Link to Round 3 Rules

Other Details
Years: 1885 - 1891
Salary Cap: None
DH, WW, AAA, Injuries: No
Clones: Only one clone allowed.
Ballpark: Must use WhatifSports Park
Division Alignment: When selecting their first season, each person will also select which division to play in. Those with two teams in a league must put one team in the NL and one in the AL.

This is a 5-round draft, where you will draft 4 single-season teams (from the defined season range). The fifth round is a single player draft (from any of the undrafted seasons from the season-range). You must roster exactly 6 players from each of your four drafted teams. The single player you select in round 5 is your 25th player. You still get one clone (can come from the drafted teams or the 25th player from round 5).

The draft is a normal serpentine draft
Round 1: 1-24 (pick a year) --> the draft order is based on the round 2 rankings
Round 2: 24-1 (pick a year)
Round 3: 1-24 (pick a year)
Round 4: 24-1 (pick a year)
Round 5: 1-24 (pick a player from an undrafted team)

There's not an easy way to differentiate the two 1890 Giants teams and two 1890 A's teams in the search engine, so you'll have to use baseball-reference to parse out which players play on each team.

National League New York Giants --> https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/NYG/1890.shtml
Player's League New York Giants --> https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/NYI/1890.shtml
American Association Philadephia Athletics --> https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/PHA/1890.shtml
Player's League Philadephia Athletics --> https://www.baseball-reference.com/teams/PHQ/1890.shtml

Site-mail List:
3dayrotation; barracuda3; BeAllEndAll; Bill_James47; calhoop; DarthDurron; eman7400; emanes10; footballmm11; glowguy; Jtpsops; kstober; mllama54; njbigwig; nocomm999; pedrocerrano; redcped; richiebrown6; schwarze; SteveIzzy; Taxman2008; thejuice6; toysboys; ybjsports

Round 1
1. toysboys --> 1888 St. Louis Browns (AL West)
2. emanes10 --> 1885 New York Giants (NL West)
3. pedrocerrano --> 1888 New York Giants (AL East)
4. schwarze --> 1886 Chicago White Stockings (NL East)
5. footballmm11 --> 1886 Detroit Wolverines (NL Central)
6. nocomm999 --> 1885 Chicago White Stockings (AL Central)
7. BeAllEndAll --> 1888 Philadelphia Athletics (AL Central)
8. njbigwig --> 1886 St. Louis Browns (AL Central)
9. DarthDurron --> 1890 Columbus Salons (NL West)
10. pedrocerrano --> 1891 Boston Reds (NL East)
11. footballmm11 --> 1887 St. Louis Browns (AL Central)
12. schwarze --> 1889 New York Giants (AL West)
13. redcped --> 1888 Detroit Wolverines (NL Central)
14. Taxman2008 --> 1890 Louisville Colonels (NL Central)
15. Bill_James47 --> 1887 New York Giants (NL East)
16. kstober --> 1885 St. Louis Browns (AL East)
17. calhoop --> 1888 Cincinnati Red Stockings (NL West)
18. Jtpsops --> 1885 Louisville Colenels (AL East)
19. richiebrown6 --> 1888 Brooklyn Bridegrooms (AL West)
20. eman7400 --> 1886 Pittsburgh Alleghenys (NL West)
21. ybjsports --> 1885 Philadelphia Athletics (AL West)
22. njbigwig --> 1890 Chicago Colts (NL Central)
23. 3dayrotation --> 1888 Philadelphia Quakers (NL East)
24. mllama54 --> 1887 Detroit Wolverines (AL East)
.
Round 2
25. mllama54 --> 1889 St. Louis Browns
26. 3dayrotation --> 1890 New York Giants (NL)
27. njbigwig --> 1886 New York Giants
28. ybjsports --> 1890 New York Giants (PL)
29. eman7400 --> 1889 Philadelphia Athletics
30. richiebrown6 --> 1885 Pittsburgh Alleghenys
31. Jtpsops --> 1889 Boston Beaneaters
32. calhoop --> 1888 Louisville Colonels
33. kstober --> 1890 Boston Reds
34. Bill_James47 --> 1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings
35. Taxman2008 --> 1886 Louisville Colonels
36. redcped --> 1887 Boston Beaneaters
37. schwarze --> 1885 Philadelphia Quakers
38. footballmm11 --> 1886 Philadelphia Quakers
39. pedrocerrano --> 1887 Louisville Colonels
40. DarthDurron --> 1890 Cleveland Infants
41. njbigwig --> 1891 Milwaukee Brewers
42. BeAllEndAll --> 1888 Chicago White Stockings
43. nocomm999 --> 1888 Boston Beaneaters
44. footballmm11 --> 1890 St. Louis Browns
45. schwarze --> 1890 Cincinnati Reds
46. pedrocerrano --> 1889 Chicago White Stockings
47. emanes10 --> 1885 Detroit Wolverines
48. toysboys --> 1890 Philadelphia Phillies
.
Round 3
49. toysboys --> 1889 Baltimore Orioles
50. emanes10 --> 1887 Philadelphia Athletics
51. pedrocerrano --> 1887 Baltimore Orioles
52. schwarze --> 1886 St. Louis Maroons
53. footballmm11 --> 1890 Syracuse Stars
54. nocomm999 --> 1890 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
55. BeAllEndAll --> 1890 Brooklyn Wonders
56. njbigwig --> 1885 Buffalo Bisons
57. DarthDurron --> 1890 Toledo Maumees
58. pedrocerrano --> 1885 New York Metropolitans
59. footballmm11 --> 1887 Indianapolis Hoosiers
60. schwarze --> 1890 Chicago Pirates
61. redcped --> 1886 New York Metropolitans
62. Taxman2008 --> 1889 Indianapolis Hoosiers
63. Bill_James47 --> 1890 Boston Beaneaters
64. kstober --> 1889 Cleveland Spiders
65. calhoop --> 1891 St. Louis Browns
66. Jtpsops --> 1887 Chicago White Stockings
67. richiebrown6 --> 1891 Boston Beaneaters
68. eman7400 --> 1889 Cincinnati Red Stockings
69. ybjsports --> 1891 Cincinnati Reds
70. njbigwig --> 1891 Philadelphia Phillies
71. 3dayrotation --> 1886 Philadelphia Athletics
72. mllama54 --> 1891 New York Giants
.
Round 4
73. mllama54 --> 1887 New York Metropolitans
74. 3dayrotation --> 1885 St. Louis Maroons
75. njbigwig --> 1890 Pittsburgh Burghers
76. ybjsports --> 1891 Columbus Salons
77. eman7400 --> 1890 Baltimore Orioles
78. richiebrown6 --> 1891 Baltimore Orioles
79. Jtpsops --> 1885 Cincinnati Red Stockings
80. calhoop --> 1889 PIttsburgh Allegenys
81. kstober --> 1887 Philadelphia Quakers
82. Bill_James47 --> 1891 Washington Statesmen
83. Taxman2008 --> 1890 Philadelphia Athletics (AA)
84. redcped --> 1886 Washington Nationals
85. schwarze --> 1889 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
86. footballmm11 --> 1886 Baltimore Orioles
87. pedrocerrano --> 1890 Cleveland Spiders
88. DarthDurron --> 1886 Cincinnati Red Stockings
89. njbigwig --> 1891 Philadelphia Athletics
90. BeAllEndAll --> 1891 Cincinnati Kelly's Killers
91. nocomm999 --> 1889 Kansas City Cowboys
92. footballmm11 --> 1890 Philadelphia Athletics (PL)
93. schwarze --> 1891 Chicago Colts
94. pedrocerrano --> 1889 Washington Nationals
95. emanes10 --> 1888 Indianapolis Hoosiers
96. toysboys --> 1889 Columbus Salons
.
Round 5 (Friday schedule, all times EDT)
97. toysboys --> 1887 Fred Carroll (Pit)
98. emanes10 --> 1888 Ed McKean (Cle)
99. pedrocerrano --> 1885 Dupee Shaw (Prov)
100. schwarze --> 1891 Mike Griffin (Brk)
101. footballmm11 --> 1890 Deacon McGuire (Roch)
102. nocomm999 --> 1888 Ed Morris (Pit)
103. BeAllEndAll --> 1890 Phenomenal Smith (Pit)
104. njbigwig --> 1888 George Keefe (Was)
105. DarthDurron --> 1885 Ezra Sutton (Bos)
106. pedrocerrano --> 1888 Ed Knouff (Cle)
107. footballmm11 --> 1887 Jimmy Say (Cle)
108. schwarze --> 1890 Jimmy Knowles (Roch)
109. redcped --> 1891 Pete Browning (Pit)
110. Taxman2008 --> 1891 Cupid Childs (Cle)
111. Bill_James47 --> 1885 Harry Porter (Brk)
112. kstober --> 1885 Charley "Old Hoss" Radbourn (Prov)
113. calhoop --> 1888 Jake Beckley (Pit)
114. Jtpsops --> 1887 Pop Smith (Pit)
115. richiebrown6 --> 1888 Sam Trott (Bal)
116. eman7400 --> 1890 Sandy Griffin (Roch)
117. ybjsports --> 1888 Oyster Burns (Bal)
118. njbigwig --> 1887 Jim Whitney (Was)
119. 3dayrotation --> 1889 Jim Fogarty (Phi)
120. mllama54 --> 1887 Alex McKinnon (Pit)

1885 Baltimore Orioles
1885 Boston Beaneaters (Ezra Sutton)
1885 Brooklyn Grays (Henry Porter)
1885 Buffalo Bisons
1885 Chicago White Stockings
1885 Cincinnati Red Stockings
1885 Detroit Wolverines
1885 Louisville Colonels
1885 New York Giants
1885 New York Metropolitans
1885 Philadelphia Athletics
1885 Philadelphia Quakers
1885 Pittsburgh Alleghenys
1885 Providence Grays (Dupee Shaw, Charley Radbourn)
1885 St. Louis Browns
1885 St. Louis Maroons
.
1886 Baltimore Orioles
1886 Boston Beaneaters
1886 Brooklyn Grays
1886 Chicago White Stockings
1886 Cincinnati Red Stockings
1886 Detroit Wolverines
1886 Kansas City Cowboys
1886 Louisville Colonels
1886 New York Giants
1886 New York Metropolitans
1886 Philadelphia Athletics
1886 Philadelphia Quakers
1886 Pittsburgh Alleghenys
1886 St. Louis Browns
1886 St. Louis Maroons
1886 Washington Nationals
.
1887 Baltimore Orioles
1887 Boston Beaneaters
1887 Brooklyn Dodgers
1887 Chicago White Stockings
1887 Cincinnati Red Stockings
1887 Cleveland Blues (Jimmy Say)
1887 Detroit Wolverines
1887 Indianapolis Hoosiers
1887 Louisville Colonels
1887 New York Giants
1887 New York Metropolitans
1887 Philadelphia Athletics
1887 Philadelphia Quakers
1887 Pittsburgh Alleghenys (Fred Carroll, Pop Smith, Alex McKinnon)
1887 St. Louis Browns
1887 Washington Nationals (Jim Whitney)
.
1888 Baltimore Orioles (Sam, Ttorr, Oyster Burns)
1888 Boston Beaneaters
1888 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
1888 Chicago White Stockings
1888 Cincinnati Red Stockings
1888 Cleveland Blues (Ed McKean, EdKnouff)
1888 Detroit Wolverines
1888 Indianapolis Hoosiers
1888 Kansas City Cowboys
1888 Louisville Colonels
1888 New York Giants
1888 Philadelphia Athletics
1888 Philadelphia Quakers
1888 Pittsburgh Alleghenys (Ed Morris, Jake Beckley)
1888 St. Louis Browns
1888 Washington Nationals (George Keefe)
.
1889 Baltimore Orioles
1889 Boston Beaneaters
1889 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
1889 Chicago White Stockings
1889 Cincinnati Red Stockings
1889 Cleveland Spiders
1889 Columbus Solons
1889 Indianapolis Hoosiers
1889 Kansas City Cowboys
1889 Louisville Colonels
1889 New York Giants
1889 Philadelphia Athletics
1889 Philadelphia Quakers (Jim Fogarty)
1889 Pittsburgh Alleghenys
1889 St. Louis Browns
1889 Washington Nationals

1890 Baltimore Orioles
1890 Boston Beaneaters
1890 Boston Reds
1890 Brooklyn Bridegrooms
1890 Brooklyn Gladiators
1890 Brooklyn Wonders
1890 Buffalo Bisons
1890 Chicago Colts
1890 Chicago Pirates
1890 Cincinnati Reds
1890 Cleveland Infants
1890 Cleveland Spiders
1890 Columbus Solons
1890 Louisville Colonels
1890 New York Giants (NL)
1890 New York Giants (PL)
1890 Philadelphia Athletics (AA)
1890 Philadelphia Athletics (PL)
1890 Philadelphia Phillies
1890 Pittsburgh Alleghenys (Phenomenal Smith)
1890 Pittsburgh Burghers
1890 Rochester Broncos (Deacon McGuire, Jimmy Knowles, Sandy Griffin)
1890 St. Louis Browns
1890 Syracuse Stars
1890 Toledo Maumees
.
1891 Baltimore Orioles
1891 Boston Beaneaters
1891 Boston Reds
1891 Brooklyn Bridegrooms (Mike Griffin)
1891 Chicago Colts
1891 Cincinnati Kelly's Killers
1891 Cincinnati Reds
1891 Cleveland Spiders (Cupid Childs)
1891 Columbus Solons
1891 Louisville Colonels
1891 Milwaukee Brewers
1891 New York Giants
1891 Philadelphia Athletics
1891 Philadelphia Phillies
1891 Pittsburgh Pirates (Pete Browning)
1891 St. Louis Browns
1891 Washington Statesmen

Division Alignment

NL East
1. schwarze - 1886 White Stockings, 1890 Reds, 1886 Maroons, 1890 Colts / 1891 Mike Griffin (Brk)
2. pedrocerrano - 1891 Reds, 1887 Colonels, 1885 Metropolitans, 1890 Spiders / 1888 Ed Knouff (Cle)
3. Bill_James47 - 1887 Giants, 1887 Red Stockings, 1890 Beaneaters, 1891 Statemen / 1885 Henry Porter (Brk)
4. 3dayrotation - 1888 Quakers, 1890 Giants (NL), 1886 Athletics, 1885 Maroons / 1889 Jim Fogarty (Phi)
.
NL Central
1. footballmm11 1886 Wolverines, 1890 Browns, 1890 Stars, 1890 Athletics (PL) / 1890 Deacon McGuire (Roch)
2. redcped - 1888 Wolverines, 1887 Beaneaters, 1886 Metropolitans, 1886 Nationals / 1891 Pete Browning (Pit)
3. Taxman2008 - 1890 Colonels, 1886 Colonels, 1889 Hoosiers, 1890 Athletics (AA) / 1891 Cupid Childs (Cle)
4. njbigwig - 1890 Colts, 1886 Giants, 1891 Phillies, 1890 Burghers / 1887 Jim Whitney (Was)
.
NL West
1. emanes10 - 1885 Giants, 1885 Wolverines, 1887 Athletics, 1888 Indianapolis / 1888 Ed McKean (Cle) / 1888 Ed McKean (Cle)
2. DarthDurron - 1890 Salons, 1890 Infants, 1890 Maumees, 1886 Red Stockings / 1885 Ezra Sutton (Bos)
3. calhoop - 1888 Red Stockings, 1888 Colonels, 1891 St. Louis Browns / 1888 Jake Beckley (Pit)
4. eman7400 - 1886 Alleghenys, 1889 Athletics, 1889 Red Stockings, 1890 Orioles / 1890 Sandy Griffin (Roch)
.
AL East
1. pedrocerrano - 1888 Giants, 1889 White Stockings, 1887 Orioles, 1899 Nationals / 1885 Dupee Shaw / 1885 Dupee Shaw (Prov)
2. kstober - 1885 Browns, 1890 Reds, 1889 Spiders, 1887 Quakers / 1885 Charley Radbourn (Prov)
3. Jtpsops - 1885 Cardinals, 1889 Beaneaters, 1887 White Stockings, 1885 Red Stockings / 1887 Pop Smith (Pit)
4. mllama54 - 1887 Wolverines, 1889 Browns, 1891 Giants, 1887 Metropolitans / 1887 Alex McKinnon (Pit)
.
AL Central
1. nocomm999 - 1885 White Stockings, 1888 Beaneaters, 1890 Bridegrooms / 1888 Ed Morris (Pit)
2. BeAllEndAll - 1888 Athletics, 1888 White Stockings, 1890 Wonders / 1890 Phenomenal Smith (Pit)
3. njbigwig - 1886 Browns, 1891 Brewers, 1885 Bisons, 1891 Athletics / 1888 George Keefe (Was)
4. footballmm11 - 1887 Browns, 1886 Quakers, 1887 Hoosiers, 1886 Orioles / 1887 Jimmy Say (Cle)
.
AL West
1. toysboys - 1888 Browns,1890 Philies, 1889 Orioles, 1889 Salons / 1887 Fred Carroll (Pit) / 1887 Fred Carroll
2. schwarze - 1889 Giants, 1885 Quakers, 1890 Pirates, 1889 Bridegrooms / 1890 Jimmy Knowles (Roch)
3. richiebrown6 - 1888 Bridegrooms, 1885 Alleghenys, 1891 Beaneaters, 1891 Orioles / 1888 Sam Trott (Bal)
4. ybjsports - 1885 Athletics, 1890 Giants (PL), 1891 Reds, 1891 Salons / 1888 Oyster Burns (Bal)

Can't pass up King Kelly and Cap Anson.

1886 Chicago White Stockings

(NL East)

FYI - I put my '88 Giants in the AL East

1886 Detroit Wolverines
NL Central

Posted by pedrocerrano on 6/7/2024 6:20:00 PM (view original):
FYI - I put my '88 Giants in the AL East

I switched my to NL East. I was going into the opposite east as you.

Via proxy, nocomm999 selects 1885 Chicago White Stockings and wants to be put into the last unclaimed division.

In this case, the AL Central

Don't expect it to get to me tonight, but won't be home until late.

Does anybody have any contact with BeAllEndAll? He hasn't opened any of my recent site-mails, including the one I sent on June 6. I'm not even sure he knows the draft has started.

Sorry fellas, I'm here. Been travelling. Pick coming shortly

1888 Philadelphia Athletics