so Frazier was easy. Oscar probably has a higher ADP in this league but I don't understand that. Easy enough to build around Walt at SG. Figured that would be the case but was looking at Dame to be the highest usage option. When that didn't happen, Embiid, despite his minutes, was too good to pass up. If Bill Walton has gone in the 3rd in the last two seasons, why can't Embiid with 20-21? One Gobert season that is 99% at PF will have to move up, but that's fine.

Didn't think Vucevic would make it to me in the 4th, but too much value and one of the only guys who could back up Embiid so I could draft some low usage guys later. Mullin is as efficient for five seasons as there is, and he's a better passer in his later seasons than you might think. Covington not only closed the gap on 3s for all teams, but also defensively, since he can switch up to the 2. McGee is an ideal Gobert backup, and I've seen the difference between having efficient backup bigs and not having them. In this league, having two paint monsters for five seasons is preferable. Dragic fills in the passing gaps, and 13-14 is good enough to start.

I'm not so sure about the last part of the draft, though. Once you hit Round 9, you have to make some tough choices. I needed 00-01 Spoon for one squad, but I'm not wild about the other four seasons I have. Vanderbilt was a nice shot in the arm for one team, although I wonder if I could've found someone there with multiple comparable seasons. 73-74 Connie comes in and plays SG on one squad (should've picked _______?) while Cheick gives me 25 total minutes of things no other SF does.

Overall, is it good enough to crack the top 10 in standings? I really don't know. Much depends on whether Mullin and Rudy can compensate for Frazier and Embiid's meh eFG%. There are a few teams I would fear more than my own. Whether or not this team is good enough, it's the result of 13 years in this racket. Would've been easier with Harden, but it is what it is. If I haven't learned by now, I can live with that. This is my final test.
Good breakdown. I think this team has a lot of positives. As I said before, my main concern is assists. What do the assist %s of your starting lineups look like? It looks to me like you're going to mostly be below 60%, with some maybe around 50%, depending on how often Dragic is starting.
56/62/62/54/55
7/12/2021 4:48 PM
My Savage V draft journal

Round 1

22? Get me the hell out of here! I drafted 24 last Savage draft and have no interest looking at the same players again. If I have to stay there, Gobert/Kawhi would be the dream start. Thank you midge! 11 is a nice spot. Hopefully 1 of the top 9 will fall to me. But realistically, I'm looking at Harden or Barkley. I haven't used either yet and think they would be pretty fun to build around. No one falls, Harden it is. I'm back in my comfort zone of having a player I can build 5 playoff teams around. I messed up last season thinking I could do that with Wade. I would have had more success loading up on 2-3 teams with Wade.

Round 2

Rodman is the pipe dream. Damn, came pretty close. Don't draft Steve Nash. Don't draft Steve Nash. Don't draft Ste...****...hes available. Don't do it dh, stick to the plan. Harden + defense + boards = playoffs. I had Chandler last season and Mutombo is overrated as a rebounder and only C eff. Fine, ok so Drummond or Whiteside? Minutes vs defense. Is Drummond the best boardlord in all of Savage? I hate to pass up defense in the 2nd but holy **** is that some amazing consistent rebounding and solid paint scoring over 5 seasons. Let's do it. We should be able to pick up some defense at the 4/5 later.

Round 3

This is the SF round for me. The Nance/Jones/Marion/Green/Grant/AK47/Marshall group is super appealing with their heavy mins and good def/reb. Miss out on that group and I'm probably gonna have to piece together the SF later on with a couple roster spots. I want someone from this group. Manu and Walton are the only other non SFs I'm looking at here. Nance and Jones gone. Feels like I'm gonna end up with my guy Ho Grant. But Marion keeps dropping. Am I gonna get him? No, tarheel or dbkc will definitely take him. Forget that pipe dream right now. Yup, there he goes. Looks like it's gonna be Grant. Or maybe Manu? I'd be on my way to a really great backcourt rotation. Nah, finding backcourt players will be much easier then finding a SF who boards/defends with low towels across 5 seasons. It's boring and predictable, but I think it's the right move.

"make the pick dh"

"Horace Grant"

"Yaaaayyyyy!!!"



Round 4

Alright, I ate my veggies with the first 3 picks. Now it's time for dessert. I can start targeting stud seasons to play next to Harden or Drummond. I want some defense at the 4/5 and those two recent Bam seasons are really standing out. Highly unlikely I'd get him in the 5th, so it's now or never. Penny would give me a huge boost for my top team, but I don't feel like his 2nd best season is good enough to warrant a 4th round pick. Lowry, Bledsoe, Rondo, and West are all intriguing options. Ok, I'm really on Lowry now. He's a better rebounder than I thought, and along with Harden, give me enough 3s to target someone like Alvin or Pressey for defense at the 1/2 later on. Lowry gonna make it to me? Yesssss. Liking my start a lot here.

Round 5

I gotta get defense at the 1/2 or 4/5 here. Guys with defense and good efg are drying up fast and I'm in danger of being weak on defense. Ahhh there goes Bam. No surprise, but it still stings. Alvin and Moncrief are guys I usually don't target due to lack of 3s that would work with Lowry/Harden. Would love one of those two guys. Bogut and Dale Davis(maybe the most underrated 4/5 in all of Savage) are my big men targets. Oooohhh Bogut's one high usg season with defense matches up nicely with the one low usg Drummond season I wanted to use. And even though their short on mins and high on fouls, those Bogut Warrior seasons are fantastic. Yup, it's Bogut.

Round 6

Sidney and Dale made it past the turn! 7 picks away and both are still available! Ouch...back to back gut shots from earl and robusk. Ok, I should go Pressey right? Great defense across 5 seasons and plenty of passing and boards. Ugh, after looking at potential lineups, I don't know if I'm gonna have the team usg I want if I go with Pressey or lower usg guards like Ward/Nate/Christie etc. Harden has the usg to carry any lineup but I just don't feel comfortable with Drummond as a 2nd scoring option in certain lineups. I think I'm gonna have to bite the bullet and sacrifice defense for some backcourt usg. You know who takes care of the usg worries? Our old buddy T-Mac. Draft him as a Harden backup and then we can fill in the backup Lowry mins later on in the draft with the super deep pool of modern guards. I think I can get him in the 7th so lets grab some more def/boards while it's still available. I'd love to use 96-97 Mason as a starter and his other 4 seasons can be backups to Grant. Oakley is a great option as well. Buuuuut, what about Dan Roundfield? 80-90 defense that can cover 3-5 and he's got the usg to backup Drummond if I feel it's needed there. Great oreb% too which is definitely a theme I'm going for here. Captain Hindsight says I might have screwed this pick up though. I may only end up using 1-2 seasons due to his mediocre efg and super high towels.

Round 7

Nice. T-Mac made it to me. What do you think Captain Hindsight? Yea, your right. I shouldn't get too excited since I'm probably only using 02-03 and a handful of mins from two other seasons. But hey, I'm excited to see what 17-18 Harden and 02-03 T-Mac can do together. Should be fun.

Round 8

While looking at potential 4/5 bigs with defense during the Bogut pick, I saved two names for later. Nerlens Noel and Oliver Miller. I thought I could get Miller in the 10th or 11th but Noel would have to be 8th or 9th. robusk took him in the 11th last season and I was sure he would target him again based on his current team and Noel adding his 20-21 season. So Noel was initially the target there, But then I started looking at other options and just couldn't ignore Plumlee. He had several different seasons with varying usg, boards, and defense that I felt could really help when putting the teams together. I also started looking at my backup SF options became concerned how that was gonna shake out with rapidly declining roster spots. A.C. Green was a perfect backup to Grant and I really liked the idea of keeping SF super clean next to a 4/5 rotation full of towels. This was the hardest decision of the draft for me picking between Noel/Green/Plumlee. Ended up going with Plumlee for the versatility.

Round 9

Holy ****. Green and Noel are still there. But after the Plumlee pick, A.C. is more important for this team so gotta go with him. Hah I was right, robusk did end up taking Noel.

Round 10

Ok, time to grab Oliver Miller or Larry Sanders to round out the frountcourt. Damn, there goes Sanders. Ah well, I wanted Miller anyway. Whew! Robert Williams went - that could have been Oliver. Noooooo! dammit albi! Ugh, well at least Varejao is still out there. He doesn't have any standout defensive seasons like Miller or Sanders but he does have 5 seasons that could crack the rotation. Hmmm maybe I should take another look at guard. Plenty of options with low defense or weak reb/ast. Can I find anyone with the usg/efg/def/ast/reb combo I want? Nah not really. But Lonzo Ball is pretty damn close. Two solid seasons to throw into the backcourt rotation.

Round 11

Varejao is still there. Pick em up!

Round 12

I need two seasons to fill out the backcourt unless I want to use some sub 50% efg McGrady seasons. Narrowed down the numerous options(Reggie Miller still out there!!!) to Brandon Roy, Gordon Hayward, and Brandon Ingram. Happy to get Ingram here. Backcourt defense will be shaky when he's in but he does everything else really well for a 12th rounder.


Overall I'm very happy with the draft. I should be able to put out 5 teams that can compete for a playoff spot and possibly make a run. I really like the floor balance I've got and the rebounding could be a real strength. I do feel a little uneasy about not having a consistent 2nd scoring threat to Harden. The towels are also probably gonna be a problem. I cant wait to see how it all turns out. Fingers crossed for some division luck! haha
7/12/2021 4:51 PM
◂ Prev 1...8|9|10|11|12...21 Next ▸
Savage V Rosters/Commentary Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.