Post All Star Collapse Topic

i have 3 teams currently post all star collapsing.. one is 13-26, the other 14-25 and now the third is 1-6 and sinking like a stone. Pity is that 2 of them were (were) in 1st place. not so much anymore. Anyone with any experience with this? or does the SIM just like to toy with my feelings on the few times I have a team with a winning record. I currently have a team 36-18 and can't enjoy it because I know (think/bet) that the same thing will happen again. It's all a bit frustrating.
1/27/2026 6:36 PM
Without knowing the teams, it is hard to say.
Maybe you had some early overperformance and it is now normalizing.
Maybe the teams you have played recently are just better than prior.
Maybe opponents are overperforming. SIM has "seemed" to be incredibly streaky the past 4-5 years but I cannot identify a change so maybe just luck.
Maybe your teams just hit the road after being really tailored towards the home park....or vice versa.

I had a pretty good team do a W23 once. They were NOT that good but couldnt seem to lose. Have also recently had the leagues 2nd best record go on a L10 using basically the same lineups and not against great teams. It happens. However, the fact that all of your teams "seem" to be tanking at once, are they all similar players? Again, it could the venue of your recent games along w/ your opponents.

Net-Net, there are a lot of reasons you could be losing. This didnt answer your question but it was too broad. If you provide some specifics after taking a look at the things above, you will find a lot of owners here who will help and some who will just try to be funny and not help. The randomness is what makes is WHAT IF SPORTS and is why many play it.

1/29/2026 6:23 AM
oh i understand and i can L 10 all day, i've never (to my memory) W 10 in a row. i took the stuff you mentioned into account. and i still don't get it. maybe it is just bad management :). thanks for the reply. i can't wait to see the next team collapse (it's coming in about 15 games)
1/29/2026 6:55 AM
Post All Star Collapse Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.