Any Questions? Topic

That is a flaw IMO!
10/16/2026 9:22 AM
Thoughts on using high HR/low OAB guys like Bauer and Maeda only on a home field, such as Petco and PalaceOTF and using Joss in a more HR friendly park?

Do you feel the game needs an overhaul? Seems to be getting doubles and triples guys with great range is the way to go? Or can you have the same amount success having good range at SS and CF, with average to poor range at the other positions.
10/20/2026 7:38 PM (edited)
I like good range guys in CF, SS, and 2B. I can live with range and fielding at 1B, 3B, and LF. RF needs some range (c or better). Bigger the field, the more range in OF I need.
10/20/2026 11:23 PM
The_Creeper wrote: One thing I have not seen anyone try is doing like a 4yr skip. Basically (for example..you go from 1920 to 1924 the next year). That basically means you can cover 100yrs in 25 seasons and no one really gets more than 5 seasons of Ruth and you actually may miss on some of the insane seasons depending on when they were. Could even do that as a regressive.

I'm the commish of a league that sort of does this--it's called Grand Slam and each season is technically four seasons. Right now, we are in 1973-1976. We started back in 1885-1888, the brainchild of Razorclams. If you own a player during the specified years, you just pick which one season you want to use. As you said, it's nice because a great player might only last 3 or 4 league seasons, you have to keep restocking.
10/23/2026 9:55 PM
Thanks Heb....RazorHawg just created a new progressive with a 5yr cap on keeping players that may accomplish what I was looking for in that I dont like leagues were a long term superstar gets drafted/locked down for his entire career. This one will force you to reload every couple of years and NOT have ot skip any years...some great owners and Season 1 starts this week.
10/23/2026 10:35 PM
I’ve been playing for years (always around .500!). I have yet to crack the code on the settings in “Team Managerial Style.” I see no impact whatsoever (other than the rest players options). And thoughts?
10/24/2026 9:54 AM
Posted by thewizard37 on 10/20/2026 7:38:00 PM (view original):
Thoughts on using high HR/low OAB guys like Bauer and Maeda only on a home field, such as Petco and PalaceOTF and using Joss in a more HR friendly park?

Do you feel the game needs an overhaul? Seems to be getting doubles and triples guys with great range is the way to go? Or can you have the same amount success having good range at SS and CF, with average to poor range at the other positions.
Because there are so many deadball pitchers in every league, no one drafts home run hitters anymore, which actually makes Maeda and Bauer types the perfect pitchers. They've got incredible value and the HR/9 doesn't matter because no one hits HR anyway. I use them in every park.
10/24/2026 12:19 PM
Posted by jterrell on 10/24/2026 9:54:00 AM (view original):
I’ve been playing for years (always around .500!). I have yet to crack the code on the settings in “Team Managerial Style.” I see no impact whatsoever (other than the rest players options). And thoughts?
I think it would be difficult to see the impact of these settings unless you're using long-term, large-sample analysis and controlling for as many other variables as possible. But they do matter, and I think we can use them to our advantage.

Hit and Run: Use a higher setting if your offense has higher-than-average speed and/or stolen base success rates. Even better with low strikeout rates. This setting can help avoid double plays, gain extra bases when successful, and "manufacture" runs for non-HR teams.
Use a lower setting if your offense is a mix of low-speed, low-SB, high-K. Failed hit-and-run plays lead to more outs on the bases.

Baserunning aggressiveness: Higher when your team speed is higher, lower when your team speed is lower. Speed (the speed score, NOT related to stolen bases) determines if a player is more or less successful when trying to take an extra base. First to third on a single. Score from first on a double, etc. Attempting to take that extra base more frequently when your runners are more likely to succeed makes sense.

Intentional walks: I never want to give a team a free base and cost my pitcher four pitches without recording an out. I set this at 1 for every team.

Pinch-hitting: If you don't have useful pinch-hit options on your bench, there's no reason to have this setting above a 1 or 2. If you have multiple pinch-hit options and a deep enough bullpen, you can be more aggressive with pinch-hitters.

Double-switch: In 20 years I don't think I've ever changed this setting.
10/30/2026 10:23 AM
One thing I dislike about the Hit and Run setting is that the "strike 'em out, them 'em out" happens too often. The engine should have enough baseball smarts to take off the H&R with 2 strikes, with considerations to the catcher's arm and SB success of the runner. Of course, there is never a situation where the engine knows that there are 2 strikes, but that's another issue.
10/30/2026 3:23 PM
Indeed!
10/30/2026 7:02 PM
I agree w/ Skunk on the Intentional BB settings. Too many BBs already, never give anyone a free base.
10/30/2026 9:00 PM
Posted by skunk206 on 10/30/2026 10:23:00 AM (view original):
Posted by jterrell on 10/24/2026 9:54:00 AM (view original):
I’ve been playing for years (always around .500!). I have yet to crack the code on the settings in “Team Managerial Style.” I see no impact whatsoever (other than the rest players options). And thoughts?
I think it would be difficult to see the impact of these settings unless you're using long-term, large-sample analysis and controlling for as many other variables as possible. But they do matter, and I think we can use them to our advantage.

Hit and Run: Use a higher setting if your offense has higher-than-average speed and/or stolen base success rates. Even better with low strikeout rates. This setting can help avoid double plays, gain extra bases when successful, and "manufacture" runs for non-HR teams.
Use a lower setting if your offense is a mix of low-speed, low-SB, high-K. Failed hit-and-run plays lead to more outs on the bases.

Baserunning aggressiveness: Higher when your team speed is higher, lower when your team speed is lower. Speed (the speed score, NOT related to stolen bases) determines if a player is more or less successful when trying to take an extra base. First to third on a single. Score from first on a double, etc. Attempting to take that extra base more frequently when your runners are more likely to succeed makes sense.

Intentional walks: I never want to give a team a free base and cost my pitcher four pitches without recording an out. I set this at 1 for every team.

Pinch-hitting: If you don't have useful pinch-hit options on your bench, there's no reason to have this setting above a 1 or 2. If you have multiple pinch-hit options and a deep enough bullpen, you can be more aggressive with pinch-hitters.

Double-switch: In 20 years I don't think I've ever changed this setting.
thanks Skunk
11/17/2026 1:18 PM
How much is it going to kill me if I play 2025 Juan Soto at 1B? I am in a progressive and I have Buxton, Carroll, Yelich and Soto. Only 1B I have are good defenders with no bat that I would prefer to use as late game defensive subs. If this is a terrible idea then I can move some parts around but this keeps my est offensive team on the field.
11/19/2026 3:37 PM
I have a question about how fatigue plays into waiver wire add/drops. Though I'm thinking about OL's, my question could probably apply to all WW add/drops. If I understand correctly, if you drop a player w/ a fatigue rating of, say, 0% and add a player in the same WW transaction, he comes in not at 0% fatigue but w/ the same PA or IP usage level relative to a full season as the player dropped. Got it. But that's for a direct drop/add transaction. What if you drop a player, then add a replacement player the next day? What if you wait 20 games? 50 games? Same calc? What if you drop three players w/ 100%, 50% and 0% fatigue ratings, respectively, and add three replacement players 10, 20 and 60 games later? How is fatigue calculated across the players you pick up from the waiver wire? Maybe a colossally stupid question but what I'm driving at (as an owner notorious for neglecting my rosters) is whether you can drop badly fatigued players and mitigate the impact on fatigue/usage of the players you pick up to replace them. Not really looking to game the system... or maybe I am, in an above board & transparent way. :-)
11/19/2026 11:07 PM
When you acquire a new player during the season (and this goes for WW and trades), he is assumed to have used up a prorated number of his allocated PA (or pitch count) based on how many games you have already played.

Simple example: at mid season you pick up a guy from the WW whose PA/162 is 200. He is assumed to have used up 100 of his PA, so he has 100 left.

So yes, you can drop badly fatigued players and seriously mitigate the problem.
11/20/2026 6:25 AM
◂ Prev 12345 Next ▸
Any Questions? Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.