Ok, this is a perfect example of the ridiculousness of this walk issue. PM2 game. Jeff Robinson is pitching. In real life he had a 3.15 BB/9 but doesn’t necessarily normalize well with a 3.79 BB/9#, but it’s still under 4 and he also has a normalized 5.40 K/9# in a $70M league.
1st inning
J.Robinson enters the game to pitch.
V.Coleman hits a Texas League single to CF.
DP J.Robinson throws a wild pitch and all runners advance.
R.Grossman takes ball four. 11 BB/100# vs 17 K/100#
DP A.Dunn walks. 16 BB/100# vs 28 K/100#
DP J.Clark hits a flyball grand slam to LCF.
E.Longoria takes ball four. 14 BB/100# vs 16 K/100#
DP B.Crawford smokes a line drive single to RF.
DP C.Biggio swings and misses for strike 3.
DP R.Hodges walks. 15 BB/100# vs 17 K/100#
DP R.Reuschel crushes a grand slam to CF.
V.Coleman is drilled in the knee by a pitch.
DPSB V.Coleman steals 2B.
SB V.Coleman steals third base.
II R.Grossman pops out to 1B.
A.Dunn grounds out to 1B.
That is 4 BB, 1 K, 4 H, 1 HBP, 1 WP, 2 HRA in the 1st inning. He pitches another 2 2/3 innings before reaching his pitch count. To his 1st inning numbers, he adds: 4 BB, 3 K, and 2 H. All in all he allowed 10 runs, all earned. He was not fatigued, starting at 100%. All 4 batters walked in the 1st had higher strikeout ratios than walk ratios.
He has walked 5 or more batters in 7 of 13 games, for a total of 45 walks, or 6.4 per game and 10.89 BB/9. The other 6 produced 18 walks, or 3 per game and 4.29 BB/9. The latter is what I would expect in a middling-to-off year. Maybe one or possibly two 5+ BB games mixed in so far. But more than half averaging 10.89 BB/9??? That seems ridiculous to me.