Overall rating doesn't mean anything and you care too much about it
a player at high D1 isn't good if they are 800+ but sub 70 ath/spd.
Your team has 4 players over 80 ath or def in a zone press that's not good for high d1.
If it's a sim team they set all players to 0 3 point frequency so running a heavy - is I'll advised regardless of their talent level.
I would recommend learning what attributes the game actually likes before quitting and telling people to quit when its just you not knowing what skills to recruit