I added some round 1 stats to the "original sound off thread". I am opening a new thread for round 2 sound off topics.
10/21/2026 2:56 PM
As was the case for the previous Franchise Draft Tournament, I expect to see some huge falloffs for successful round 1 teams as well as round 1 MVP and Cy Young players. I will provide one early season example below. (I have linked all the round 1 leagues to the Cardinals/Yankees round 2 league).

My round 1 Reds team
94-68 (best in league)
.591 exp winning% (best in league)
Lost 4-1 in World Series to 78-84 team
'24 Eppa Rixey 25-8, 3.57 ERA, Cy Young Winner

My round 2 Reds team
Started 0-10
Currently 10-19
'24 Eppa Rixey 0-5, 6.38 ERA
10/21/2026 3:02 PM
Don't you just love it when it seems like all your teams tank at the same time? For example...

Cardinals. Started 14-5, Recent 4-8
Cubs: Started 14-7, Recent 3-7
White Sox: Started 9-10, Recent 3-9
Dodgers: Started 14-6, Recent 3-8
Athletics: Started 13-6, Recent 4-8
Phillies: Started 13-11, Recent 0-7
Twins: Started 15-11, Recent 1-4
Reds: Started 9-13, Recent 1-8
Braves: Started 13-11, Recent 2-5

Totals: Started 114-80, Recent 21-64
In aggregate, these teams started out on a pace to go 95-67 (on avg). Since then, they are on pace to go 47-115. Fun times.
10/22/2026 9:07 AM
My 14 teams went from +20 (wins minus losses) to -10 in 3 days. Just a brutal stretch
10/23/2026 1:01 PM
Posted by schwarze on 10/23/2026 1:01:00 PM (view original):
My 14 teams went from +20 (wins minus losses) to -10 in 3 days. Just a brutal stretch
That's a 48-78 run for those keeping score at home. Nine straight losing sessions.
10/23/2026 2:11 PM
I am going to be comparing the round 1 and round 2 results of my first round picks here. Round 2 is thru 40 games. 86 game update added.

Cardinals
1907 Ed Karger
Round 1: 46 GS, 347 IP, 22-15, 4.04 ERA, 2nd in Cy Young for a 100-62 team (1st place). Grade A
Round 2: 13 GS, 94 IP, 10-1, 3.56 ERA, 1st in Cy Young for a 24-16 team (1st place). Grade A+
Thru 86 G: 26 GS, 177 IP, 13-4, 4.84 ERA, 3rd in Cy Young for a 54-32 team (1st place). Grade A

Yankees
1904 Jack Chesbro
Round 1: 73 GS, 462 IP, 32-21, 4.69 ERA, Wins Cy Young for a 91-71 team (1st place). Grade A
Round 2: 16 GS, 122 IP, 10-2, 2.66 ERA, 1st in Cy Young for a 24-16 team (1st place), Grade A+
Thru 86 G: 37 GS, 257 IP, 19-6, 3.44 ERA (3rd), 1st in Cy Young for a 45-41 team (3rd place), Grade A+

Giants
1907 Christry Mathewson
Round 1: 49 GS, 352 IP, 28-14, 3.27 ERA, Wins Cy Young for a 97-65 team (1st place). Grade A+
Round 2: 12 GS, 89 IP, 5-4, 3.83 ERA for a 21-18 team (3rd place). Grade C+
Thru 86G: 25 GS, 188 IP, 14-4, 3.64 ERA, 3rd in Cy Young for a 52-34 team (1st place). Grade A+

Cubs
1902 Jack Taylor
Round 1: 55 GS, 407 IP, 29-13, 3.56 ERA, 3rd in Cy Young for a 85-77 team (1st place). Grade A
Round 2: 13 GS, 92 IP, 5-5, 3.82 ERA for a 25-15 team. Grade B
Thru 86G: 28 GS, 210 IP, 12-10, 2.91 ERA (5th), 3rd in Cy Young for a 52-34 team (1st place). Grade A-

White Sox
1911 Ed Walsh
Round 1: 63 GS, 436 IP, 25-21, 3.79 ERA, 2nd in Cy Young for a 83-79 team (3rd place). Grade A-
Round 2: 14 GS, 6-8, 3.71 ERA for a 16-24 team (last place). Grade C
Thru 86G: 32 GS, 232 IP, 14-16, 3.50 ERA for a 38-48 team (last place). Grade C

Dodgers
1907 Kaiser Wilhelm
Round 1: 43 GS, 291 IP, 17-19, 5.32 ERA for a 82-80 team (1st place). Grade C-
Round 2: 10 GS, 69 IP, 3-4, 3.80 ERA for a 22-18 team (3rd place). Grade C+
Thru 86G: 23 GS, 162 IP, 11-5, 3.84 ERA, 3rd in Cy Young for a 51-35 team (1st place). Grade A-

Athletics
1908 Eddie Plank
Round 1: 43 GS, 280 IP, 22-12, 3.99 ERA, 4th in Cy Young for a 93-69 team (1st place). Grade A
Round 2: 11 GS, 71 IP, 4-3, 3.80 ERA for a 18-22 team (4th place). Grade B-
Thru 86G: 23 GS, 149 IP, 9-6, 3.51 ERA, 4th in Cy Young for a 40-46 team (5th place). Grade B+

Phillies
1917 Pete Alexander
Round 1: 57 GS, 427 IP, 28-14, 3.61 ERA, 2nd in Cy Young for a 88-74 team (2nd place). Grade A
Round 2: 14 GS, 101 IP, 5-4, 4.19 ERA for a 15-25 team (last place). Grade B-
Thru 86G: 31 GS, 223 IP, 10-11, 4.59 ERA for a 37-49 team (5th place). Grade C-

Indians
1909 Addie Joss
Round 1: 39 GS, 257 IP, 16-12, 4.21 ERA for a 89-73 team (1st place). Grade B-
Round 2: 9 GS, 62 IP, 6-1, 3.06 ERA, 2nd in Cy Young for a 21-19 team (3rd place). Grade A+
Thru 86G: 20 GS, 135 IP, 13-3, 3.74 ERA (2nd), 1st in Cy Young for a 45-41 team (3rd place). Grade A+

Twins
1968 Dean Chance
Round 1: 46 GS, 320 IP, 24-12, 3.66 ERA, 3rd in Cy Young for a 91-71 team (1st place). Grade A+
Round 2: 10 GS, 73 IP, 6-2, 1.49 ERA, 2nd in Cy Young for a 20-20 team (3rd place). Grade A+
Thru 86G: 24 GS, 175 IP, 14-7, 1.95 ERA (1st), 2nd in Cy Young for a 45-41 team (3rd place). Grade A+

Reds
1993 Jose Rijo 1924 Eppa Rixey
Rijo was drafted so I would get an early round 2 pick. I selected 1924 Reds and since Rijo sucked, I am listing '24 Eppa Rixey instead.
Round 1: 41 GS, 272 IP, 25-8, 3.57 ERA for a 94-68 team (1st place). Grade A+
Round 2: 10 GS, 61 IP, 0-6, 6.53 ERA for a 14-26 team (last place). Grade F
Thru 86G: 21 GS, 128 IP, 4-11, 5.91 ERA for a 35-51 team (last place). Grade D-

Tigers
1944 Dizzy Trout
Round 1: 54 GS, 346 IP, 15-27, 4.74 ERA for a 84-78 team (3rd place). Grade D
Round 2: 14 GS, 93 IP, 4-6, 3.98 ERA for a 17-23 team (5th place).. Grade C
Thru 86G: 30 GS, 203 IP, 12-8, 3.55 ERA (5th), 1st in Cy Young for a 43-43 team (4th place). Grade A

Braves
1919 Art Nehf
Round 1: 47 GS, 337 IP, 23-20, 4.58 ERA for a 86-76 team (2nd place). Grade B-
Round 2: 12 GS, 83 IP, 6-2, 4.45 ERA, 4th in Cy Young for a 20-20 team (4th place). Grade B
Thru 86G: 25 GS, 175 IP, 11-6, 4.57 ERA, 4th in Cy Young for a 42-44 team (4th place). Grade B

Orioles
1904 Harry Howell
Round 1: 46 GS, 355 IP, 27-11, 3.25 ERA, Wins Cy Young for a 98-64 team (1st place). Grade A+
Round 2: 12 GS, 75 IP, 7-4, 5.85 ERA for a 24-16 team (1st place). Grade B-
Thru 86G: 25 GS, 173 IP, 15-6, 3;80 ERA, 2nd in Cy Young for a 54-32 team (1st place). Grade A+
11/9/2026 3:41 PM (edited)
Updated above thread thru 86 games.
11/9/2026 3:41 PM
I'm in 2nd place with 7 of my 11 teams, with 0 teams leading their division. Currently a league-worst 14 wins below expected (though shoutout DarthDurron who is right there with me). Ugh.
11/15/2026 12:10 PM
So, basically what you are saying is.... you are due.
11/15/2026 8:05 PM
I had to do a team-by-team look. I do a rough projection of my team vs others entering the season, so that's what I'm referring to below.


STL
Started with about 25% division odds, co-favorites with schwarze and njbigwig. My team has actually performed about as expected (in fact, slightly above) but this is my unluckiest team at -7 wins (Exp% vs Act%). More importantly, schwarze's team has been a juggernaut with .614 Exp% so it likely wouldn't have mattered.
VERDICT: schwarze crushing it

NYY
Again, started with about 25% division odds, and again as co-favorites with schwarze and njbigwig. In this case, my team has played about as expected and actually have best Exp% in the division but njbigwig is right behind me with better luck. Only 1 game back right now so this one is one of my best hopes at almost 50/50.
VERDICT: about on par

SFG
Tough division with 4 of us between 20-30% division odds. My team has underperformed, while schwarze has both performed much better (.537 vs .497 Exp%) and he has been +6 wins lucky, so this one is out of reach for me.
VERDICT: my underperformance AND schwarze's overperformance/good luck

CHC
Came in as a 36% to 27% division favorite over schwarze and I've actually played over initial projection but schwarze has played well above it. We've caught up recently to close within 2 games so still a shot here albeit as an underdog.
VERDICT: schwarze crushing it

CHW
Started in a dead-heat with njbigwig and we've both played to a near dead-heat (.533 vs .530 Exp%). The difference has been his team being +5.5 wins over Exp% while we're -1.2 games under. Down 7 games, this one is a longshot.
VERDICT: bad close-game luck

LAD
Came in as underdogs, performed a bit below expectation, and redcped and schwarze have been very good. No chance here but mostly because we didn't have the best team.
VERDICT: not a good team

CLE
My worst team this round coming in and it's played out as such. ronthegenius and 3dayrotation have the two best teams and it's playing out as such as they're locked in a pennant race well ahead of the pack.
VERDICT: not a good team

MIN
I had myself as a slight favorite here but with some strong competition. My team has actually overperformed but both jtpsops and nocomm999 have crushed it. We're lucky to be just 1 game back as both of them (-6 wins for nocomm, -2 for jtpsops) have been unlucky in the wins column.
VERDICT: jtp and nocmm crushing it

CIN
League 7 (CIN and DET) was easily my strongest league. CIN was my 2nd-biggest favorite starting at over 50%. Unfortunately for me, thejuice6 has played me to a dead heat so far and holds a 1-game lead. This is currently my best bet to advance at 56%.
VERDICT: juice playing above expectation

DET
This was my biggest favorite at nearly 75% to win the division and we were absolutely cruising for most the season. Then lately the bottom has completely fallen out while both bbondsmvp and kstober have soared, and we now find ourselves in 3rd place. This has been my biggest underperforming team relative to initial expectation, and we've simply been outplayed by bbondsmvp and kstober.
VERDICT: my team underperforming

BAL
Another division where we came in neck and neck with schwarze but find ourselves well behind him. We've overperformed expectation but by less than schwarze and that's been coupled with a 6-win swing in luck (+2.5 for schwarze, -3.5 for us) and that's curtains.
VERDICT: schwarze crushing it

Overall, my preseason expectation across my 11 teams was a .533 rate and our Exp% is EXACTLY .533. Our win% is a bit lower .520 (-15 wins negative luck) so that's part of it. But also we just find ourselves in divisions where we've been outplayed. I still have a shot to advance a team or two but also a distinct possibility we get completely shut out!
11/16/2026 7:01 PM
Thanks for sharing. I've been meaning to do something similar for my teams.
11/18/2026 11:50 AM
I had 14 teams advance to round 2. Here is a quick summary of their round 1 results. I will post current round 2 results in a separate thread.
.
Lg01: Cardinals
Final Record: 100-62, .617 (1st in AL East)
Expected Win%: .655 (1st overall)
Playoff Results: Won World Series
.
Lg02: Yankees
Final Record: 91-71, .562 (1st in NL East)
Expected Win%: .530 (3rd best in NL, 7th overall)
Playoff Results: Won World Series
.
Lg03: Giants
Final Record: 97-65, .599 (1st in AL East)
Expected Win%: .601 (1st overall)
Playoff Results: Lost in LCS
.
Lg05: Cubs
Final Record: 85-77, .525 (1st in NL East)
Expected Win%: .536 (3rd in NL, 5th overall)
Playoff Results: Won World Series
.
Lg06: White Sox
Final Record: 83-79, .512 (1st in AL East)
Expected Win%: .511 (3rd in AL, 7th overall)
Playoff Results: Won World Series
.
Lg07: Dodgers
Final Record: 82-80, .506 (1st in NL East)
Expected Win%: .514 (4th in NL, 7th overall)
Playoff Results: Won World Series
.
Lg08: Athletics
Final Record: 93-69, .574 (1st in NL East)
Expected Win%: .586 (1st in NL, 2nd overall)
Playoff Results: Lost in World Series
.
Lg09: Phillies
Final Record: 88-74, .543 (2nd in NL East)
Expected Win%: .573 (1st overall)
Playoff Results: Missed playoffs
.
Lg10: Indians
Final Record: 89-73, .549 (1st in NL West)
Expected Win%: .532 (Best in NL, 4th overall)
Playoff Results: Lost in LCS
.
Lg12: Twins
Final Record: 91-71, .562 (1st in AL East)
Expected Win%: .539 (1st in AL, 4th overall)
Playoff Results: Won World Series
.
Lg13: Reds
Final Record: 94-68, .580 (1st in AL West)
Expected Win%: .591 (1st overall)
Playoff Results: Lost in World Series
.
Lg14: Tigers
Final Record: 84-78, .519 (3rd in NL West)
Expected Win%: .569 (2nd in NL, 2nd overall)
Playoff Results: Missed playoffs
.
Lg15: Braves
Final Record: 86-76, .531 (2nd in NL East)
Expected Win%: .543 (1st in NL, 4th overall)
Playoff Results: Missed playoffs
.
Lg16: Orioles
Final Record: 98-64, .605 (1st in NL East)
Expected Win%: .636 (1st overall)
Playoff Results: Lost in LCS
11/18/2026 12:50 PM (edited)

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.