Players Taken
.
Aguirre, Hank 1962 Crawford, Sam 1907 Hernandez, Willie 1984 Rodriguez, Ivan 2004
Alburquerque, Al 2011 Crawford, Sam 1909 Hernandez, Willie 1985 Rowe, Schoolboy 1935
Alexander, Dale 1932 Crawford, Sam 1911 Hiller, John 1973 Sanchez, Anibal 2013
Alexander, Doyle 1987 partial Cullenbine, Roy 1946 Hoeft, Billy 1955 Sanchez, Anibal 2014
Avila, Alex 2011 Donovan, Bill 1903 Holton, Tyler 2023 Saucier, Kevin 1981
Barrett, Jimmy 1903 Donovan, Bill 1908 Holton, Tyler 2024 Scherzer, Max 2013
Bassler, Johnny 1924 Elberfeld, Kid 1903 partial Hurter, Brant 2024 Siever, Ed 1902
Benoit, Joaquin 2013 Evers, Hoot 1950 Kaline, Al 1955 Skubal, Tarik 2023
Boland, Bernie 1918 Farnsworth, Kyle 2005 Kaline, Al 1959 Skubal, Tarik 2024
Boone, Ray 1953 Fidrych, Mark 1976 Kaline, Al 1961 Skubal, Tarik 2025
Boone, Ray 1956 Fielder, Prince 2012 Kaline, Al 1962 Smyly, Drew 2013
Bridges, Tommy 1943 Fister, Doug 2011 Kaline, Al 1966 Summers, Champ 1979
Brocail, Doug 1998 Flaherty, Jack 2024 partial Kaline, Al 1967 Summers, Ed 1909
Brocail, Doug 1999 Fothergill, Bob 1926 Kell, George 1949 Thompson, Justin 1997
Brown, Gates 1968 Fothergill, Bob 1927 Kell, George 1950 Trammell, Alan 1983
Cabrera, Miguel 2010 Freehan, Bill 1964 Killian, Ed 1909 Trammell, Alan 1984
Cabrera, Miguel 2011 Freehan, Bill 1967 Kuenn, Harvey 1959 Trammell, Alan 1986
Cabrera, Miguel 2012 Gehringer, Charlie 1929 LeFlore, Ron 1976 Trammell, Alan 1987
Cabrera, Miguel 2013 Gehringer, Charlie 1930 Lolich, Mickey 1967 Trammell, Alan 1990
Cabrera, Miguel 2015 Gehringer, Charlie 1933 Lolich, Mickey 1969 Trammell, Alan 1993
Cabrera, Miguel 2016 Gehringer, Charlie 1934 Manush, Heinie 1926 Trout, Dizzy 1943
Cash, Norm 1961 Gehringer, Charlie 1935 Martinez, J.D. 2017 Trout, Dizzy 1944
Cavet, Pug 1914 Gehringer, Charlie 1936 Martinez, Victor 2011 Trucks, Virgil 1943
Cisnero, Jose 2020 Gehringer, Charlie 1937 Martinez, Victor 2014 Trucks, Virgil 1949
Cobb, Ty 1909 Gehringer, Charlie 1938 McAuliffe, Dick 1966 Turnbull, Spencer 2021
Cobb, Ty 1910 Gehringer, Charlie 1939 McCosky, Barney 1939 Veach, Bobby 1919
Cobb, Ty 1911 Gehringer, Charlie 1940 McCosky, Barney 1940 Veach, Bobby 1921
Cobb, Ty 1912 Granderson, Curtis 2007 McLain, Denny 1965 Verlander, Justin 2009
Cobb, Ty 1913 Greenberg, Hank 1934 McLain, Denny 1968 Verlander, Justin 2010
Cobb, Ty 1914 Greenberg, Hank 1935 McLain, Denny 1969 Verlander, Justin 2011
Cobb, Ty 1915 Greenberg, Hank 1937 McMahon, Don 1968 Verlander, Justin 2012
Cobb, Ty 1916 Greenberg, Hank 1938 Mullin, George 1909 Verlander, Justin 2016
Cobb, Ty 1917 Greenberg, Hank 1939 Newhouser, Hal 1944 Wakefield, Dick 1944
Cobb, Ty 1918 Greenberg, Hank 1940 Newhouser, Hal 1945 Whitaker, Lou 1983
Cobb, Ty 1919 Guillen, Carlos 2004 Newhouser, Hal 1946 Willett, Ed 1909
Cobb, Ty 1921 Guillen, Carlos 2005 Newhouser, Hal 1948 Willett, Ed 1910
Cobb, Ty 1922 Guillen, Carlos 2006 Ordonez, Magglio 2007 Wilson, Earl 1966 partial
Cobb, Ty 1925 Heilmann, Harry 1921 Petry, Dan 1985 Wingo, Al 1925
Cochrane, Mickey 1935 Heilmann, Harry 1922 Phillips, Tony 1991 Winter, George 1908 partial
Colavito, Rocky 1961 Heilmann, Harry 1923 Phillips, Tony 1993 York, Rudy 1937
Collins, Rip 1924 Heilmann, Harry 1925 Polanco, Placido 2005 York, Rudy 1938
Coveleski, Harry 1915 Heilmann, Harry 1926 Polanco, Placido 2007
Coveleski, Harry 1916 Heilmann, Harry 1927 Price, David 2015
1/24/2026 6:11 PM (edited)
Draft Results
.
ROUND 1
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
emanes10 Newhouser, Hal 1946 11,367,771 11,367,771
ronthegenius Newhouser, Hal 1945 12,019,176 12,019,176
Jtpsops Skubal, Tarik 2025 7,328,295 7,328,295
3dayrotation Kell, George 1949 7,144,657 7,144,657
footballmm11 Cobb, Ty 1911 21,147,360 21,147,360
mllama54 Verlander, Justin 2011 10,025,297 10,025,297
bigsteve12 Skubal, Tarik 2024 6,924,876 6,924,876
pedrocerrano Cash, Norm 1961 10,581,600 10,581,600
schwarze Fidrych, Mark 1976 7,189,617 7,189,617
chewy3344 McLain, Denny 1968 11,732,050 11,732,050
calhoop Hernandez, Willie 1984 5,942,198 5,942,198
DarthDurron Siever, Ed 1902 7,638,033 7,638,033
ff09 Rodriguez, Ivan 2004 5,279,116 5,279,116
nocomm999 Aguirre, Hank 1962 7,388,263 7,388,263
njbigwig Trammell, Alan 1987 7,544,556 7,544,556
thejuice6 Holton, Tyler 2024 3,884,696 3,884,696
.
ROUND 2
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
thejuice6 Cobb, Ty 1917 11,838,216 15,722,912
ff09 Guillen, Carlos 2004 6,228,956 11,508,072
calhoop Cullenbine, Roy 1946 4,743,142 10,685,340
bigsteve12 Heilmann, Harry 1923 9,886,067 16,810,943
3dayrotation Scherzer, Max 2013 8,043,795 15,188,452
schwarze Trout, Dizzy 1944 12,144,583 19,334,200
Jtpsops Holton, Tyler 2023 3,169,534 10,497,829
nocomm999 Cobb, Ty 1912 10,328,469 17,716,732
njbigwig Cabrera, Miguel 2013 8,208,030 15,752,586
DarthDurron Gehringer, Charlie 1937 9,761,210 17,399,243
mllama54 Cobb, Ty 1915 10,014,468 20,039,765
pedrocerrano Gehringer, Charlie 1934 8,405,547 18,987,147
emanes10 Cobb, Ty 1910 10,116,322 21,484,093
chewy3344 Guillen, Carlos 2006 5,643,924 17,375,974
ronthegenius Granderson, Curtis 2007 7,563,829 19,583,005
footballmm11 Donovan, Bill 1903 11,473,890 32,621,250
.
ROUND 3
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
Jtpsops Cobb, Ty 1921 8,493,798 18,991,627
calhoop Skubal, Tarik 2023 3,274,659 13,959,999
ff09 Gehringer, Charlie 1936 8,790,578 20,298,650
3dayrotation Verlander, Justin 2012 7,527,750 22,716,202
thejuice6 Greenberg, Hank 1938 8,969,245 24,692,157
njbigwig Heilmann, Harry 1927 8,076,202 23,828,788
bigsteve12 Cobb, Ty 1922 9,497,786 26,308,729
chewy3344 Cabrera, Miguel 2012 7,555,969 24,931,943
DarthDurron Verlander, Justin 2016 7,170,342 24,569,585
nocomm999 Coveleski, Harry 1916 9,244,303 26,961,035
pedrocerrano Ordonez, Magglio 2007 7,904,611 26,891,758
schwarze Summers, Ed 1909 9,928,631 29,262,831
ronthegenius Gehringer, Charlie 1929 7,246,087 26,829,092
mllama54 Greenberg, Hank 1937 9,318,423 29,358,188
emanes10 Fister, Doug 2011 6,521,929 28,006,022
footballmm11 Newhouser, Hal 1944 10,291,106 42,912,356
.
ROUND 4
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop Phillips, Tony 1993 7,407,357 21,367,356
Jtpsops Heilmann, Harry 1925 7,434,199 26,425,826
ff09 Willett, Ed 1909 8,250,921 28,549,571
3dayrotation Cabrera, Miguel 2011 7,420,703 30,136,905
njbigwig Crawford, Sam 1911 6,935,332 30,764,120
DarthDurron York, Rudy 1938 6,051,333 30,620,918
thejuice6 Cabrera, Miguel 2010 6,679,761 31,371,918
chewy3344 Alexander, Doyle 1987 partial 3,522,588 28,454,531
bigsteve12 Greenberg, Hank 1935 8,111,519 34,420,248
ronthegenius McCosky, Barney 1940 6,865,667 33,694,759
pedrocerrano Cobb, Ty 1916 8,390,432 35,282,190
nocomm999 Heilmann, Harry 1921 7,821,622 34,782,657
emanes10 Kaline, Al 1959 7,946,198 35,952,220
schwarze Kaline, Al 1961 8,154,811 37,417,642
mllama54 Cochrane, Mickey 1935 5,067,943 34,426,131
footballmm11 Greenberg, Hank 1940 8,004,288 50,916,644
.
ROUND 5
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop Martinez, Victor 2014 6,006,460 27,373,816
Jtpsops Gehringer, Charlie 1930 7,343,176 33,769,002
chewy3344 Price, David 2015 6,665,392 35,119,923
ff09 Cobb, Ty 1913 7,725,972 36,275,543
3dayrotation Donovan, Bill 1908 7,048,025 37,184,930
DarthDurron Thompson, Justin 1997 6,432,986 37,053,904
njbigwig Cobb, Ty 1918 9,965,488 40,729,608
thejuice6 Heilmann, Harry 1922 5,353,727 36,725,645
ronthegenius Wingo, Al 1925 5,895,697 39,590,456
bigsteve12 McCosky, Barney 1939 7,026,324 41,446,572
mllama54 Kaline, Al 1955 7,016,429 41,442,560
nocomm999 Trammell, Alan 1984 5,691,258 40,473,915
pedrocerrano Wakefield, Dick 1944 4,028,844 39,311,034
emanes10 Phillips, Tony 1991 6,978,737 42,930,957
schwarze Cobb, Ty 1909 8,130,997 45,548,639
footballmm11 Manush, Heinie 1926 6,466,965 57,383,609
.
ROUND 6
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop Hiller, John 1973 4,760,215 32,134,031
Jtpsops Cabrera, Miguel 2015 5,507,123 39,276,125
chewy3344 Rowe, Schoolboy 1935 9,809,379 44,929,302
ff09 Killian, Ed 1909 4,434,087 40,709,630
thejuice6 Kaline, Al 1967 5,678,550 42,404,195
DarthDurron Boone, Ray 1953 5,809,888 42,863,792
3dayrotation Trucks, Virgil 1949 8,625,255 45,810,185
pedrocerrano Martinez, J.D. 2017 5,146,748 44,457,782
ronthegenius Bassler, Johnny 1924 4,754,574 44,345,030
nocomm999 Cabrera, Miguel 2016 6,482,223 46,956,138
njbigwig Gehringer, Charlie 1935 7,122,960 47,852,568
mllama54 Petry, Dan 1985 6,471,380 47,913,940
bigsteve12 Gehringer, Charlie 1933 6,627,891 48,074,463
emanes10 Alexander, Dale 1932 5,254,121 48,185,078
schwarze Veach, Bobby 1919 7,033,185 52,581,824
footballmm11 Gehringer, Charlie 1939 4,757,088 62,140,697
.
ROUND 7
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop McLain, Denny 1969 8,955,519 41,089,550
Jtpsops Saucier, Kevin 1981 2,901,818 42,177,943
ff09 Lolich, Mickey 1967 5,777,034 46,486,664
thejuice6 Boone, Ray 1956 5,146,837 47,551,032
DarthDurron Cobb, Ty 1919 7,799,395 50,663,187
ronthegenius Crawford, Sam 1909 6,111,554 50,456,584
pedrocerrano Greenberg, Hank 1939 6,246,531 50,704,313
chewy3344 Greenberg, Hank 1934 6,847,666 51,776,968
3dayrotation Heilmann, Harry 1926 5,869,474 51,679,659
nocomm999 Farnsworth, Kyle 2005 2,554,631 49,510,769
njbigwig Fielder, Prince 2012 5,525,067 53,377,635
mllama54 Polanco, Placido 2007 6,730,538 54,644,478
bigsteve12 Veach, Bobby 1921 7,095,344 55,169,807
emanes10 Coveleski, Harry 1915 9,118,372 57,303,450
schwarze Barrett, Jimmy 1903 6,542,255 59,124,079
footballmm11 McAuliffe, Dick 1966 4,141,416 66,282,113
.
ROUND 8
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop Brown, Gates 1968 1,829,537 42,919,087
Jtpsops Fothergill, Bob 1926 4,333,035 46,510,978
ff09 Trucks, Virgil 1943 5,978,322 52,464,986
thejuice6 McLain, Denny 1965 5,974,361 53,525,393
nocomm999 Evers, Hoot 1950 6,777,009 56,287,778
ronthegenius Trout, Dizzy 1943 7,337,352 57,793,936
DarthDurron Wilson, Earl 1966 partial 5,668,880 56,332,067
pedrocerrano York, Rudy 1937 4,486,422 55,190,735
3dayrotation Willett, Ed 1910 6,049,188 57,728,847
chewy3344 Cobb, Ty 1925 6,121,852 57,898,820
njbigwig Kaline, Al 1966 6,107,240 59,484,875
mllama54 Hoeft, Billy 1955 6,557,627 61,202,105
bigsteve12 Hurter, Brant 2024 1,516,892 56,686,699
emanes10 Trammell, Alan 1983 5,616,755 62,920,205
schwarze Crawford, Sam 1907 6,471,632 65,595,711
footballmm11 Kaline, Al 1962 5,005,936 71,288,049
.
ROUND 9
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop Cobb, Ty 1914 5,432,344 48,351,431
Jtpsops Avila, Alex 2011 5,184,209 51,695,187
ff09 Kell, George 1950 6,747,832 59,212,818
thejuice6 Freehan, Bill 1964 5,856,327 59,381,720
pedrocerrano Brocail, Doug 1998 2,441,450 57,632,185
nocomm999 Bridges, Tommy 1943 5,733,927 62,021,705
DarthDurron Trammell, Alan 1990 5,867,374 62,199,441
bigsteve12 Martinez, Victor 2011 4,372,503 61,059,202
3dayrotation Guillen, Carlos 2005 2,631,533 60,360,380
ronthegenius Trammell, Alan 1986 5,762,683 63,556,619
chewy3344 Turnbull, Spencer 2021 1,740,209 59,639,029
njbigwig Freehan, Bill 1967 5,983,342 65,468,217
mllama54 Lolich, Mickey 1969 7,742,213 68,944,318
emanes10 Elberfeld, Kid 1903 partial 1,677,364 64,597,569
schwarze Gehringer, Charlie 1938 6,354,301 71,950,012
footballmm11 Polanco, Placido 2005 6,265,154 77,553,203
.
ROUND 10
Owner________ Player________ Salary_______ New Salary____
calhoop Verlander, Justin 2010 6,568,844 54,920,275
Jtpsops Flaherty, Jack 2024 partial 3,149,198 54,844,385
pedrocerrano Collins, Rip 1924 6,208,293 63,840,478
ff09 Cisnero, Jose 2020 2,900,987 62,113,805
thejuice6 Boland, Bernie 1918 6,985,752 66,367,472
chewy3344 Brocail, Doug 1999 2,830,704 62,469,733
3dayrotation Trammell, Alan 1993 3,911,297 64,271,677
bigsteve12 Benoit, Joaquin 2013 2,221,989 63,281,191
nocomm999 Sanchez, Anibal 2013 5,665,189 67,686,894
DarthDurron Hernandez, Willie 1985 3,719,724 65,919,165
ronthegenius Sanchez, Anibal 2014 4,015,829 67,572,448
emanes10 LeFlore, Ron 1976 5,408,368 70,005,937
njbigwig Newhouser, Hal 1948 8,274,115 73,742,332
mllama54 Gehringer, Charlie 1940 4,974,956 73,919,274
schwarze Smyly, Drew 2013 2,519,319 74,469,331
footballmm11 Summers, Champ 1979 2,752,506 80,305,709
1/24/2026 6:12 PM (edited)
ROUND 1
Owner________
1 emanes10
2 ronthegenius
3 Jtpsops
4 3dayrotation
5 footballmm11
6 mllama54
7 bigsteve12
8 pedrocerrano
9 schwarze
10 chewy3344
11 calhoop
12 DarthDurron
13 ff09
14 nocomm999
15 njbigwig
16 thejuice6
1/19/2026 10:36 PM
1946 Hal Newhouser - $11,367,771
1/20/2026 9:22 AM
I have no idea but I emanes always knows what he's doing so I guess I'll go with
1945 Hal Newhouser $12,019,176
1/20/2026 12:49 PM
2025 Tarik Skubal - $7,328,295
1/20/2026 1:55 PM
Kell, George 1949

sm please
1/20/2026 2:09 PM
Sm sent
1/20/2026 2:26 PM
1911 Ty Cobb $21,147,360
1/20/2026 2:44 PM
2011 Justin Verlander $10,025,297
1/20/2026 2:58 PM
2024 Tarik Skubal - $6,924,876
1/20/2026 3:37 PM (edited)
1961 Norm Cash - $10,581,600
1/20/2026 3:57 PM
Posted by pedrocerrano on 1/20/2026 3:57:00 PM (view original):
1961 Norm Cash - $10,581,600
that was my second choice, since there are so many Cobbs, but I have a soft spot for the most expensive version of guys, lol
1/20/2026 3:58 PM
I haven't picked yet, and I already hate my team. Need some time to figure out how to not hate my team.
1/20/2026 4:10 PM
Here's how not to hate a team. Pick a player that I like and that has done well for me in the past... Who cares if he's not really a first rounder talent. In round 1 of the draft tournament, he went 19-9 with a 3,97 ERA (playing home games at Palace of the Fans). He was the leader in the Cy Young race for most of the season... can't remember if he actually won it or not.

1976 Mark Fidrych, $7,189,617
1/20/2026 4:28 PM
1|2|3...15 Next ▸

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.