Two owners are overloaded on active teams so we have a couple openings. The league is entering its 61st season and will be drafting in a couple weeks. Here's a quick summary:
  • 12 team league
  • Exactly 15 keepers, which means there is always talent available in the draft, allowing to rebuild quickly.
  • Draft order is in reverse order of keeper salary, with a lottery for the top six picks in the draft, so no incentive to tank!
  • The drafts happen during the prior season, so you're always right back in action for the new season
The rosters and full league rules are below, sign up now!
12/15/2025 10:10 AM
Detroit
Aaron Robinson C
Wes Westrum C
Eddie Robinson 1B
Red Schoendienst 2B
Hank Thompson 2B, IR eligible
Frankie Gustine 3B
Luke Appling SS
Bob Kennedy OF
Bobby Thomson OF
Dick Wakefield OF
Pat Mullin OF
Vic Wertz OF
Al Benton P
Dave Koslo P
Elmer Riddle P
Gerry Staley P
Hugh Casey P
Nels Potter P
Randy Gumpert P
Ray Scarborough P
Sam Zoldak P
Ted Wilks P
Tom Ferrick P
Fred Martin P, IR eligible

Pittsburgh
Yogi Berra C
Mickey Owen C, IR eligible
Mickey Vernon 1B
Bobby Adams 2B
Danny Murtaugh 2B
Emil Verban 2B
Eddie Yost 3B
Sam Dente SS
Charlie Keller OF
Hank Edwards OF
Johnny Lindell OF
Johnny Wyrostek OF
Richie Ashburn OF
Wally Moses OF
Catfish Metkovich OF/1B, IR eligible
Al Gettel P
Bill Voiselle P
Billy Pierce P
Bob Rush P
Joe Haynes P
Rip Sewell P
Tommy Byrne P

12/15/2025 11:31 AM (edited)
League Format: Alternate WIS Format E (162 games, 12 teams, NL:6/0/0, AL:6/0/0, balanced, interleague)
Keepers: Exactly 15 keepers plus unlimited IR, due by game 100.
- If you are keeping a player with a split season, you need to specify which version you plan to use, and then you will be locked into using that version the next season. If such a player is traded during the next year's draft, the player's new owner can use any version they choose.


Draft:

- The draft will be 10 rounds with 12 picks each round. The draft order will be determined by the total salary of 15 keepers and IR players (50% of value of next active season salary), with the lowest salary picking first, the second lowest picking second, etc. in all rounds except the first.

- WWII rule: the IR player tax will be reduced to 25% of next active season salary during WWII (1942-1945).

- The top six picks of the first round will be determined by an equally-weighted lottery of the lowest six keeper salaries.

- If an owner cannot keep the full 15 players, there will be a penalty of $1 million added to the keeper salary total for each player the owner is short.

- Any trades during the draft must result in all parties to the trade ending up with exactly 25 players at the conclusion of the 10th round of the draft, so there will be no extra picks added on like in some other leagues. For example, if I traded a second round pick for two third round picks, I would need to give up one additional draft pick or a keeper to make the trade valid.

- In the event an owner cannot keep 15 players, they will make any additional needed picks after the 10th round is complete.

- If the commissioner incorrectly does not cross off a keeper on the draft board, and that keeper is drafted by someone else, the owner who drafted the player will get the player in question and the owner who kept the player will lose him and be given a compensatory pick. The exception to this rule is if the error is noticed before any more players are picked.

AAA: 6/2 below average, randomly generated, real names
Injuries: On
DH: Off
Waiver Wire: Off
Add/Drop after the draft: No
Transaction Deadline: Off (midnight EST after game 159)
Trades: Yes, deadline is game 100, draft picks can only be traded one season in advance. Any trades involving draft picks before the draft must leave each team with exactly 10 picks. Also, each team must have a minimum of 22 real MLB players at all times (majors or minors it does not matter). Otherwise, non-contending teams would be dumping all 10 non-keepers for pennies on the dollar. Trades can also be vetoed if six or more owners vote against it (but please reserve this for outrageously lopsided trades, call it the arvidjosef rule.)

Note that the trading deadline above applies to trades of players within the ongoing season. There is a moratorium on trading between the in-season trade deadline until the draft board and order is fully posted. Once the draft begins (which will be after the trading deadline but before the end of the season) owners are free to trade draft picks and keepers, and all such trades involving keepers will not take effect until the following season.

Stadium: Must use a stadium active in that MLB season. When a stadium becomes obsolete, you can relocate to any available stadium in your league, and you will never be forced to move to the stadium of a different franchise unless that franchise has been contracted (for example, if you're in Yankee Stadium (II) you're guaranteed Yankee Stadium (I) if you want it). Returning owners are allowed to change stadiums one time (other than when a stadium becomes obsolete).
12/15/2025 10:13 AM
I don't know why, but I feel compelled to take the Pittsburgh team...
12/15/2025 11:18 AM
welcome!
12/15/2025 11:31 AM
still one team available!
12/16/2025 4:05 PM

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2025 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.