MVP & Cy Young Award Winners, Draft Tournament Topic

schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
These are the top players in the MVP and Cy Young awards from the most recent draft tournament. I wanted to post these before the leagues go away. Even when I link leagues, once the league disappears, you can no longer view the awards.
8/20/2026 10:10 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 01 - Braves

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '57 Hank Aaron Brutally Bad Braves Baseball
3B '99 Chipper Jones The East Coast Comedy Club
OF '67 Hank Aaron Terry, Torre and Tony
OF '34 Wally Berger The East Coast Comedy Club
OF '64 Hank Aaron BMA Braves
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '20 Marcell Ozuna BRA (23-33-73-89-20) VES
OF '69 Hank Aaron Sale of the Century
OF '61 Hank Aaron '61 Braves
OF '65 Hank Aaron Sam Game Braves
OF '33 Wally Berger BRA (23-33-73-89-20) VES
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '95 Greg Maddux 01 Braves 21-42-55-95-12
P '94 Greg Maddux Tom's House
P '01 Vic Willis High Scoring Braves 01 32 53 00 23
P '53 Warren Spahn High Scoring Braves 01 32 53 00 23
P '18 Anibal Sanchez The East Coast Comedy Club

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '97 Greg Maddux LG01: Bigwig's Braves (5 Yrs)
P '18 Jake Northrop LG01: Bigwig's Braves (5 Yrs)
P '68 Pat Jarvis LG01: Bigwig's Braves (5 Yrs)
P '93 Greg Maddux Franchise 01 Braves
P '14 Dick Rudolph Sam Game Braves
8/20/2026 10:10 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 02 - White Sox

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '20 Joe Jackson High Scoring White Sox 20 26 63 90 22
OF '17 Happy Felsch How Do You Spell Pierzynski?
1B '92 Frank Thomas "Cartwright"
1B '20 Jose Abreu LG02: Bigwig's White Sox (5 Yrs)
1B '94 Frank Thomas 11, 47, 56, 94, 10
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '33 Al Simmons 06-33-67-81-14 White Sox
1B '72 Dick Allen WHITE (04-41-72-98-06) SOX
OF '16 Joe Jackson Felsch? From Cranston??
OF '03 Magglio Ordonez The Shyte Sox
OF '39 Mike Kreevich Wish I Had the xx20 Sox
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '10 Ed Walsh Who Left These White Sox?
P '07 Ed Walsh LG02: Bigwig's White Sox (5 Yrs)
P '17 Eddie Cicotte How Do You Spell Pierzynski?
P '11 Ed Walsh 11, 47, 56, 94, 10
P '21 Red Faber Franchise 02 White Sox

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '08 Ed Walsh '54 White Sox
P '04 Frank Owen WHITE (04-41-72-98-06) SOX
P '64 Hoyt Wilhelm Wish I Had the xx20 Sox
P '64 Joe Horlen Wish I Had the xx20 Sox
P '12 Ed Walsh 02 White Sox 12-27-74-00-21
8/20/2026 10:11 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 07 - Reds

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '62 Frank Robinson Riverfront Reds Patrol 22-37-62-87-1
OF '13 Shin-Soo Choo A Pitcher Named Homer?
OF '20 Edd Roush 20-46-74-88-09 Reds
OF '68 Pete Rose Sam Game Reds
OF '74 Pete Rose 20-46-74-88-09 Reds
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '05 Cy Seymour CINCI (05-27-79-79-24) NNATI
OF '77 George Foster 07 Reds 04-35-60-77-17
OF '69 Pete Rose Franchise 07 Reds
1B '17 Joey Votto 07 Reds 04-35-60-77-17
1B '15 Joey Votto Reds but not commies
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '23 Dolf Luque Reds 23-29-56-91-10
P '88 Danny Jackson 20-46-74-88-09 Reds
P '42 Bucky Walters LG07: Bigwig's Reds (5 Yrs)
P '75 Gary Nolan LG07: Bigwig's Reds (5 Yrs)
P '17 Fred Toney The Horror

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '04 Noodles Hahn 07 Reds 04-35-60-77-17
P '24 Eppa Rixey White Queen Rose & Bubbles
P '77 Tom Seaver 07 Reds 04-35-60-77-17
P '25 Dolf Luque not much of the machine
P '24 Jakob Junis CINCI (05-27-79-79-24) NNATI
8/20/2026 10:13 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 08 - Red Sox

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '49 Ted Williams LG08: Bigwig's Red Sox (5 Yrs)
OF '41 Ted Williams A Boston Potpourri
OF '47 Ted Williams Random Red Sox
OF '46 Ted Williams Sam Game Red Sox
OF '55 Ted Williams 16-50-55-88-03 Red Sox
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '14 Tris Speaker RED (14-38-54-90-10) SOX
OF '12 Tris Speaker Manny, Mo & Ted
OF '42 Ted Williams the royal rooters
OF '48 Ted Williams Babe's Cursed Red Sox 19 48 73 95 24
OF '10 Tris Speaker Franchise 08 Red Sox
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '00 Pedro Martinez Cys Matters
P '07 Cy Young Cys Matters
P '18 Chris Sale 08 Red Sox 02-43-57-85-18
P '02 Derek Lowe Random Red Sox
P '02 Cy Young 08 Red Sox 02-43-57-85-18

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '14 Dutch Leonard RED (14-38-54-90-10) SOX
P '19 Carl Mays Babe's Cursed Red Sox 19 48 73 95 24
P '01 Cy Young How Do You Spell Schreckengost?
P '14 Ernie Shore RED (14-38-54-90-10) SOX
P '07 Jonathan Papelbon Pedro y Papi 15-37-67-99-07
8/20/2026 10:14 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 09 - Cubs

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '01 Sammy Sosa 09 Cubs 20-37-64-76-01
OF '28 Hack Wilson 07-28-60-90-17 Cubs
OF '29 Hack Wilson Sam Game Cubs
1B '45 Phil Cavarretta Cubs 12-45-59-84-24
2B '84 Ryne Sandberg Cubs 12-45-59-84-24
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '43 Bill Nicholson CUB (11-43-69-85-20) BIES
OF '30 Hack Wilson we will have to be lovable
OF '70 Billy Williams 25 or 6 to 4
1B '16 Anthony Rizzo Orphaned Cubs 02 26 55 87 16
OF '65 Billy Williams The Scrubs
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '23 Pete Alexander Sam Game Cubs
P '08 Mordecai Brown TinkertoEverstoRizzo
P '03 Jack Taylor LG09: Bigwig's Cubs (5 Yrs)
P '64 Larry Jackson 09 Cubs 20-37-64-76-01
P '06 Mordecai Brown Franchise 09 Cubs

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '02 Jack Taylor Orphaned Cubs 02 26 55 87 16
P '19 Pete Alexander The Scrubs
P '09 Mordecai Brown 25 or 6 to 4
P '10 Mordecai Brown Calamitous Cubbies
P '25 Brad Keller 25 or 6 to 4
8/20/2026 10:14 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 10 - Yankees

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '27 Babe Ruth Bombs Away!
OF '56 Mickey Mantle Yogi's Yankees OF Icons
1B '27 Lou Gehrig Bombs Away!
OF '23 Babe Ruth I tried to draft range. will it help?
OF '31 Babe Ruth Yucky Yankees
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '26 Babe Ruth Baby Ruth loves M&Ms
OF '30 Babe Ruth 10 Yankees 25-30-57-00-11
OF '37 Joe Dimaggio '60 Yankees
OF '24 Babe Ruth Franchise 10 Yankees
OF '58 Mickey Mantle Pitching Heavy Yanks 22 43 58 99 14
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '10 Russ Ford LG10: Bigwig's Yankees (5 Yrs)
P '04 Jack Chesbro 04-29-69-97-07 Yankees
P '72 Steve Kline YAN (20-36-72-79-05) KEES
P '14 Ray Caldwell Bombs Away!
P '39 Marius Russo Yogi's Yankees OF Icons

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '58 Whitey Ford Pitching Heavy Yanks 22 43 58 99 14
P '43 Spud Chandler Pitching Heavy Yanks 22 43 58 99 14
P '46 Spud Chandler Southpaw Stoppers?
P '37 Lefty Gomez '60 Yankees
P '11 Russ Ford '60 Yankees
8/20/2026 10:15 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 12 - Athletics

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
1B '32 Jimmie Foxx 5 Seasons A's Disaster
OF '25 Al Simmons "A" is for Abysmal
1B '34 Jimmie Foxx Those Lazy Hazy Crazy A's of Summer
OF '30 Al Simmons 12 Athletics 03-30-62-95-19
1B '35 Jimmie Foxx Foxx Mulder in “The A-Files”
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '81 Rickey Henderson let the midget hit
1B '33 Jimmie Foxx '70 A's
OF '29 Al Simmons Franchise 12 Athletics
OF '27 Al Simmons Sam Game Athletics
OF '33 Bob Johnson '70 A's
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '05 Rube Waddell Mostly Pitching A's 05 31 66 96 08
P '32 Lefty Grove 5 Seasons A's Disaster
P '90 Dennis Eckersley "A" is for Abysmal
P '07 Joe Blanton 5 Seasons A's Disaster
P '90 Dave Stewart "A" is for Abysmal

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '04 Rube Waddell Band-O Bargain Basement A's
P '02 Rube Waddell Mr.October's Athletic Nap
P '09 Chief Bender ATHL (09-26-55-77-13) ETICS
P '10 Chief Bender '70 A's
P '71 Vida Blue Band-O Bargain Basement A's
8/20/2026 10:16 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
League 13 - Giants

Most Valuable Player - NL
Pos Name Team
OF '01 Barry Bonds Gibberish Giants
OF '58 Willie Mays Carl Hubbell's Giants 24 33 58 78 21
OF '93 Barry Bonds In the Eyre Tonight
OF '02 Barry Bonds Sam Game Giants
OF '04 Barry Bonds 13 Giants 21-50-59-92-04
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Most Valuable Player - AL
Pos Name Team
OF '57 Willie Mays '57 Giants
1B '69 Willie McCovey GIA (23-47-69-89-11) NTS
1B '30 Bill Terry Franchise 13 Giants
OF '54 Willie Mays Joe McGinnity not Tony Stark
OF '29 Mel Ott '57 Giants
* minimum 3.1 plate appearances/game average
* minimum of 4.5 innings played/game average

Cy Young Award - NL
Pos Name Team
P '33 Carl Hubbell Carl Hubbell's Giants 24 33 58 78 21
P '36 Carl Hubbell In the Eyre Tonight
P '07 Christy Mathewson Gibberish Giants
P '68 Gaylord Perry Gibberish Giants
P '18 Fred Toney Sam Game Giants

Cy Young Award - AL
Pos Name Team
P '08 Christy Mathewson Get Christy Mathewson
P '04 Joe McGinnity Joe McGinnity not Tony Stark
P '05 Christy Mathewson '57 Giants
P '09 Christy Mathewson Barry, Harry & Larry
P '12 Jeff Tesreau Franchise 13 Giants
8/20/2026 10:16 AM
schwarze
Posts: 49352 (1)
Hall of Famer
1904 74 4 1 1
Hall of Famer
Leagues 14, 15 and 16 will be added when those regular seasons are completed.
8/20/2026 10:17 AM
MVP & Cy Young Award Winners, Draft Tournament Topic
△Top△Bottom

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.