This is a draft for the top 16 from round 1. Please select your league, franchise and season. Any season between 1901-2024 can be selected, except those seasons used in round 1.

12/21/2024 11:32 AM
These seasons were used in round 1 and are not available in round 2. (Read down, then across - these are the round 1 divisions)
.
SFG League 1 NYY
1906 . 1919 . 1934 . 1967 . 1993 . 2005 . . . 1920 . 1930 . 1934 . 1955 . 1997 . 2005
1908 1920 1962 1968 1998 2007 1923 1931 1939 1979 1998 2006
1910 1927 1964 1969 2002 2009 1926 1932 1942 1984 2000 2016
1916 1933 1965 1970 2003 2011 1928 1933 1951 1996 2004 2021
. .
LAD League 2 BOS
1928 . 1955 . 1961 . 1980 . 2006 . 2020 1908 . 1915 . 1941 . 1972 . 1998 . 2002
1931 1956 1963 1992 2008 2021 1909 1936 1942 1974 1999 2003
1942 1957 1965 1993 2009 2022 1913 1939 1952 1980 2000 2004
1952 1960 1966 2002 2014 2024 1914 1940 1967 1986 2001 2017
. .
STL League 3 CLE
1926 . 1933 . 1946 . 1962 . 1970 . 2005 1902 . 1910 . 1921 . 1954 . 1995 . 2005
1927 1940 1947 1963 1985 2007 1903 1911 1922 1955 1996 2013
1928 1941 1948 1967 1990 2011 1905 1916 1949 1957 1997 2018
1929 1943 1961 1968 2001 2012 1909 1920 1950 1994 1999 2019
. .
PIT League 4 OAK
1901 . 1911 . 1922 . 1928 . 1956 . 1990 1902 . 1927 . 1931 . 1976 . 1990 . 2000
1903 1912 1923 1934 1961 1991 1908 1928 1970 1985 1991 2001
1907 1913 1926 1935 1977 1992 1909 1929 1972 1987 1992 2006
1910 1915 1927 1947 1986 2015 1912 1930 1975 1989 1999 2009
. .
CHC League 5 CHW
1906 . 1910 . 1919 . 1933 . 1970 . 1992 1904 . 1916 . 1933 . 1963 . 1991 . 2004
1907 1911 1926 1935 1986 2004 1909 1917 1935 1964 1993 2008
1908 1913 1929 1940 1988 2005 1913 1918 1959 1967 1994 2010
1909 1916 1930 1966 1991 2017 1915 1919 1961 1986 1997 2022
. .
ATL League 6 DET
1916 . 1946 . 1959 . 1972 . 1998 . 2002 1905 . 1921 . 1937 . 1945 . 1968 . 2011
1917 1949 1960 1995 1999 2003 1914 1924 1939 1960 2008 2012
1928 1957 1964 1996 2000 2019 1915 1926 1940 1963 2009 2013
1935 1958 1966 1997 2001 2023 1920 1936 1941 1967 2010 2014
. .
PHI League 7 BAL
1911 . 1917 . 1967 . 1982 . 2010 . 2020 1909 . 1918 . 1933 . 1967 . 1973 . 1997
1913 1930 1976 1983 2011 2022 1915 1919 1961 1969 1976 1998
1915 1957 1979 2004 2018 2023 1916 1920 1964 1970 1981 2012
1916 1964 1981 2009 2019 2024 1917 1924 1966 1971 1995 2013
. .
CIN League 8 MIN
1902 . 1926 . 1959 . 1974 . 1979 . 2000 1915 . 1923 . 1927 . 1965 . 1970 . 2006
1913 1932 1964 1975 1980 2006 1916 1924 1928 1967 1987 2007
1916 1939 1972 1977 1988 2007 1918 1925 1933 1968 1988 2020
1921 1941 1973 1978 1989 2019 1922 1926 1946 1969 2005 2021
12/21/2024 7:16 PM (edited)
Draft Order and Team Selection for the Top 16 Draft
12/21/2024 11:41 AM
Draft Order & Team Selection for Top 16 Draft
.
1 schwarze - 1912 Chicago Cubs (Lg 5)
2 pedrocerrano - 1993 Atlanta Braves (Lg 6)
3 schwarze - 1911 Boston Braves (Lg 6)
4 jfranco77 - 2007 New York Yankees (Lg 1)
5 pedrocerrano - 1914 Pittsburgh Pirates (Lg 4)
6 3dayrotation - 1959 Los Angeles Dodgers (Lg 2)
7 redcped - 2004 Minnesota Twins (Lg 8)
8 footballmm11 - 2004 St. Louis Cardinals (Lg 3)
9 pedrocerrano - 1920 Chicago White Sox (Lg 5)
10 crazyamos - 1919 Cleveland Indians (Lg 3)
11 calhoop - 1912 Washington Senators (Lg 8)
12 barracuda3 - 2017 Los Angeles Dodgers (Lg 2)
13 schwarze - 1907 New York Giants (Lg 1)
14 toysboys - 1942 St. Louis Cardinals (Lg 3)
15 pedrocerrano - 1913 Cleveland Naps (Lg 3)
16 glowguy - 1919 Cincinnati Reds (Lg 8)
12/23/2024 10:32 PM (edited)
Based on how all the similar seasons did in round 1, I think my best choice is...

League #5
1912 Cubs
12/21/2024 6:51 PM
Posted by schwarze on 12/21/2024 6:51:00 PM (view original):
Based on how all the similar seasons did in round 1, I think my best choice is...

League #5
1912 Cubs
First team I had landed on in my (thus far) limited research. I guess there was no way they'd fall to me.
12/21/2024 8:29 PM
I will try my best to keep things moving along but have had company for the last week, and will have a full house all day tomorrow. I'm going to try to make this pick late tonight or tomorrow morning (CA time). Sorry for the delay.
12/21/2024 10:15 PM
1993 Atlanta Braves
12/22/2024 2:11 AM
Yep, that 1993 Braves team was definitely on my short list. But I had a backup Braves team ready to go. He's no Ed Walsh, but Cy Young should do ok in this league.

League 6
1911 Boston (Braves)

As you know, the Braves franchise has had a number of different nicknames during it's history... Boston Reds (1876), Boston Nationals (1901-06), Boston Doves (1907-10) and the Boston Bees (1936-40). What I never realized is that according to baseball-reference, this Boston team did not have a nickname in 1911 (or in the years 1877-1900).

12/22/2024 9:46 AM

Since I'm not involved with the Top 16, if any of you guys want to send me a proxy choice/list, I'll be on here most of the afternoon.


12/22/2024 12:55 PM
Posted by thejuice6 on 12/22/2024 12:55:00 PM (view original):

Since I'm not involved with the Top 16, if any of you guys want to send me a proxy choice/list, I'll be on here most of the afternoon.


Same.

Berween juice and I, someone should be good to post picks expediently.
12/22/2024 12:57 PM
jfranco77 hasn't opened the sitemail I sent yesterday at 2:30 pm. It's tough being this close to the holidays.
12/22/2024 1:04 PM
Posted by schwarze on 12/22/2024 1:04:00 PM (view original):
jfranco77 hasn't opened the sitemail I sent yesterday at 2:30 pm. It's tough being this close to the holidays.
gives me plenty of time to line up some wrong choices...

don't think i've done well enough to face this kind of pressure before...
12/22/2024 2:23 PM
With four picks in this Top 16, at least this is giving PEDRO some extra time to do some research.

12/22/2024 4:36 PM
My Pirates team ended the regular season on a 2-7 run, which was just bad enough to drop enough spots to ensure that I won't get one of the teams I want.
12/22/2024 6:32 PM
1234 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.