Is there an expanded play-by-play like in Gridiron Dynasty, or some other way to see the players whom you had on the field for each snap and see their fatigue level for each play? I've seen the basic play-by-play, but that doesn't show you which players you had on the field for that play. In Gridiron Dynasty we have an expanded play-by-play that shows you which players were on the field, and it also shows you their fatigue level on that play. That's what I'm trying to find.

The reason that I'm so keen on seeing my players' fatigue levels on each play during games is because I have Peyton Manning with a 66 INT rating and an actual NFL interception percentage of only 2%, yet he is throwing interceptions at a much higher rate.

In the preseason he threw interceptions on 5% of his pass attempts and in the first half of today's Game # 1, his interception percentage is 7%.

I know that there could be other factors at play, but I suspect that the largest factor in throwing a higher rate of interceptions is QB fatigue. In order to suss this out, I really need to know what his fatigue level has been when attempting these passes.

I cannot find any way to see which of my players are on the field on any given play. I cannot find any way to see what their fatigue level is on any given play, nor at any point in a game.

I'm a bit lost trying to figure out why Manning's stats are so bad. I know that 2004 Peyton Manning doesn't suck as a SimLeague QB. Apparently I suck as a SimLeague coach.

Thankfully you finally found the play-by-play information.

But in answer to your fatigue level question: no
Although GP% and also ATT/game average play significant roles in determining fatigue situations.
Or, if your QB is running in the sim far more often than he did on average in real life, that'll also determine his fatigue level.