500 HR League - Need 1 Topic

We are finishing up season 19 of an ongoing theme league built around the MLB players who hit 500 HR. We need 2 new owners to join us for season 20.

The basic premise is this: we are replaying the careers of each of the 28 members of the 500 HR club. To make the math work out and allow us to play 24 full seasons of this theme, we added Fred McGriff to the pool.

We progress our 500-HR hitters one season at a time. In each season we will use 24 of the 29 players, so not every player is used in every season of this league, but we will ultimately play every season of these player's career. Each season we do a random draw to assign each hitter to each owner. You might get 73 Schmidt in season 1, 87 Palmeiro in season 2, 28 Ott in season 3, etc. You must use that exact season of your HR hitter’s career, but you may TWIST any of his actual teammates from that season. If your HR hitter played for multiple teams in that season, you may choose which team you want to twist, but you MUST use the combined version of your HR hitter who is allocated to the team you choose. For example, if in season 23 you draw 1972 Willie Mays, you may choose to twist either his 72 Giants teammates or his 72 Mets teammates, not both. And whichever you choose, you must use the combined 1972 Mays version from that team. No $200K exceptions. All players on your roster must have appeared on your team as verified by baseball-reference.com. The only exception to this rule will be if a team has fewer than 25 players who have any WIS-eligible seasons.

The cap is 100M, with no AAA, and we do use the DH. The DH is essential for this league, especially for the modern players who often had seasons in which they played mostly or entirely DH. To avoid fatigue death spirals, which massively distort both stats and pennant races, you must roster AT LEAST 1300 IP for your pitching staff.

PLEASE NOTE: We have a few days left in season 19, so there will not be a league number until our current regular season is complete. However, once we have a league number, as with all of my leagues, there are strict deadlines for getting rosters entered. I have no patience with needing to chase people down to get their teams in, and it's not fair to other owners if 1 or 2 stragglers are holding us up. Please only join this league if you are comfortable with your ability to build and enter a team quickly once a league number has been generated.

Owners are not obligated to play all 24 seasons. Come and go as you wish.


All teams will use WIS Park each season. My goal for this league is to see how each player does without WIS’s sometimes extreme park effects impacting the results.

FATGUYRD BONUS PRIZE EACH SEASON: each season, before we do the random draw to assign players, I will announce a challenge for that season. This could be something like "most doubles hit by a team" or "most strikeouts by your pitching staff" or "fewest errors by a team," etc. Each season, I will donate the commissioner's WIS reward money to the owner who wins the challenge. This gives everyone something else to play for, which might be a lot of fun in those seasons when you know your team is just not gonna be good enough to win the championship. We named this award in honor our late friend Fatguyrd who was a mainstay of WIS, and this league, for many years. For this upcoming season, the bonus prize will go to team with the most combined doubles and triples.

A very important note:
The primary purpose of this league is to replay the careers of these 29 great players; winning any individual league is a secondary consideration. Each season, each owner is expected to accept his random player allocation without whining, and to use his 500 HR player realistically. You are required to get your 500HR player at least 95% of his actual PA/162. Failure to do this will incur a 10-win penalty in the standings.
11/2/2026 1:47 PM
1.) contrarian23
2.) 84champs
3.) jbar8888
4.) busterglen
5.) odalisgagne
6.) mensu1954
7.) SteveIzzy
8.) coachgreat1
9.) tywebb3
10.) keth
11.) ff09
12.) redcped
13.) pmars2001
14.) akira_hokuto
15.) jfranco77
16.) Rattlers
17.) stroh23
18.) redwingscup
19.) chewy3344
20.) SAKABAKBRG
21.) cstrohmier
22.) totalpkg504
23.) dhomard

Season 20 sitemail list: contrarian23; 84champs; jbar8888; busterglen; odalisgagne; mensu1954; SteveIzzy; coachgreat1; tywebb3; keth; ff09; redcped; pmars2001; akira_hokuto; jfranco77; Rattlers; stroh23; redwingscup; chewy3344; SAKABAKBRG; cstrohmier; totalpkg504; dhomard
11/2/2026 9:50 PM (edited)
This league is a ton of fun, almost always highly competitive, and we're seeing a bunch of these players approaching significant career HR totals.
11/2/2026 1:52 PM
I have been terrible in this league so far. Let’s continue it for another season.
11/2/2026 7:51 PM
just need 1 more!
11/2/2026 9:50 PM
I know there's another owner out there who wants to join us...you'll have the chance to manage one of these players in season 20:
Aaron 72
Cabrera 19
Foxx 41
Griffey 06
Jackson 83
Killebrew 73
Mantle 64
Mays 69
McCovey 76
McGriff 02
Murray 93
Ortiz 12
Ott 42
Palmeiro 01
Pujols 20
Ramirez 06
Robinson 72
Rodriguez 13
Ruth 31
Schmidt 87
Sheffield 05
Thomas 04
Thome 08
Williams 56


Some great seasons in there and some excellent twist potential!!
11/3/2026 11:29 AM
500 HR League - Need 1 Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.