Same Roster Challenge - Player Selection Topic

Here is the link to the rules.

Site-mail list:

_JJP_; 3dayrotation; beauchamp; bigsteve12; contrarian23; DarthDurron; dhomard; ermocito; giannivanaco; happyhours; je3rd; just4me; mjoyce103; oldtimer59; redcped; schwarze
4/6/2026 11:45 AM (edited)
We will select 3 players per day. I will post the search criteria on this thread. You will perform the search and site-mail me your preferred choice for each search. I will review the choices and post three of the players (from each search) on this thread for the official vote. I will not vote, but I will break any ties. I will list the winners of the voting here...

Total Salary: $124,797,641

C: 1977 Ted Simmons, $6,938,311 (S)
1B: 1940 Johnny Mize, $7,490,553 (L)
2B: 1973 Joe Morgan, $8,216,504 (L)
3B: 2018 Jose Ramirez, $5,804,878 (S)
SS: 2007 Jimmy Rollins, $7,835,024 (S)
OF: 1981 Rickey Henderson, $7,650,489 (R)
OF: 1936 Joe Medwick, $7,964,662 (R)
OF: 1913 Tris Speaker, $8,512,877 (L)

Sub: 1933 Stan Hack, $743,928 (L)
Sub: 2016 Anthony Recker, $708,040 (R)
Sub: 2019 Austin Hays, $1,038,193 (R)
Sub: 2025 Tyler Tolbert, $368,041 (R)
Sub: 1942 Roy Cullenbine, $1,533,490 (S)

SP1: 1933 Carl Hubbell, $12,114,190 (L)
SP2: 2004 Johan Santana,$9,546,606 (L)
SP3: 2020 Shane Bieber, $9,586,963 (R)
SP4: 1907 Mordecai Brown, $8,232,577

RP1: 1976 Ron Reed, $4,634,423 (R)
RP2: 2018 Sean Doolittle, $2,566,363 (L)
RP3: 1998 Steve Reed, $2,238,709 (R)
RP4: 2020 Victor Gonzalez, $2,916,370 (L)
RP5: 1958 Hoyt Wilhelm, $1,820,609 (R)
RP6: 1991 Steve Howe, $1,813,650 (L)
RP7: 1966 Pat Jarvis, $2,495,577 (R)
RP8: 2016 Andrew Miller, $2,026,614 (L)
4/13/2026 5:45 PM (edited)
Batter 1
Min Games at OF: 0 (uncheck secondary positions)
PA/162: 700+
OBP#: .400+
Years 1961-2925
Salary: 7M to 8M
Search Results: 15 players
4/6/2026 12:14 PM (edited)
Starting Pitcher 1
SP
IP/162: 275+
Years: 1920-1960
Salary: 11M to 13M
Search Results: 14 players
4/6/2026 12:13 PM
Relief Pitcher 1
RP
IP/162: 100-150
ERC#: 0 to 2.60
Throws: Right-handed
Season Type: Full/Partial
Years: 1960-1979
Salary: 3M to 5M
IP/G: 2 to 3
Search Results: 19 players
4/6/2026 12:52 PM (edited)
Posted by schwarze on 4/6/2026 12:24:00 PM (view original):
Relief Pitcher 1
RP
IP/162: 100-150
ERC#: 0 to 2.60
Throws: Right-handed
Season Type: Full/Partial
Years: 1960-1979
IP/G: 2 to 3
Search Results: 19 players
Anyone else getting 23 results here?
4/6/2026 12:45 PM
Sorry, forgot the salary limit. The link at the top of each page should be accurate.
4/6/2026 12:52 PM
Posted by schwarze on 4/6/2026 12:52:00 PM (view original):
Sorry, forgot the salary limit. The link at the top of each page should be accurate.
Got it, thanks. Didn't affect the nomination I sent you.
4/6/2026 12:59 PM
Choose who you want for Batter 1.
Votes: 17
(Last vote received: 4/7/2026 1:19 PM)
4/6/2026 7:21 PM
Choose who you want for Starting Pitcher 2
Votes: 16
(Last vote received: 4/7/2026 7:46 AM)
4/6/2026 7:21 PM
Choose who you want as Relief Pitcher 1
Votes: 16
(Last vote received: 4/7/2026 7:46 AM)
4/6/2026 7:22 PM
I added a "See Results" option since I am not voting. Plus, anybody not in this league that happens to stumble upon this thread can also "see results" without polluting the voting.
4/6/2026 7:23 PM
Batter 2
Min Games at C: 0 (uncheck secondary positions)
PA/162: 600+
Salary: 6M to 7M
CSPCT: 0.35 to 1
Search Results: 14 players
4/7/2026 9:47 AM
Relief Pitcher 2
Min Games at RP: 0
WHIP#: 0 to 0.90
Salary: 2M to 4M
Throws: Left-handed
K/9: 10+
IP/G: 0.97 to 1.10
Search Results: 13 players
4/7/2026 10:01 AM
Pinch Hitter
Min Games at All: 0 (uncheck secondary positions)
PA/162: 0-100
Salary: 500K to 750K
Bats: Left-handed
Range: 0 to 2
OPS+: 125+
Search Results: 19 players
4/7/2026 10:10 AM
123456 Next ▸
Same Roster Challenge - Player Selection Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.