The Shuffle

16 Team Format E (4/4 w/interleague play)
Seasons: 1955-2024
All Players must be less than $13M.

To start: Everyone will select a Franchise. No duplicates.
Select 4 exclusive players from your Franchise: 1 Infielder, 1 Outfielder, 1 Starting Pitcher (SP), 1 Relief Pitcher (RP).
We'll then have a 21 round draft and each round we'll Shuffle the Franchises randomly for each pick. (So, if the Tigers, Cubs and Astros are 3 of the Franchises chosen, in round 1 you might pick from the Cubs, round 2 from the Astros, round 3 from the Cubs again, round 4 the Tigers and so on).

I will Shuffle the Franchises between rounds. (Only the 16 Franchises chosen will be used).
Each owner will get a 1 of the 16 Franchises to pick from so only 1 player per Franchise will be chosen each round.
You will have 1 day to make your pick starting immediately after I post the Franchises for that round. There will be no waiting for someone before you.
If you don't make your pick by the time I post the next round, whoever has that Franchise in that next round can make their pick. Missed picks can be made up at anytime but all picks made before that are valid.

The 4 players chosen before the Draft are exclusive for that Franchise. (Verlander could be chosen for the Tigers and the Astros).
Players taken in the draft are only exclusive by season, so you must state which season you are taking when you make your pick.
(Example: If Mike Trout is taken as 1 of the 4 exclusives, he is off-the-board. If he isn't 1 of the 4, then multiple versions of him can be taken in the draft).

No Salary Cap
No Clones
Yes DH
No AAA
No WW
Injuries On
Any Stadium
Alignment for the league will be done by Salary, (Highest in the NLEast, Lowest in the ALWest).
1/1/2025 1:33 PM (edited)
This is the 2nd iteration of this league.
Owners from Season 1 have first dibs on spots for Season 2.
Waitlisted Owners have 2nd dibs.
If you want in, signup to be put on the Waitlist.
New Owners will select their Franchise last.

All of the 4 Main Players from the 1st season will be Blacklisted. They are in the post below.
So if you want one of those Franchises you cannot use the Blacklisted versions of those 4 players.

Owners (S1) Bold is returning
1.slim senior
2.grayfoxx
3.mllama54
4.pmars2001
5.thejuice6
6.3dayrotation
7.bheid408
8.trumbull
9.Dougsdawgs13
10.nocomm999
11.ff09
12.jbar8888
13.schwarze
14.mensu1954
15.calhoop
16.Jtpsops

Waitlist
1.pmwksw
2.akira_hokuto
3.benfc
4.ronthegenius
5.ybjsports

Waitlist S2

1.dvorr80
1/7/2025 9:12 AM (edited)
Astros = 94JeffBagwell, 01LanceBerkman, 86MikeScott, 99BillyWagner
Athletics = 01JasonGiambi, 90RickeyHenderson, 72CatfishHunter, 90DennisEckersley
BlueJays = 00CarlosDelgado, 11JoseBautista, 97RogerClemens, 17RobertoOsuna
Braves = 08ChipperJones, 59HankAaron, 98GregMaddux, 12CraigKimbrel
Cardinals = 98MarkMcGwire, 85WillieMcGee, 85JohnTudor, 22RyanHelsley
Cubs = 59ErnieBanks, 01SammySosa, 15JakeArrieta, 77BruceSutter
Dodgers = 97MikePiazza, 55DukeSnider, 63SandyKoufax, 03EricGagne
Expos/Nats = 19AnthonyRendon, 15BryceHarper, 97PedroMartinez, 18SeanDoolittle
Giants = 69WillieMcCovey, 03BarryBonds, 66JuanMarichal, 11SergioRomo
Indians = 99OmarVizquel, 58RockyColovito, 68LuisTiant, 24EmmanuelClase
Padres = 96KenCaminiti, 94TonyGwynn, 20DinelsonLamet, 98TrevorHoffman
RedSox = 87WadeBoggs, 57TedWilliams, 99PedroMartinez, 13KojiUehara
Reds = 75JoeMorgan, 62FrankRobinson, 20TrevorBauer, 12AroldisChapman
Tigers = 61NormCash, 59AlKaline, 11JustinVerlander, 84WillieHernandez
Twins = 77RodCarew, 88KirbyPuckett, 04JohanSantana, 06JoeNathan
Yankees = 07AlexRodriguez, 61MickeyMantle, 78RonGuidry, 08MarianoRivera
1/1/2025 11:05 AM (edited)
All 30 Franchises are available to pick from in Season 2, the 14 Franchises not used in Season 1 will have all of their players available to use.
1/1/2025 11:03 AM
Interesting. So if I join, when do I select my franchise/players?
1/1/2025 3:22 PM
I’ll join the waitlist
1/1/2025 4:10 PM
Posted by ybjsports on 1/1/2025 3:22:00 PM (view original):
Interesting. So if I join, when do I select my franchise/players?
Returning Owners will be selecting first, so it depends on how many return. They have until Sunday to claim their spot. So far, pmars2001 and schwarze are not playing season 2.
pmwksw is the first new owner
waiting to hear from akira_hokuto
benfc is next
1/1/2025 8:00 PM
I am in from waitlist if there is an opening
1/2/2025 9:20 AM
Are the blacklisted players blacklisted for the entire league? Or are they draftable for other teams?
1/2/2025 11:56 AM
Please add me to the waitlist
1/2/2025 11:59 AM
Posted by ff09 on 1/2/2025 11:56:00 AM (view original):
Are the blacklisted players blacklisted for the entire league? Or are they draftable for other teams?
You cannot use the specific years that are blacklisted. So for example, ARod's 2007 season is blacklisted, but you can draft any of his Yankees seasons other than 2007, as well as his Mariners and Rangers seasons (if you select those franchises).
1/2/2025 12:37 PM
Posted by Jtpsops on 1/2/2025 12:38:00 PM (view original):
Posted by ff09 on 1/2/2025 11:56:00 AM (view original):
Are the blacklisted players blacklisted for the entire league? Or are they draftable for other teams?
You cannot use the specific years that are blacklisted. So for example, ARod's 2007 season is blacklisted, but you can draft any of his Yankees seasons other than 2007, as well as his Mariners and Rangers seasons (if you select those franchises).
If i select the A's, of course I can't take those players/years. But if I pick the Cubs, and during the draft, the A's come up, I still can't take those guys for those years. Correct?
1/2/2025 2:27 PM
Posted by ff09 on 1/2/2025 2:27:00 PM (view original):
Posted by Jtpsops on 1/2/2025 12:38:00 PM (view original):
Posted by ff09 on 1/2/2025 11:56:00 AM (view original):
Are the blacklisted players blacklisted for the entire league? Or are they draftable for other teams?
You cannot use the specific years that are blacklisted. So for example, ARod's 2007 season is blacklisted, but you can draft any of his Yankees seasons other than 2007, as well as his Mariners and Rangers seasons (if you select those franchises).
If i select the A's, of course I can't take those players/years. But if I pick the Cubs, and during the draft, the A's come up, I still can't take those guys for those years. Correct?
That is correct. Blacklist is for the entire league.
1/2/2025 2:50 PM
This filled so quickly the first time. I’m surprised everyone’s not returning.
1/3/2025 9:10 AM
Posted by Jtpsops on 1/3/2025 9:10:00 AM (view original):
This filled so quickly the first time. I’m surprised everyone’s not returning.
Blacklist may have something to do with that. The way I see it, the blacklist makes the 14 Franchises not chosen in Season 1 more competitve and possibly better options. That's a good thing.
1/3/2025 4:22 PM
12 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.