I will be taking the 1973 Reds with my turn (since schwarze has already used his pick in that time period)

Sorry for the delay. Was playing poker till 3:00 am. Catching up... I know I am up for Reds & Twins/Senators.

Critical mistake with my last Reds pick. I should've taken 2020, but instead let barracuda3 get them. Congrats on winning 100+ games, barracuda3.

Lots of folks still need 2003-2022 seasons, so I might as well grab one with a solid SP and great RP. And believe it or not, but Mesoroco is an upgrade over my '76 Bench.

2014 Cincinnati Reds

1962 Orioles

1925 reds

2014 O's

Posted by redcped on 6/3/2023 11:46:00 AM (view original):
1918 Washington Senators (Twins)

I was going to take 1918, but decided all the Walter Johnsons are pretty good, and didn't really care which one I got.

Also, '18 Walter Johnson was pretty disappointing for my round 3 team (under .500 and ERA ranked 17th, behind notable HOF pitchers, Larry Cheney, Red Faber and Dutch Reuther)

Posted by schwarze on 6/3/2023 12:13:00 PM (view original):

Posted by redcped on 6/3/2023 11:46:00 AM (view original):
1918 Washington Senators (Twins)

I was going to take 1918, but decided all the Walter Johnsons are pretty good, and didn't really care which one I got.

Also, '18 Walter Johnson was pretty disappointing for my round 3 team (under .500 and ERA ranked 17th, behind notable HOF pitchers, Larry Cheney, Red Faber and Dutch Reuther)

There were 3 I was still going to be equally happy with, but this one had the most innings. Plus a couple teammate pitchers who are rosterable. I figured it was better to have a choice than not to, but when I went to bed that wasn't the pick I thought I'd make. I woke up in the middle of the night and did more research, then went back to bed. Time will tell if I should have just picked up a book instead.