Over the 20 yrs. I've been playing; the most frustrating has been Albert Pujols. He always seems underpriced; BUT he always under performs his cost.

Rod Carew has entered my most disappointing players crew lately.

George Brett has officially redeemed himself with his WISC performance

Posted by fatguyrd on 7/18/2021 2:48:00 PM (view original):
I’ve never got a good season from Babe Ruth!

Depends on the season for me.

We’ve all heard it before, but I’ve never received value fro Joe Morgan….occasionally the ‘77 would come close to be worth the money, but I haven’t touched him by choice in years.

The single worst performance I ever got out of anyone was 2004 Ryan Drese in a single-season prog. I had a contending team, was certain we'd make the playoffs, but lost the division by 2 games and the wild card by 1. Drese was my #3 starter and he sunk us.

Real life stats: 208 IP, 14-10, ERC+ 106, ERC# 3.97

Sim stats: 198 IP, 6-17, 9.00 ERA

Never used him tired, and he had a conservative pitch count. Couldn't figure out why he performed like a 200K mop all season when he had slightly better than league average normalized numbers.