Change in how credits are used to purchase teams Topic

Hopefully everyone reads the app announcement, even if you don't plan on using it, because there's also news in there about an upcoming change to how site credits are used.
3/11/2026 6:35 PM
Yup.. cash in your credits soon if you want to avoid paying more than you would expect.
3/11/2026 6:39 PM
Are they saying that, going forward, if I want to purchase a SLB 6-pack for $60, even if I have $60 in credits in my account, I can only apply $30 in credits to the purchase and have to pay the other $30 via credit card?
3/11/2026 9:55 PM
Posted by barracuda3 on 3/11/2026 9:55:00 PM (view original):
Are they saying that, going forward, if I want to purchase a SLB 6-pack for $60, even if I have $60 in credits in my account, I can only apply $30 in credits to the purchase and have to pay the other $30 via credit card?
That's the way I read it.
3/11/2026 10:07 PM
That's not good news...
3/11/2026 10:15 PM
This feels targeted at highly successful owners that have racked up so many credits they never have to buy teams. I really wonder how much those owners actually cost WIS, since they should consider the value those type of owners add. Most of the incredible sim league baseball info in the forums was posted by those type of owners.

I also think this hurts the new owners. Win your first championship and get enough for a free team - except when you check out and have to pay for half. Maybe an annual cap on credits before the 50% discount kicks in would have been a better solution.
3/12/2026 1:02 AM (edited)
That being said, it is promising to see the developments happening. A good app could really help with growth, and the site definitely needs new players. This credit policy is just a bit of a head scratcher unless it’s really costing the website a significant amount of money.
3/12/2026 12:59 AM
"This feels targeted at highly successful owners that have racked up so many credits they never have to buy teams."

It definitely is.

I've been playing and paying WIS since 2004, on this and my previous account.

I've been successful enough these past two years that I've had to pay very little actual money to play the game, and to be honest that's probably why I'm still around.
If they expect me to want to pay actual money for this stagnating game, they'd better give me more than an app, I'm talking about updates that will finally solve the cancer of this game, that is the nauseating redundancy of cookie players.

I have 9 teams sitting in my draft center and enough credits for at least 9 more. I don't play dozens of teams at a time like a lot of owners do, I like to micro-manage everything and study boxscores to keep learning about the game.
Now I will be forced to cash in those credits before the March 24th deadline or lose money.
I don't like to feel forced to do anything.

I agree that the app will probably, hopefully, be *one* way of getting new players, but as soon as they enter an OL and go 42-120 because they get banged up by certain types of owners who abuse the cookie recipe, they'll be gone before their first season is even over.

You want my money, give me updates, it's as simple as that.

I've paid to play MLB, NBA, NFL and NHL throughout the years, and of all these games, which use to be really good and fun when there was regular updates but now totally suck because of the cookie situation and the NBA's "state farm" strategy, only MLB still offer mild interest, mostly thanks to theme leagues.

I don't really see any other options than a dynamic salary system to solve the cookie crisis. But one with the correct formula, that is increase salaries of the most used players but also decrease those of lesser used players.
The only formula ever used in the past was all increase and almost no decrease at all.

This is a major, major change of WIS "account policy update", and unless they offer a better quality product in return, I will not go along with it. The app alone won't cut it for me.
3/12/2026 4:59 AM

You want my money, give me updates, it's as simple as that.

Bingo. My thought exactly. The "Interactive, animated play-by-play with Live GameTracker" might be a nice feature (although I won't know for sure until they release an Android version of the app), but they at the VERY least need to fix the myriad issues with the game that have existed forever before they get much more of my money.
3/12/2026 10:22 AM
Pretty much what BillyM. said. Though for me it isn't about credits or the cost. (I NEVER have many credits as I don't win many divisions, etc.)
It's REALLY ALL about the attitude of this new policy. It's a serious F U to the long term successful owners who make this site even work!!

In short it's a HORRID new decision that will likely mark the beginning of the end of this place!
3/12/2026 4:55 PM (edited)
I only play progressives and don't have that many credits, but as a player who has been around since almost the beginning, this will probably be a last straw for me. It's definitely a serious FU to long time owners who have a ton of credits. There's no real reason to implement this policy except for that reason. There are just too many other games now that continue to get updates like Out of the Park Baseball and others to keep throwing money at a product that hasn't been updated this century.
3/12/2026 7:28 PM
Teams don’t expire in the draft center, and credits don’t buy you anything else. So I just cashed mine in and added 12 more teams to my draft center. It’s my WISC zone, basically. I’m sure it will be frustrating in the future when I accumulate more, but there’s no harm in doing it now with what you have.
3/12/2026 7:36 PM
I have no idea what this company is doing w/ this new credit rule. I spent $ on this site for years buying 6 packs and the occasional single team. I plan my days around the sim times. Finally last year I won credits in contrarian's World Series tournament plus a few prog teams that I had were all good at the same time...so for the first time ever, I got two six packs without having to pay a dime. That was something I had looked forward to for years.

Now that's illegal? That's hogwash.
3/12/2026 11:30 PM
Completely Agree with that Coach!
3/13/2026 12:02 AM
I think this is a big mistake by the new management. I'm sure they've looked at the financials and discovered that many long-time owners on the site haven't paid them a dime for years, but the site is going to dry up because a good percentage of those owners aren't going to start spending hundreds of dollars a year on something they've been getting for free. Without big upgrades combined with a major advertising campaign, I think the baseball part of the site will be in trouble. I can't speak for the other games but I'd imagine it's similar there as well.

It's also a very bad sign that they've buried this announcement at the bottom of another announcement, a lot of people aren't going to realize this even happened until it's too late to redeem their credits at 100% and be really mad and not pay another dime on principle.
3/13/2026 8:14 AM
12 Next ▸
Change in how credits are used to purchase teams Topic

Search Criteria

Terms of Use Customer Support Privacy Statement

© 1999-2026 WhatIfSports.com, Inc. All rights reserved. WhatIfSports is a trademark of WhatIfSports.com, Inc. SimLeague, SimMatchup and iSimNow are trademarks or registered trademarks of Electronic Arts, Inc. Used under license. The names of actual companies and products mentioned herein may be the trademarks of their respective owners.